Design characteristics of integrated surveillance of antimicrobial resistance at the human, animal, and environment interfaces

Abstract

Abstract Efforts have been made to strengthen national and global antimicrobial resistance (AMR) surveillance programs by integrating data collection across the human, animal, and environmental sectors. We searched the literature to review published studies reporting the implementation of integrated AMR surveillance approaches, and we identified a total of 96 articles from 36 countries published from 2000 to 2022, which met our inclusion criteria. Standard review protocols were applied in our study. Out of 96 studies, 47 (49%) articles integrated AMR analysis from human and animal (HA) populations, 24 (25%) considered human, animal, and environmental (HAE) samples together, 11 (12%) studies included animal and environment (AE) samples, and 12 (13%) integrated human and environmental (HE) surveillance. Human isolate-based and animal isolate-based surveillance were the most common study designs (38, 52.8%), with the remainder applying human case-based and isolate-based for animal populations (32, 44.4%). Finally, our results demonstrate that AMR studies on E. coli revealed a lower correlation between human and animal AMR prevalence compared to Salmonella spp. and Campylobacter spp. studies. Different aspects of surveillance design were associated with the level of correlation of AMR prevalence between sectors. Our study found that while global efforts for integrated AMR surveillance have increased in the past 10 years, significant variation exists between studies with regard to the epidemiological and laboratory aspects of their surveillance designs. Our findings indicate that to enable the generation of comparable epidemiological data across countries and sectors, there is a need for the development of a global protocol to support the design of surveillance programs that aim to conduct integrated surveillance of AMR.