Rural Road Assessment Method for Sustainable Territorial Development

Abstract

In Latin America, initiatives have been advocated for developing rural roads that facilitate optimal conditions free from dust, mud, and noise. The criteria for assessing public investment do not align with the requirements of rural infrastructure. Indeed, in rural areas, the territorial conditions such as openness to rural–urban markets, access to education and health, environmental protection, culture, and identity are more important than transportation times or traffic volume. Hence, a multicriteria evaluation method is proposed to prioritize the rural road improvements and maximize their contribution to sustainable territorial development. The roads with the highest sustainable contribution are optimized using a multi-objective decision-making analysis and prioritized based on a Manhattan distance. In addition, a fuzzy cognitive map analyzes the dynamic behavior of the optimal roads. Based on this proposal, a case study is applied where fifteen roads are selected from a sample of 101 in the Araucanía Region, Chile. For this, 16 evaluation criteria, 27 indicators, and sustainability’s social, environmental, technical, and economic dimensions are considered. The results detect reduced one-dimensional contributions despite identifying 15 optimal roads that collectively enhance sustainability. Two roads stand out for their long-term sustainability contribution, which are influenced by economic criteria of zonal productivity, tourism, and road maintenance. Thus, this method can help public agencies rank the roads that must be the subject of development projects.