The unmanaged waste disposal, coupled with the increased industrialization and urbanization, has aggravated the problem of heavy metal contamination in the environment, especially in the agricultural soils. In view of this, the present study was planned to evaluate the effectiveness of zinc (Zn) in the amelioration of cadmium (Cd) toxicity in plants, thereby sustaining the crop productivity in near future. The experiment was performed in two parts. The first part focused on calculating the EC50 (half-effective concentration) of Cd, for which the potted experimental plants (Amaranthus cruentus L.) were treated with different doses of Cd (10, 20, 30, 40, and 50 mgL−1). In the second part, the EC50 Cd dose was combined with different Zn doses (100, 200, 300, 400, and 500 mgL−1) and the effect of Zn supplementation on Cd exposed plants was studied by evaluating the response of different biochemical, physiological and yield parameters. The EC50 Cd dose was calculated to be 26.5 mgL−1. Plant yield increased significantly with reduced Zn dosages. Biochemical parameters improved more than physiological parameters after Zn treatment in Cd-stressed plants. At higher Zn doses, its toxic effects exacerbate Cd toxicity. The study indicates that Zn partially decreases Cd toxicity in Amaranthus plants. The results suggest that 300 mgL−1 Zn dose was sufficient to bring about maximum recorded mitigation of Cd toxicity. However, since the synergistic effects of high doses of Zn with Cd cannot be ruled out, the selection of the applied Zn dose should be carefully selected.