Recent studies have shown that multistage magmatic and metallogenic events in NE China were dominated by the Paleo-Asian Ocean tectonic regime and the Paleo-Pacific Ocean tectonic regime. However, outstanding questions remain on the petrogenesis and fertility of ore-causative magma in each metallogenic event. In this study, we report new geochronologic and geochemical data on ore-causative intrusions from the Tianbaoshan orefield in the east Jilin-Heilongjiang belt (EJHB), aiming to identify their petrogenesis, magma fertility, and their implications for the geodynamic evolution of the EJHB. Middle Permian Lishan ore-causative quartz monzodiorites with abundant mafic microgranular enclaves (MMEs) were emplaced at ca. 264.9 ± 2.6 Ma. Petrographic and geochemical characteristics (87Sr/86Sr(i) = 0.7049–0.7053, εNd(t) = 2.9–3.7, and εHf(t) = 4.7–11.7) indicate a juvenile crust source injected by a slab-metasomatized mantle component. The Early Jurassic Beishan monzogranites (ca. 192.5 ± 1.8 Ma) were generated by the partial melting of the juvenile underplating basaltic lower crust with subsequent fractional crystallization in response to their highly evolved geochemical features, combined with their depleted Sr-Nd-Hf isotopic signature (ISr = 0.7032–0.7037, εNd(t) = 2.8–3.3, and εHf(t) = 7.2–12.2). Based on the zircon trace element geochemistry, we infer that the Middle Permian quartz monzodiorites had a high oxygen fugacity (Ce4+/Ce3+ = 40–216), potentially generating the Pb-Zn-Cu mineralization. Early Jurassic Beishan monzogranites had a lower magmatic oxygen fugacity (Ce4+/Ce3+ = 14–106), which may account for the Mo-dominated mineralization. A combination of this study and previous results corroborates that the Tianbaoshan orefield records the superposition of different tectonic regimes during metallogenesis.