Efficacy of three-dimensional arterial spin labeling and how it compares against that of contrast enhanced magnetic resonance imaging in preoperative grading of brain gliomas.

Abstract

To evaluate the efficacy of three-dimensional arterial spin labeling (3D-ASL) imaging in preoperative grading of brain gliomas, and compare the discrepancy between images obtained from 3D-ASL and contrast enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (CE-MRI) in grading of gliomas. Fifty-one patients with brain gliomas received plain MRI, CE-MRI and 3D-ASL scanning before surgery. In 3D-ASL images, the maximum tumor blood flow (TBF) of tumor parenchyma was measured, relative TBF-M and rTBF-WM were calculated. The cases were categorized into "ASL dominant" and "CE dominant" to compare the discrepancy between 3D-ASL and CE-MRI results. Independent samples t test, Mann-Whitney and U test and one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) were performed to test the differences of TBF, rTBF-M and rTBF-WM values among brain gliomas with different grades. Spearman rank correlation analysis was performed to assess the correlation between TBF, rTBF-M, rTBF-WM and glioma grades respectively. To compare the discrepancy between 3D-ASL and CE-MRI results. In high-grade gliomas (HGG) group, TBF, rTBF-M and rTBF-WM values were higher than those in low-grade gliomas (LGG) group (p < .05). Multiple comparison showed TBF and rTBF-WM values were different between grade I and IV gliomas, grade II and IV gliomas (both p < .05), the rTBF-M value was different between grade I and IV gliomas (p < .05). The values of all 3D-ASL derived parameters were positively correlated with gliomas grading (all p < .001). TBF showed highest specificity (89.3%) and rTBF-WM showed highest sensitivity (96.4%) when discriminating LGG and HGG using ROC curve. There were 29 CE dominant cases (23 cases were HGG), 9 ASL dominant cases (4 cases were HGG). CONCLUSION: 3D-ASL is of significance to preoperative grading of brain gliomas and might be more sensitive than CE-MRI in detection of tumor perfusion.