Crop diversification and digestate application effect on the productivity and efficiency of irrigated winter crop systems

Abstract

Irrigated winter crops can reduce input demands when compared with irrigated summer cropping systems in the Mediterranean area. The sustainability of these systems can be further improved resorting to diverse rotations, but also to fertilisation with digestate, a by-product from anaerobic digestion of organic waste. Post-treatments such as drying and acidifying can improve the fertiliser value of this product. In this study, we compare wheat performance in a three-year full cereal rotation or in a diverse rotation, with pea and canola. Besides, untreated and dried acidified digestates are tested as fertilisers for all crops, comparing to mineral fertilisation at a rate of 140 kg N ha−1 and a control with no fertilisation. To assess productivity and efficiency of the different systems, grain yield and N concentration, N uptake efficiency (NUpE) and water use efficiency (WUE) were determined, along with soil nitrate dynamics and total N at the end of the experiment. Results showed an average wheat yield increase of 1.79 t ha−1 by the last year of the diverse crop rotation rather than the cereal rotation (p < 0.001). Although there was no yield increase in the previous year, wheat after pea showed higher grain N concentration (p < 0.001). However, the NUpE of wheat remained steady due to a higher soil N availability after pea, which suggests that fertilisation can be adjusted. Although wheat WUE increased due to canola and pea precedents (p < 0.001), the cereal rotations should be more adapted to systems with low water availability. Nonetheless, both rotations required about 30% of irrigated water than the typical irrigated summer crops of the Ebro valley region. Fertiliser effect on yields was variable according to the tested crop mainly due to differences in N demand along each growing cycle. Overall, dried acidified digestate application resulted in similar soil nitrate levels than the mineral fertiliser. The diverse rotation raised soil nitrates content compared to the cereal rotation at sowing and harvesting times (p = 0.002 and p < 0.001, respectively). Higher soil nitrate levels were found when associating these two practices, while nitrate levels after mineral fertilisation showed to be less dependent on the implemented rotation. The diverse rotation also raised soil total N at the end of the experiment (p = 0.023). Similarly, the dried acidified digestate application resulted in higher soil total N than mineral fertilisation (p = 0.011). These findings show how these management practices should allow for a chemical fertilisation reduction in irrigated winter crop systems.