Multivariate Methods for Clustered Binary Data with Multiple Subclasses, with Application to Binary Longitudinal Data

Abstract

Clustered binary data occur frequently in biostatistical work. Several approaches have been proposed for the analysis of clustered binary data. In Rosner (1984, Biometrics 40, 1025-1035), a polychotomous logistic regression model was proposed that is a generalization of the beta-binomial distribution and allows for unit- and subunit-specific covariates, while controlling for clustering effects. One assumption of this model is that all pairs of subunits within a cluster are equally correlated. This is appropriate for ophthalmologic work where clusters are generally of size 2, but may be inappropriate for larger cluster sizes. A beta-binomial mixture model is introduced to allow for multiple subclasses within a cluster and to estimate odds ratios relating outcomes for pairs of subunits within a subclass as well as in different subclasses. To include covariates, an extension of the polychotomous logistic regression model is proposed, which allows one to estimate effects of unit-, class-, and subunit-specific covariates, while controlling for clustering using the beta-binomial mixture model. This model is applied to the analysis of respiratory symptom data in children collected over a 14-year period in East Boston, Massachusetts, in relation to maternal and child smoking, where the unit is the child and symptom history is divided into early-adolescent and late-adolescent symptom experience.