Peer review declaration

Abstract

All papers published in this volume of IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science have been peer reviewed through processes administered by the Editors. Reviews were conducted by expert referees to the professional and scientific standards expected of a proceedings journal published by IOP Publishing.• Type of peer review: For validating scientific and technical research of paper submitted to IOP, we already did single-blind review, that is reviewers know the identity of authors, but authors do not know the identity of reviewers. By keeping reviewers anonymous allows us to critique work without being influenced by authors. Authors cannot contact the reviewer since they do not know who they are.The review process carried out on the papers submitted to the Sustainable Island Development Initiatives - International Conference 2019 (SIDI-IC 2019) has been organized in a common manner as conducted by most conference organizers, as follows:1. Each paper has been peer reviewed by two reviewers.2. A paper is accepted for publication if the two corresponding reviewers give the confirmation of the acceptance.3. For the case where one reviewer gives the confirmation of accepted the paper, but the other reviewer does not give the confirmation of accepted the paper, then a third reviewer is assigned to review. The final decision is in accordance with the confirmation of the third reviewer whether the paper was accepted or rejected.4. The committee of the SIDI-IC 2019 has then documented the papers which were accepted and rejected for publications at IOP EES.5. The papers accepted for publication were then sent back to the corresponding authors for revisions in accordance with the comments and requirements of the corresponding peer reviewers.6. The papers that have been revised by the authors were then sent back to the committee to be processed for final editing by the assigned SIDI-IC 2019 paper editors.7. Finally, all the papers that have been completely checked and edited were compiled and submitted to IOP EES.• Conference submission management system: 1st SIDI International Conference 2019 used Microsoft Conference Management Toolkit (https://cmt3.research.microsoft.com/) as conference submission management system• Number of submissions received: 93.• Number of submissions sent for review: 93.• Number of submissions accepted: 71.• Acceptance Rate (Number of Submissions Accepted / Number of Submissions Received X 100): Acceptance rate = 71/93 x 100% = 76.3%• Average number of reviews per paper: Average number of reviews per paper are 2.• Total number of reviewers involved: Total number of reviewers involved are 24.• Any additional info on review process: -• Contact person for queries: Prof. Eko B Djatmiko – Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember, Indonesia