HELICAL VERSUS STRAIGHT PLATING OF PROXIMAL THIRD HUMERAL SHAFT FRACTURES - A BIOMECHANICAL STUDY

Abstract

Proximal humeral shaft fractures are commonly treated with long straight locking plates endangering the radial nerve distally. The aim of this study was to investigate the biomechanical competence in a human cadaveric bone model of 90°-helical PHILOS plates versus conventional straight PHILOS plates in proximal third comminuted humeral shaft fractures.Eight pairs of humeral cadaveric humeri were instrumented using either a long 90°-helical plate (group1) or a straight long PHILOS plate (group2). An unstable proximal humeral shaft fracture was simulated by means of an osteotomy maintaining a gap of 5cm. All specimens were tested under quasi-static loading in axial compression, internal and external rotation as well as bending in 4 directions. Subsequently, progressively increasing internal rotational loading until failure was applied and interfragmentary movements were monitored by means of optical motion tracking.Flexion/extension deformation (°) in group1 was (2.00±1.77) and (0.88±1.12) in group2, p=0.003. Varus/valgus deformation (°) was (6.14±1.58) in group1 and (6.16±0.73) in group2, p=0.976. Shear (mm) and displacement (°) under torsional load were (1.40±0.63 and 8.96±0.46) in group1 and (1.12±0.61 and 9.02±0.48) in group2, p≥0.390. However, during cyclic testing shear and torsional displacements and torsion were both significantly higher in group 1, p≤0.038. Cycles to catastrophic failure were (9960±1967) in group1 and (9234±1566) in group2, p=0.24.Although 90°-helical plating was associated with improved resistance against varus/valgus deformation, it demonstrated lower resistance to flexion/extension and internal rotation as well as higher flexion/extension, torsional and shear movements compared to straight plates. From a biomechanical perspective, 90°-helical plates performed inferior compared to straight plates and alternative helical plate designs with lower twist should be investigated in future paired cadaveric studies.