A hubristic windmill off Harvard Yard: Historically situating the Department of Social Relations

Abstract

This essay reviews Patrick L. Schmidt’s book chronicling the rise and fall of Harvard’s Department of Social Relations (Harvard’s Quixotic Pursuit of a New Science) and contrasts Schmidt’s history with work of other scholars focusing on the impacts of the Cold War on Harvard’s social sciences during this period. While Schmidt provides important new historical details about the Department of Social Relations, with significant new information on some of Harvard’s internal politics, this review considers some of the department’s failures in relation to the chilling effects of McCarthyism and some department members covert arrangements with intelligence agencies, and limits to free inquiry during the early Cold War.