Abstract
Recent studies have shown how MEG can reveal spatial patterns of functional connectivity using frequency-specific oscillatory coupling measures and that these may be modified in disease. However, there is a need to understand both how repeatable these patterns are across participants and how these measures relate to the moment-to-moment variability (or ‘irregularity) of neural activity seen in healthy brain function. In this study, we used Multi-scale Rank-Vector Entropy (MRVE) to calculate the dynamic timecourses of signal variability over a range of temporal scales. The correlation of MRVE timecourses was then used to detect functional connections in resting state MEG recordings that were robust over 183 participants and varied with temporal scale. We compared these MRVE connectivity patterns to those derived using the more conventional method of oscillatory amplitude envelope correlation (AEC) using methods designed to quantify the consistency of these patterns across participants. Using AEC, the most consistent connectivity patterns, across the cohort, were seen in the alpha and beta frequency bands. At fine temporal scales (corresponding to ‘scale frequencies, fS = 30-150Hz), MRVE correlation detected mostly occipital and parietal connections. These showed high similarity with the networks identified by AEC in the alpha and beta frequency bands. The most consistent connectivity profiles between participants were given by MRVE correlation at fS = 75Hz and AEC in the beta band. The physiological relevance of MRVE was also investigated by examining the relationship between connectivity strength and local variability. It was found that local activity at frequencies fS≳ 10Hz becomes more regular when a region exhibits high levels of resting state connectivity, as measured by fine scale MRVE correlation (fS∼ 30-150Hz) and by alpha and beta band AEC. Analysis of the EOG recordings also revealed that eye movement affected both connectivity measures. Higher levels of eye movement were associated with stronger frontal connectivity, as measured by MRVE correlation. More eye movement was also associated with reduced occipital and parietal connectivity strength for both connectivity measures, although this was not significant after correction for multiple comparisons.
Highlights
In recent years, MEG has revealed much about the electrophysiological underpinnings of connectivity in the brain
Multi-scale Rank-Vector Entropy (MRVE) correlation was used to measure functional connectivity and we assessed which of these connections were consistently among the strongest across subjects
We investigated whether MRVE correlation could provide additional information about functional connectivity beyond that provided by amplitude envelope correlation (AEC) analysis
Summary
MEG has revealed much about the electrophysiological underpinnings of connectivity in the brain. To be clinically useful, connectivity research must progress from group-level analysis to the characterisation of individual subjects. To make meaningful comparisons between connectivity profiles of individuals, robust connectivity measures are needed that give consistent results for subjects with the same pathology. Several recent studies have found that many commonly used techniques for measuring functional connectivity in MEG lack repeatability between healthy subjects, and even show inconsistency over repeated scans of the same subject (Colclough et al, 2016; Liuzzi et al, 2017; Wens et al, 2014). Colclough et al (2016) found that the method that gave the most consistent connectivity was oscillatory amplitude envelope correlation (AEC), using symmetric orthogonalisation to remove spurious zero-lag correlation between timecourses due to signal leakage (Colclough et al, 2015). The repeatability of connectivity given by any alternative methods could be compared to AEC to assess the
Published Version
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have