Yeast tRNA Ligase Research Articles

TRNA ligase structure reveals kinetic competition between non-conventional mRNA splicing and mRNA decay.

Yeast tRNA ligase (Trl1) is an essential trifunctional enzyme that catalyzes exon-exon ligation during tRNA biogenesis and the non-conventional splicing of HAC1 mRNA during the unfolded protein response (UPR). The UPR regulates the protein folding capacity of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). ER stress activates Ire1, an ER-resident kinase/RNase, which excises an intron from HAC1 mRNA followed by exon-exon ligation by Trl1. The spliced product encodes for a potent transcription factor that drives the UPR. Here we report the crystal structure of Trl1 RNA ligase domain from Chaetomium thermophilum at 1.9 Å resolution. Structure-based mutational analyses uncovered kinetic competition between RNA ligation and degradation during HAC1 mRNA splicing. Incompletely processed HAC1 mRNA is degraded by Xrn1 and the Ski/exosome complex. We establish cleaved HAC1 mRNA as endogenous substrate for ribosome-associated quality control. We conclude that mRNA decay and surveillance mechanisms collaborate in achieving fidelity of non-conventional mRNA splicing during the UPR.

Characterization of the tRNA ligases of pathogenic fungi Aspergillus fumigatus and Coccidioides immitis.

Yeast tRNA ligase (Trl1) is an essential trifunctional enzyme that repairs RNA breaks with 2′,3′-cyclic-PO4 and 5′-OH ends. Trl1 is composed of C-terminal cyclic phosphodiesterase and central polynucleotide kinase domains that heal the broken ends to generate the 3′-OH, 2′-PO4, and 5′-PO4 termini required for sealing by an N-terminal ligase domain. Trl1 enzymes are found in all human fungal pathogens and they are promising targets for antifungal drug discovery because: (i) their domain structures and biochemical mechanisms are unique compared to the mammalian RtcB-type tRNA splicing enzyme; and (ii) there are no obvious homologs of the Trl1 ligase domain in mammalian proteomes. Here we characterize the tRNA ligases of two human fungal pathogens: Coccidioides immitis and Aspergillus fumigatus. The biological activity of CimTrl1 and AfuTrl1 was verified by showing that their expression complements a Saccharomyces cerevisiae trl1Δ mutant. Purified recombinant AfuTrl1 and CimTrl1 proteins were catalytically active in joining 2′,3′-cyclic-PO4 and 5′-OH ends in vitro, either as full-length proteins or as a mixture of separately produced healing and sealing domains. The biochemical properties of CimTrl1 and AfuTrl1 are similar to those of budding yeast Trl1, particularly with respect to their preferential use of GTP as the phosphate donor for the polynucleotide kinase reaction. Our findings provide genetic and biochemical tools to screen for inhibitors of tRNA ligases from pathogenic fungi.

A fungal anticodon nuclease ribotoxin exploits a secondary cleavage site to evade tRNA repair

PaOrf2 and γ-toxin subunits of Pichia acaciae toxin (PaT) and Kluyveromyces lactis zymocin are tRNA anticodon nucleases. These secreted ribotoxins are assimilated by Saccharomyces cerevisiae, wherein they arrest growth by depleting specific tRNAs. Toxicity can be recapitulated by induced intracellular expression of PaOrf2 or γ-toxin in S. cerevisiae. Mutational analysis of γ-toxin has identified amino acids required for ribotoxicity in vivo and RNA transesterification in vitro. Here, we report that PaOrf2 residues Glu9 and His287 (putative counterparts of γ-toxin Glu9 and His209) are essential for toxicity. Our results suggest a similar basis for RNA transesterification by PaOrf2 and γ-toxin, despite their dissimilar primary structures and distinctive tRNA target specificities. PaOrf2 makes two sequential incisions in tRNA, the first of which occurs 3' from the mcm(5)s(2)U wobble nucleoside and depends on mcm(5). A second incision two nucleotides upstream results in the net excision of a di-nucleotide. Expression of phage and plant tRNA repair systems can relieve PaOrf2 toxicity when tRNA cleavage is restricted to the secondary site in elp3 cells that lack the mcm(5) wobble U modification. Whereas the endogenous yeast tRNA ligase Trl1 can heal tRNA halves produced by PaOrf2 cleavage in elp3 cells, its RNA sealing activity is inadequate to complete the repair. Compatible sealing activity can be provided in trans by plant tRNA ligase. The damage-rescuing ability of tRNA repair systems is lost when PaOrf2 can break tRNA at both sites. These results highlight the logic of a two-incision mechanism of tRNA anticodon damage that evades productive repair by tRNA ligases.

Function of yeast and amphioxus tRNA ligase in IRE1alpha-dependent XBP1 mRNA splicing

During their maturation step, transfer RNAs (tRNAs) undergo excision of their introns by specific splicing. Although tRNA splicing is a molecular event observed in all domains of life, the machinery of the ligation reaction has diverged during evolution. Yeast tRNA ligase 1 (TRL1) is a multifunctional protein that alone catalyzes RNA ligation in tRNA splicing, whereas three molecules [RNA ligase (RNL), Clp1, and PNK/CPDase] are necessary for RNA ligation in tRNA splicing in amphioxi. RNA ligation not only occurs in tRNA splicing, but also in yeast HAC1 mRNA splicing and in animal X-box binding protein 1 (XBP1) mRNA splicing under conditions of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress. Yeast TRL1 is known to function as an RNA ligase for HAC1 mRNA splicing, whereas the RNA ligase for XBP1 mRNA splicing is unknown in animals. We examined whether yeast and amphioxus RNA ligases for tRNA splicing function in RNA ligation in mammalian XBP1 splicing. Both RNA ligases functioned in RNA ligation in mammalian XBP1 splicing in vitro. Interestingly, Clp1, and PNK/CPDase were not necessary for exon–exon ligation in XBP1 mRNA by amphioxus RNL. These results suggest that RNA ligase for tRNA splicing might therefore commonly function as an RNA ligase for XBP1 mRNA splicing.

Dual functions of yeast tRNA ligase in the unfolded protein response: unconventional cytoplasmic splicing of HAC1 pre-mRNA is not sufficient to release translational attenuation.

The unfolded protein response (UPR) is an essential signal transduction to cope with protein-folding stress in the endoplasmic reticulum. In the yeast UPR, the unconventional splicing of HAC1 mRNA is a key step. Translation of HAC1 pre-mRNA (HAC1(u) mRNA) is attenuated on polysomes and restarted only after splicing upon the UPR. However, the precise mechanism of this restart remained unclear. Here we show that yeast tRNA ligase (Rlg1p/Trl1p) acting on HAC1 ligation has an unexpected role in HAC1 translation. An RLG1 homologue from Arabidopsis thaliana (AtRLG1) substitutes for yeast RLG1 in tRNA splicing but not in the UPR. Surprisingly, AtRlg1p ligates HAC1 exons, but the spliced mRNA (HAC1(i) mRNA) is not translated efficiently. In the AtRLG1 cells, the HAC1 intron is circularized after splicing and remains associated on polysomes, impairing relief of the translational repression of HAC1(i) mRNA. Furthermore, the HAC1 5' UTR itself enables yeast Rlg1p to regulate translation of the following ORF. RNA IP revealed that yeast Rlg1p is integrated in HAC1 mRNP, before Ire1p cleaves HAC1(u) mRNA. These results indicate that the splicing and the release of translational attenuation of HAC1 mRNA are separable steps and that Rlg1p has pivotal roles in both of these steps.

In vitro dissection revealed that the kinase domain of wheat RNA ligase is physically isolatable from the flanking domains as a non-overlapping domain enzyme

Wheat RNA ligase contains 5′-hydroxyl kinase, 2′,3′-cyclic phosphate 3′-phosphodiesterase, and 5′-phosphate 2′-phosphate-3′-hydroxyl RNA ligase activities in a 110-kDa polypeptide. Taking advantage of a wheat cell-free protein production system, we prepared various fragments containing a part of the enzyme. The method allowed us to check the activities of the fragments rapidly, eliminating the time-consuming cloning and sequencing steps for the expression of the fragment proteins. The results showed that each of the three activities can be assigned to a non-overlapping domain that does not require the presence of the other part(s) of the enzyme for its activity. This contrasts to the case of yeast tRNA ligase, in which the central kinase domain has been suggested to require to be tethered to one of the flanking domains for its activity.

RNA Repair: An Antidote to Cytotoxic Eukaryal RNA Damage

RNA healing and sealing enzymes drive informational and stress response pathways entailing repair of programmed 2',3' cyclic PO(4)/5'-OH breaks. Fungal, plant, and phage tRNA ligases use different strategies to discriminate the purposefully broken ends of the anticodon loop. Whereas phage ligase recognizes the tRNA fold, yeast and plant ligases do not and are instead hardwired to seal only the tRNA 3'-OH, 2'-PO(4) ends formed by healing of a cyclic phosphate. tRNA anticodon damage inflicted by secreted ribotoxins such as fungal gamma-toxin underlies a rudimentary innate immune system. Yeast cells are susceptible to gamma-toxin because the sealing domain of yeast tRNA ligase is unable to rectify a break at the modified wobble base of tRNA(Glu(UUC)). Plant andphage tRNA repair enzymes protect yeast from gamma-toxin because they are able to reverse the damage. Our studies underscore how a ribotoxin exploits an Achilles' heel in the target cell's tRNA repair system.

How IRE1 Reacts to ER Stress

The long-awaited structure of the effector portion of IRE1, the endoplasmic reticulum stress transducer, is published in this issue of Cell (Lee et al., 2008). This structure provides new insight into the mysterious coupling of kinase and endoribonuclease activities in the oldest, most-conserved branch of the unfolded protein response in eukaryotes.

Reprogramming the tRNA-splicing activity of a bacterial RNA repair enzyme

Programmed RNA breakage is an emerging theme underlying cellular responses to stress, virus infection and defense against foreign species. In many cases, site-specific cleavage of the target RNA generates 2′,3′ cyclic phosphate and 5′-OH ends. For the damage to be repaired, both broken ends must be healed before they can be sealed by a ligase. Healing entails hydrolysis of the 2′,3′ cyclic phosphate to form a 3′-OH and phosphorylation of the 5′-OH to form a 5′-PO4. Here, we demonstrate that a polynucleotide kinase-phosphatase enzyme from Clostridium thermocellum (CthPnkp) can catalyze both of the end-healing steps of tRNA splicing in vitro. The route of tRNA repair by CthPnkp can be reprogrammed by a mutation in the 3′ end-healing domain (H189D) that yields a 2′-PO4 product instead of a 2′-OH. Whereas tRNA ends healed by wild-type CthPnkp are readily sealed by T4 RNA ligase 1, the H189D enzyme generates ends that are spliced by yeast tRNA ligase. Our findings suggest that RNA repair enzymes can evolve their specificities to suit a particular pathway.

Structure-function analysis of the kinase-CPD domain of yeast tRNA ligase (Trl1) and requirements for complementation of tRNA splicing by a plant Trl1 homolog

Trl1 is an essential 827 amino acid enzyme that executes the end-healing and end-sealing steps of tRNA splicing in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Trl1 consists of two domains—an N-terminal ligase component and a C-terminal 5′-kinase/2′,3′-cyclic phosphodiesterase (CPD) component—that can function in tRNA splicing in vivo when expressed as separate polypeptides. To understand the structural requirements for the kinase-CPD domain, we performed an alanine scan of 30 amino acids that are conserved in Trl1 homologs from other fungi. We thereby identified four residues (Arg463, His515, Thr675 and Glu741) as essential for activity in vivo. Structure–function relationships at these positions, and at four essential or conditionally essential residues defined previously (Asp425, Arg511, His673 and His777), were clarified by introducing conservative substitutions. Biochemical analysis showed that lethal mutations of Asp425, Arg463, Arg511 and His515 in the kinase module abolished polynucleotide kinase activity in vitro. We report that a recently cloned 1104 amino acid Arabidopsis RNA ligase functions in lieu of yeast Trl1 in vivo and identify essential side chains in the ligase, kinase and CPD modules of the plant enzyme. The plant ligase, like yeast Trl1 but unlike T4 RNA ligase 1, requires a 2′-PO4 end for tRNA splicing in vivo.

Purification and sequence determination of an RNA ligase from wheat embryos

Wheat embryos have an RNA ligase activity that catalyses ligation of RNA molecules between the 5'-hydroxyl and 2',3'-cyclic phosphate termini. In contrast to yeast tRNA ligase, which ligates tRNA half molecules specifically, the wheat enzyme acts on various RNA substrates. It has been suggested that RNA ligase plays some unknown roles in vivo other than the maturation of tRNA. Here, we report purification of the enzyme and determination of the protease-digested peptide sequences. The sequences showed homologies to three database cDNA clones from Oryza sativa and Arabidopsis thaliana.

Structure–function analysis of yeast tRNA ligase

Trl 1 is an essential 827-amino-acid enzyme that executes the end-healing and end-sealing steps of tRNA splicing in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Trl1 consists of two catalytic domains--an N-terminal adenylyltransferase/ligase component (amino acids 1-388) and a C-terminal 5'-kinase/cyclic phosphodiesterase component (amino acids 389-827)--that can function in tRNA splicing in vivo when expressed as separate polypeptides. Sedimentation analysis indicates that the ligase and kinase/CPD domains are monomeric proteins that do not form a stable complex in trans. To understand the structural requirements for the RNA ligase component, we performed a mutational analysis of amino acids that are conserved in Trl1 homologs from other fungi. Alanine scanning identified 23 new residues as essential for Trl1-(1-388) activity in vivo. Structure-activity relationships at these positions, and four essential residues defined previously, were clarified by introducing 50 different conservative substitutions. Lethal mutations of Lys114, Glu184, Glu266, and Lys284 abolished Trl1 adenylyltransferase activity in vitro. The essential elements embrace (1) putative equivalents of nucleotidyltransferase motifs I, Ia, III, IV, and V found in DNA ligases, T4 RNA ligase 2, and mRNA capping enzymes; (2) an N-terminal segment shared with the T4 RNA ligase 1 subfamily only; and (3) a constellation of conserved residues specific to fungal tRNA splicing enzymes. We identify yeastlike tRNA ligases in the proteomes of Leishmania and Trypanosoma. These findings recommend tRNA ligase as a target for antifungal and antiprotozoal drug discovery.

Portability and fidelity of RNA-repair systems

Yeast tRNA ligase (Trl1) is an essential enzyme that converts cleaved tRNA half-molecules into spliced tRNAs containing a 2'-PO(4), 3'-5' phosphodiester at the splice junction. Trl1 also catalyzes splicing of HAC1 mRNA during the unfolded protein response. Trl1 performs three reactions: the 2',3'-cyclic phosphate of the proximal RNA fragment is hydrolyzed to a 3'-OH, 2'-PO(4) by a cyclic phosphodiesterase; the 5'-OH of the distal RNA fragment is phosphorylated by a GTP-dependent polynucleotide kinase; and the 3'-OH, 2'-PO(4), and 5'-PO(4) ends are then sealed by an ATP-dependent RNA ligase. The removal of the 2'-PO(4) at the splice junction is catalyzed by the essential enzyme Tpt1, which transfers the RNA 2'-PO(4) to NAD(+) to form ADP-ribose 1"-2"-cyclic phosphate. Here, we show that the bacteriophage T4 enzymes RNA ligase 1 and polynucleotide kinase/phosphatase can fulfill the tRNA and HAC1 mRNA splicing functions of yeast Trl1 in vivo and bypass the requirement for Tpt1. These results attest to the portability of RNA-repair systems, notwithstanding the significant differences in the specificities, mechanisms, and reaction intermediates of the individual yeast and T4 enzymes responsible for the RNA healing and sealing steps. We surmise that Tpt1 and its unique metabolite ADP-ribose 1"-2"-cyclic phosphate do not play essential roles in yeast independent of the tRNA-splicing reaction. Our finding that one-sixth of spliced HAC1 mRNAs in yeast cells containing the T4 RNA-repair system suffered deletion of a single nucleotide at the 3' end of the splice-donor site suggests a model whereby the yeast RNA-repair system evolved a requirement for the 2'-PO(4) for RNA ligation to suppress inappropriate RNA recombination.

Genetic and Biochemical Analysis of the Functional Domains of Yeast tRNA Ligase

Yeast tRNA ligase (Trl1) converts cleaved tRNA half-molecules into spliced tRNAs containing a 2'-PO4, 3'-5' phosphodiester at the splice junction. Trl1 performs three reactions: (i) the 2',3'-cyclic phosphate of the proximal fragment is hydrolyzed to a 3'-OH, 2'-PO4 by a cyclic phosphodiesterase (CPD); (ii) the 5'-OH of the distal fragment is phosphorylated by an NTP-dependent polynucleotide kinase; and (iii) the 3'-OH, 2'-PO4, and 5'-PO4 ends are sealed by an ATP-dependent RNA ligase. Trl1 consists of an N-terminal adenylyltransferase domain that resembles T4 RNA ligase 1, a central domain that resembles T4 polynucleotide kinase, and a C-terminal CPD domain that resembles the 2H phosphotransferase enzyme superfamily. Here we show that all three domains are essential in vivo, although they need not be linked in the same polypeptide. We identify five amino acids in the adenylyltransferase domain (Lys114, Glu266, Gly267, Lys284, and Lys286) that are essential for Trl1 activity and are located within motifs I (114KANG117), IV (266EGFVI270), and V (282FFKIK286) that comprise the active sites of DNA ligases, RNA capping enzymes, and T4 RNA ligases 1 and 2. Mutations K404A and T405A in the P-loop (401GXGKT405) of the central kinase-like domain had no effect on Trl1 function in vivo. The K404A and T405A mutations eliminated ATP-dependent kinase activity but preserved GTP-dependent kinase activity. A double alanine mutant in the P-loop was lethal in vivo and abolished GTP-dependent kinase activity. These results suggest that GTP is the physiological substrate and that the Trl1 kinase has a single NTP binding site of which the P-loop is a component. Two other mutations in the central domain were lethal in vivo and either abolished (D425A) or severely reduced (R511A) GTP-dependent RNA kinase activity in vitro. Mutations of the signature histidines of the CPD domain were either lethal (H777A) or conferred a ts growth phenotype (H673A).

Bacteriophage T4 RNA ligase 2 (gp24.1) exemplifies a family of RNA ligases found in all phylogenetic domains.

RNA ligases participate in repair, splicing, and editing pathways that either reseal broken RNAs or alter their primary structure. Bacteriophage T4 RNA ligase (gp63) is the best-studied member of this class of enzymes, which includes yeast tRNA ligase and trypanosome RNA-editing ligases. Here, we identified another RNA ligase from the bacterial domain--a second RNA ligase (Rnl2) encoded by phage T4. Purified Rnl2 (gp24.1) catalyzes intramolecular and intermolecular RNA strand joining through ligase-adenylate and RNA-adenylate intermediates. Mutational analysis identifies amino acids required for the ligase-adenylation or phosphodiester synthesis steps of the ligation reaction. The catalytic residues of Rnl2 are located within nucleotidyl transferase motifs I, IV, and V that are conserved in DNA ligases and RNA capping enzymes. Rnl2 has scant amino acid similarity to T4 gp63. Rather, Rnl2 exemplifies a distinct ligase family, defined by variant motifs, that includes the trypanosome-editing ligases and a group of putative RNA ligases encoded by eukaryotic viruses (baculoviruses and an entomopoxvirus) and many species of archaea. These findings have implications for the evolution of covalent nucleotidyl transferases and virus-host dynamics based on RNA restriction and repair.

Exon structure requirements for yeast tRNA ligase

Different nucleotides were introduced into nucleotides 32, 37 and 38 of yeast tRNA(Phe) precursors via oligonucleotide directed mutations. Pre-tRNAs were prepared using T7-transcription in vitro and spliced with the purified yeast tRNA endonuclease and tRNA ligase. It is demonstrated that tRNA ligase activities will be inhibited by the 5'-double-stranded end of 3'-halves.

Multiple nucleotide cofactor use by yeast ligase in tRNA splicing. Evidence for independent ATP- and GTP-binding sites.

We have examined multiple cofactor usage by yeast tRNA ligase in splicing in vitro. The ligase mechanism of action requires expenditure of two molar equivalents of nucleotide cofactor per mole of tRNA product. Recent evidence (Westaway, S.K., Belford, H.G., Apostol, B.L., Abelson, J., and Greer, C.L. (1993) J. Biol. Chem. 268, 2435-2443) demonstrated that the ligase-associated kinase activity is more efficient with GTP as cofactor than with ATP. Employing a ligase fusion construct with dihydrofolate reductase (Apostol, B.L., Westaway, S.K., Abelson, J., and Greer, C.L. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 7445-7455) for purposes of enzyme purification, we performed joining assays demonstrating that ATP and GTP are the most effective combination of cofactors. ATP was essential to the joining reaction, while UTP, CTP, or ATP replaced GTP inefficiently. Specific and functionally independent binding sites were confirmed for ATP and GTP by direct binding measurement. A third site was implicated in UTP- and CTP-ligase interactions. Comparison of binding constants with Kapp values determined for nucleotide-dependent joining suggested both that nucleotide triphosphate binding may be limiting in tRNA joining and that tRNA ligation occurs most efficiently using GTP for the kinase reaction and ATP as the adenylylate synthetase cofactor.

Novel activity of a yeast ligase deletion polypeptide. Evidence for GTP-dependent tRNA splicing.

Yeast tRNA ligase possesses multiple activities which are required for the joining of tRNA halves during the tRNA splicing process: cyclic phosphodiesterase, kinase, adenylylate synthetase, and ligase. A deletion polypeptide of a dihydrofolate reductase-ligase fusion protein, designated DAC, was previously shown to join tRNA halves although ATP-dependent kinase activity was not measurable in the assay used. We describe here a characterization of the mechanism of joining used by DAC and the structure of the tRNA product. DAC produces a joined tRNA and a splice junction with a structure identical to that produced by DAKC, the full-length dihydrofolate reductase-ligase fusion. Furthermore, DAC can use GTP as the sole cofactor in the joining reaction, in contrast to DAKC, which can only complete splicing in the presence of ATP. Both enzymes exhibit GTP-dependent kinase activity at 100-fold greater efficiency than with ATP. These results suggest that a potential function for the center domain of tRNA ligase (missing in DAC) is to provide structural integrity and aid in substrate interactions and specificity. They also support the hypothesis that ligase may prefer to use two different cofactors during tRNA splicing.

Yeast tRNA ligase mutants are nonviable and accumulate tRNA splicing intermediates.

We show here that yeast tRNA ligase protein is essential in the cell and participates in joining together tRNA half-molecules resulting from excision of the intron by the splicing endonuclease. A haploid yeast strain carrying a chromosomal deletion of the ligase gene is viable only if ligase protein can be supplied from a plasmid copy of the gene. When synthesis of the plasmid-borne ligase gene is repressed, cells eventually die and accumulate endonuclease cut but unligated half-molecules and intervening sequences. Half-molecules that accumulate appear to be fully end-processed. Two temperature-sensitive ligase mutant strains have been isolated; these strains accumulate a similar set of unligated half-molecules at the nonpermissive temperature.

Deletion analysis of a multifunctional yeast tRNA ligase polypeptide. Identification of essential and dispensable functional domains.

Splicing of tRNA precursors in extracts of Saccharomyces cerevisiae requires the action of two enzymes: a site specific endonuclease and a tRNA ligase. The tRNA ligase contains three distinct enzymatic activities: a polynucleotide kinase, a cyclic phosphodiesterase, and an RNA ligase. The polypeptide also has a high affinity pre-tRNA binding site based on its ability to form stable complexes with pre-tRNA substrates. To investigate the organization of functional enzymatic and binding elements within the polypeptide a series of defined tRNA ligase gene deletions were constructed and corresponding proteins were expressed in Escherichia coli as fusions with bacterial dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR). The DHFR/ligase derivative proteins were then efficiently purified by affinity chromatography. The complete ligase fusion protein retained enzymatic and binding activities which were unaffected by the presence of the DHFR segment. Examination of tRNA ligase deletion derivatives revealed that the amino-terminal region was required for adenylylation, while the carboxyl-terminal region was sufficient for cyclic phosphodiesterase activity. Deletions within the central region affected kinase activity. Pre-tRNA binding activity was not strictly correlated with a distinct enzymatic domain. A DHFR/ligase-derived protein lacking kinase activity efficiently joined tRNA halves. We postulate that this variant utilizes a novel RNA ligation mechanism.