On Corrective Justice and Rights in Property

Abstract

In this Review, I hope to critique specific parts of Property Law and Social Morality that fairly represent these various reactions. In Part I, I explain the basis for my first cheer, and situate Property Law and Social Morality in relation to other prominent moral theories of property. In Part II, I study one representative example confirming my second cheer about Gerhart’s cross-pollination experiment—his critique of economic “evolutionary” or “Demsetzian” accounts of property in chapter 4.8 In Part III, I offer what I hope is a friendly amendment to Property Law and Social Morality, to clarify several possible confusions about the scope of “corrective justice.” In Part IV, I turn to my friendly disagreements.