Medial helical versus straight lateral plating of distal femoral fractures—a biomechanical comparative study

Abstract

BackgroundDistal femoral fractures are commonly treated with lateral straight plates. However, the lateral approach may not always be desirable, and 180°-helical plates may be an alternative. AimTo investigate the biomechanical competence of 180°-helical plating versus standard straight lateral plating of unstable fractures at the distal femur. MethodsTwelve left artificial femora were instrumented with a 15-hole Locking Compression Plate–Distal Femur, using either 180°-helical plates (group 1) or conventional straight lateral plates (group 2). An unstable distal femoral fracture AO/OTA 33-A3.3 was simulated. All specimens were biomechanically tested under quasi-static and progressively increasing combined cyclic axial and torsional loading in internal rotation until failure. FindingsInitial axial stiffness (N/mm) was significantly higher in group 1 (185.6 ± 50.1) compared to group 2 (56.0 ± 14.4), p < 0.001. Group 1 demonstrated significantly higher initial interfragmentary flexion (°) and significantly lower initial varus/valgus deformation (°) under 500 N static axial compression versus group 2 (2.76 ± 1.02 versus 0.87 ± 0.77 and 4.08 ± 1.49 versus 6.60 ± 0.47), p ≤ 0.005. Shear displacement (mm) under 6 Nm static torsion was significantly higher in group 1 versus group 2 in both internal (1.23 ± 0.28 versus 0.40 ± 0.42) and external (1.21 ± 0.40 versus 0.57 ± 0.33) rotation, p ≤ 0.013. Cycles to failure and failure load (N) (clinical/catastrophic) were significantly higher in group 1 (12,484 ± 2116/13,752 ± 1518 and 1748.4 ± 211.6/1875.2 ± 151.8) compared to group 2 (7853 ± 1262/9727 ± 836 and 1285.3 ± 126.2/1472.7 ± 83.6), p ≤ 0.001. InterpretationAlthough 180°-helical plating using a pre-contoured standard straight lateral plate was associated with higher shear and flexion movements, it demonstrated improved initial axial stability and resistance against varus/valgus deformation compared to straight lateral plating. Moreover, the helical plates were associated with significantly higher endurance to failure. From a biomechanical perspective, 180°-helical plating may be considered as a valuable alternative to standard straight lateral plating of unstable distal femoral fractures.