Enhancing mathematical function understanding in university students: a comparative study of design thinking vs. traditional teaching methods

Abstract

Mathematical education requires innovative didactic strategies to enhance the understanding and application of mathematical concepts, as traditional teaching methods often lack relevance. This methodology aims to develop a problem-solving scientific approach called design thinking as a strategy for learning mathematics functions. The study was applied to a sample of 138 students of biochemical, biological, and industrial engineering careers attending the first academic cycle at the Faculty of Natural and Exact Sciences of the Particular Technical University of Loja-Ecuador. The methodology uses a quasi-experimental design with a convenience sampling method. All participants were divided into a control group (C, D, K) and an experimental group (P, Q, R). Knowledge, skills, perceptions, and engagement were measured through pretest, posttest, workshop, rubric, project, and survey instruments. The pretest results indicate that both groups had similar knowledge of mathematical functions (pretest mean experimental group: 1.42/2 and mean control group: 1.55/2). Moreover, after applying design thinking strategy to the experimental group, variables questionnaire, project, and workshop show statistical differences (p < 0.001) between groups related to the traditional learning strategy, increasing the experimental group’s score in the project (posttest mean experimental group: 1.62/2 points, and mean control group: 1.65/2). The survey opinion indicates that 53.5% of the experimental group highlighted the project’s development as positively impacting their academic training. In conclusion, problem-solving design thinking using scientific projects as a mathematical function learning strategy contributes to improving the comprehension of polynomial functions and developing mathematical competencies, abilities, and skills to generate tangible solutions for real problems.