Abstract
For original paper, see Rouquette and Najim (IEEE Trans. Signal Process., vol.49, no.1, p.237-45, 2001).The original authors present two high-resolution approaches to estimate two-dimensional (2-D) signal parameters. The first approach decomposes the 2-D estimation problem into two one-dimensional (1-D) ones, estimates the 1-D frequencies with the MEMP method, and then forms correct pairs using a new pairing scheme introduced in Vanpoucke et al. (1994). The second method (the 2-D ESPRIT method) directly estimates the 2-D frequencies. It is shown that both methods are more accurate than the related methods. The present authors note that the original paper appears to have a key error in the permutation matrix specification of the first method. In this comment, they derive the correct one with the performance simulations.
Published Version
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have