Soil drying legacy does not affect phenanthrene fate in soil but modifies bacterial community response

Abstract

Alteration of the structure of soil microbial communities following the elimination of hydrophobic organic pollutants (e.g., polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, PAHs) is generally assessed using DNA-based techniques, and soil is often required to dry prior to pollutant addition, to facilitate a better mix when establishing microcosms. However, the drying practice may have a legacy effect on soil microbial community structure, which would in turn influence the biodegradation process. Here, we used 14C-labeled phenanthrene to examine the potential side effects of precedent short-term drought events. The results indicate that the drying practice had legacy effects on soil microbial community structure, illustrated by irreversible shifts in the communities. The legacy effects had no significant impact on phenanthrene mineralization and non-extractable residue formation. However, they altered the response of bacterial communities to PAH degradation, leading to a decrease in the abundance of potential PAH degradation genes plausibly attributed to moderately abundant taxa. Based on a comparison of the varied effects of different drying intensity levels, an accurate description of microbial responses to phenanthrene degradation strongly relies on the establishment of stable microbial communities before PAH amendment. Concurrent alterations in the communities resulting from environmental perturbation could greatly mask minor alterations from the degradation of recalcitrant hydrophobic PAH. In practice, to minimize the legacy effects, a soil equilibration step with a reduced drying intensity is indispensable.