Comment on “Photonic bands in two-dimensional microplasma array. I. Theoretical derivation of band structures of electromagnetic waves” [J. Appl. Phys. 101, 073304 (2007)

Abstract

Recently, theoretical derivation of band structures of electromagnetic waves in two-dimensional microplasma array has been induced by Osamu Sakai et al. [J. Appl. Phys. 101, 073304 (2007)] using a modified plane wave expansion (PWE) method and a frequency-dependent finite difference time–domain (FDTD) method. This report reveals band diagrams with the effects of plasma electron collision frequency, especially focuses on the TE wave by nonmagnetized plasma. Although the band diagrams of TE wave and formulas of calculation look correct at first glance, there are some mistakes in the report which are unfortunately ignored by the authors. The correct formulas of the modified PWE method and FDTD method will be proposed.