X-shaped Galaxies Research Articles

From 100 MHz to 10 GHz: Unveiling the spectral evolution of the X-shaped radio galaxy in Abell 3670

Context. X-shaped radio galaxies (XRGs) are characterised by two pairs of misaligned lobes: active lobes hosting radio jets and the wings. None of the formation mechanisms proposed thus far are able to exhaustively reproduce the diverse features observed among XRGs. Emerging evidence has proposed the existence of sub-populations of XRGs forming via different processes. Aims. The brightest cluster galaxy (BCG) in Abell 3670 (A3670) is a dumbbell system hosting the XRG MRC 2011-298. The morphological and spectral properties of this interesting XRG were first characterised based on Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (JVLA) data at 1–10 GHz. In the present work, we follow up on MRC 2011-298 with the upgraded Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (uGMRT) at 120–800 MHz to further constrain its properties and origin. Methods. We carried out a detailed spectral analysis sampling different spatial scales. Integrated radio spectra, spectral index maps, radio colour-colour diagrams, and radiative age maps of both the active lobes and prominent wings were employed to test the origin of the source. Results. We confirm a progressive spectral steepening from the lobes to the wings. The maximum radiative age of the source is ~80 Myr, with the wings being older than the lobes by ≳30 Myr in their outermost regions. Conclusions. The observed properties are in line with an abrupt reorientation of the jets by ~90 deg from the direction of the wings to their present position. This formation mechanism is further supported by the comparison with numerical simulations in the literature, which additionally highlight the role of hydrodynamic processes in the evolution of large wings such as those of MRC 2011-298. It is plausible that the coalescence of supermassive black holes could have triggered the spin-flip of the jets. Moreover, we show that the S-shape of the radio jets is likely driven by precession with a period of P ~ 10 Myr.

X-shaped radio galaxies: probing jet evolution, ambient medium dynamics, and their intricate interconnection

This review explores the field of X-shaped radio galaxies (XRGs), a distinctive subset of winged radio sources that are identified by two pairs of jetted lobes which aligned by a significant angle, resulting in an inversion-symmetric structure. These lobes, encompassing active (primary) and passive (secondary) phases, exhibit a diverse range of properties across the multiple frequency bands, posing challenges in discerning their formation mechanism. The proposed mechanisms can broadly be categorized into those related either to a triaxial ambient medium, into which the jet propagates, or to a complex, central AGN mechanism, where the jet is generated. The observed characteristics of XRGs as discovered in the most substantial sample to date, challenge the idea that there is universal process at work that produces the individual sources of XRGs. Instead, the observational and numerical results rather imply the absence of an universal model and infer that distinct mechanisms may be at play for the specific sources. By scrutinizing salient and confounding properties, this review intends to propose the potential direction for future research to constrain and constrict individual models applicable to XRGs.

A VLBA-uGMRT search for candidate binary black holes: study of six X-shaped radio galaxies with double-peaked emission lines

ABSTRACT Identifying methods to discover dual active galactic nucleus (AGN) has proven to be challenging. Several indirect tracers have been explored in the literature, including X/S-shaped radio morphologies and double-peaked (DP) emission lines in the optical spectra. However, the detection rates of confirmed dual AGN candidates from the individual methods remain extremely small. We search for binary black holes (BBH) in a sample of six sources that exhibit both X-shaped radio morphology and DP emission lines using the Very Long Baseline Array (VLBA). Three out of the six sources show dual VLBA compact components, making them strong candidates for BBH sources. In addition, we present deep uGMRT images revealing the exquisite details of the X-shaped wings in three sources. We present a detailed precession modeling analysis of these sources. The black hole separations estimated from the simplistic geodetic precession model are incompatible with those estimated from emission line offsets and the VLBA separations. However, precession induced by a non-coplanar secondary black hole is a feasible mechanism for explaining the observed X-shaped radio morphologies and the black hole separations estimated from other methods. The black hole separations estimated from the double-peaked emission lines agree well with the VLBA compact component separations. Future multifrequency VLBA observations will be critical in ruling out or confirming the BBH scenario in the three galaxies with dual component detections.

Massive black hole binaries as sources of low-frequency gravitational waves and X-shaped radio galaxies

ABSTRACT We present the study of multimessenger signatures of massive black hole (MBH) binaries residing in the centres of galaxy merger remnants. In particular, we first focus on the gravitational wave background (GWB) produced by an ensemble of MBH binary inspirals in the frequency range probed by the Pulsar Timing Array (PTA) experiments. The improved estimates of the characteristic strain were obtained with the inclusion of environmental effects on the MBH binary orbital decay within the galaxy merger remnants, added in post-processing to the semi-analytical model of galaxy formation and evolution SHARK. Secondly, we explore two, intriguing in terms of the MBH binary evolution studies, hypotheses aiming to explain the origins of X-shaped radio galaxies – a peculiar type of objects with double lobe structures, constituting approximately 6–10 per cent of known radio loud galaxies. The two considered scenarios involve either an abrupt change in the jet direction after an MBH merger (a spin-flip) or an unresolved close binary, where each of the two components produces a jet. We find that the estimated GWB amplitude at the reference frequency $f_0=1 \, {\rm yr}^{-1}$ is in the range of $A_{\rm { yr^{-1}}} = 1.20\times 10^{-15}{\!-\!}1.46\times 10^{-15}$, which is 50 per cent lower than the strain of the signal detected by the PTA experiments. We also show that the spin-flip scenario considered in gas-poor mergers reproduces the observed properties of X-shaped radio galaxies well in terms of flip angle, redshift, and luminosity distributions.

Deciphering the Morphological Origins of X-shaped Radio Galaxies: Numerical Modeling of Backflow versus Jet Reorientation

X-shaped radio galaxies (XRGs) develop when certain extragalactic jets deviate from their propagation path. An asymmetric ambient medium (backflow model) or complex active galactic nucleus activity (jet-reorientation model) enforcing the jet direction to deviate may cause these structures. In this context, the present investigation focuses on the modeling of XRGs by performing 3D relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simulations. We implement different jet-propagation models applying an initially identical jet-ambient medium configuration to understand distinctive features. This study, the first of its kind, demonstrates that all adopted models produce XRGs with notable properties, thereby challenging the notion of a universal model. Jet reorientation naturally explains several contentious properties of XRGs, including wing alignment along the ambient medium’s primary axis, development of collimated lobes, and the formation of noticeably longer wings than active lobes. These XRGs disrupt the cluster medium by generating isotropic shocks and channeling more energy than in the backflow scenario. Our synthetic thermal X-ray maps of the cluster medium reveal four clear elongated cavities associated with the wing-lobe alignment, regardless of projection effects, but they affect their age estimation. We show that the depth and geometric alignment of the evolved cavities may qualify as promising characteristics of XRGs, which may be used to disentangle different formation scenarios.

Multifrequency analysis of the radio emission from a post-merger galaxy CGCG 292-057

ABSTRACT Galaxies exhibiting a specific large-scale extended radio emission, such as X-shaped radio galaxies, belong to a rare class of winged radio galaxies. The morphological evolution of these radio sources is explained using several theoretical models, including galaxy mergers. However, such a direct link between a perturbed radio morphology and a galaxy merger remains observationally sparse. Here, we investigate a unique radio galaxy J1159+5820, whose host CGCG 292-057 displays the optical signature of a post-merger system with a distinct tidal tail feature, and an X-shaped radio morphology accompanied by an additional pair of inner lobes. We observed the target on a wide range of radio frequencies ranging from 147 to 4959 MHz, using dedicated GMRT and VLA observations, and supplemented it with publicly available survey data for broad-band radio analysis. Particle injection models were fitted to radio spectra of lobes and different parts of the wings. Spectral ageing analysis performed on the lobes and the wings favours a fast jet realignment model with a reorientation time-scale of a few million years. We present our results and discuss the possible mechanisms for the formation of the radio morphology.

Scalable precision wide-field imaging in radio interferometry: I. uSARA validated on ASKAP data

ABSTRACT As Part I of a paper series showcasing a new imaging framework, we consider the recently proposed unconstrained Sparsity Averaging Reweighted Analysis (uSARA) optimization algorithm for wide-field, high-resolution, high-dynamic range, monochromatic intensity imaging. We reconstruct images from real radio-interferometric observations obtained with the Australian Square Kilometre Array Pathfinder (ASKAP) and present these results in comparison to the widely used, state-of-the-art imager WSClean . Selected fields come from the ASKAP Early Science and Evolutionary Map of the Universe (EMU) Pilot surveys and contain several complex radio sources: the merging cluster system Abell 3391-95, the merging cluster SPT-CL 2023-5535, and many extended, or bent-tail, radio galaxies, including the X-shaped radio galaxy PKS 2014-558 and ‘the dancing ghosts’, known collectively as PKS 2130-538. The modern framework behind uSARA utilizes parallelization and automation to solve for the w -effect and efficiently compute the measurement operator, allowing for wide-field reconstruction over the full field-of-view of individual ASKAP beams (up to ∼3.3° each). The precision capability of uSARA produces images with both super-resolution and enhanced sensitivity to diffuse components, surpassing traditional CLEAN algorithms that typically require a compromise between such yields. Our resulting monochromatic uSARA-ASKAP images of the selected data highlight both extended, diffuse emission and compact, filamentary emission at very high resolution (up to 2.2 arcsec), revealing never-before-seen structure. Here we present a validation of our uSARA-ASKAP images by comparing the morphology of reconstructed sources, measurements of diffuse flux, and spectral index maps with those obtained from images made with WSClean .

Simulations of Precessing Jets and the Formation of X-shaped Radio Galaxies

Jet precession is sometimes invoked to explain asymmetries in radio galaxy (RG) jets and “X/S/Z-shaped” RGs, caused by the presence of a binary black hole companion to the source active galactic nucleus or by accretion instabilities. We present a series of simulations of RG jet precession to examine how these sources would evolve over time, including a passive distribution of cosmic-ray electrons so we can model radio synchrotron emissions and create synthetic radio maps of the sources. We find that a single source viewed from different angles can result in differing RG morphological classifications, confusing physical implications of these classifications. Additionally, the jet trajectories can become unstable due to their own self-interactions and lead to “reorientation events” that may look like the effects of external dynamics such as shocks, winds, or cold fronts in the medium. Finally, something akin to an “Odd Radio Circle” may be observed in the case of viewing the radio remnant of such a precessing source from a line of sight near the precession axis.

Is Jet Re-orientation the Elusive Trigger for Star Formation Suppression in Radio Galaxies?

Jet re-orientation associated with the time evolution of radio quasars explains the formation of X-shaped radio galaxies and their preference for isolated environments. But since X-shaped radio galaxies are generally not found in dense environments (e.g., groups/clusters), the jet re-orientation phenomenon for radio galaxies in groups and clusters has been ignored. We take a closer look at the re-orientation of FRI jets with respect to FRII jets, and find that it may constitute the as-yet unidentified trigger for star formation suppression in radio galaxies. We show how the recently explored radio “red geyser” galaxies can be interpreted in this context and ultimately reveal a deeper understanding of why FRII radio galaxies are on one side of the star formation enhancement/suppression divide compared to FRI radio galaxies.

The Unusual Active Galaxy H1821+643 and the Elusive Nature of FRI Quasars

The moderate spin estimate for the black hole at the center of the cool core cluster H1821+643 motivates the completion of a story about this object’s origin and evolution that was in the making since the work by Blundell & Rawlings over two decades ago as the first example of a massive black hole accreting at near-Eddington rates with an FRI jet. This elusive combination of properties was explained in our 2010 model where we showed it to be part of a small parameter space that includes X-shaped radio galaxies. As an accreting black hole that never experienced a counterrotating phase, H1821+643 is constrained by theory to produce a jet for spin values a satisfying 0.1 < a < ∼ 0.7 and an FRI jet for a slightly smaller range. The feedback from such a black hole is not subject to a tilted jet and is why star formation rates remain high in this cluster environment. The prediction is that H1821+643 is within millions of years of becoming jetless.

Bridging the Bondi and Event Horizon Scales: 3D GRMHD Simulations Reveal X-shaped Radio Galaxy Morphology

X-shaped radio galaxies (XRGs) produce misaligned X-shaped jet pairs and make up ≲10% of radio galaxies. XRGs are thought to emerge in galaxies featuring a binary supermassive black hole (SMBH), SMBH merger, or large-scale ambient medium asymmetry. We demonstrate that XRG morphology can naturally form without such special, preexisting conditions. Our 3D general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulation for the first time follows magnetized rotating gas from outside the SMBH sphere of influence of radius R B to the SMBH of gravitational radius R g at the largest scale separation, R B/R g = 103, to date. Initially, our axisymmetric system of constant-density hot gas contains a weak vertical magnetic field and rotates in the equatorial plane of a rapidly spinning SMBH. We seed the gas with small-scale 2% level pressure perturbations. Infalling gas forms an accretion disk, and the SMBH launches relativistically magnetized collimated jets reaching well outside R B. Under the pressure of the infalling gas, the jets intermittently turn on and off, erratically wobble, and inflate pairs of cavities in different directions, resembling an X-shaped jet morphology. Synthetic X-ray images reveal multiple pairs of jet-powered shocks and cavities. Large-scale magnetic flux accumulates on the SMBH, becomes dynamically important, and leads to a magnetically arrested disk state. The SMBH accretes at 2% of the Bondi rate ( for M87*) and launches twin jets at η = 150% efficiency. These jets are powerful enough (P jets ≃ 2 × 1044 erg s−1) to escape along the SMBH spin axis and end the short-lived intermittent jet state, whose transient nature can account for the rarity of XRGs.

X-shaped radio galaxy 3C 223.1: A ‘double boomerang’ with an anomalous spectral gradient

A comparison of the recent LOFAR 144 MHz map of the radio source 3C 223.1 (J094124.028+394441.95) with the VLA maps at 4.9 GHz and 8.3 GHz that we built based on archival data, establishes this X-shaped radio galaxy (XRG) as a singularly robust case where the ‘wings’ exhibit a distinctly flatter radio spectrum than the primary lobes. The details of its anomalous spectral gradient are unravelled here with unprecedented precision. We also highlight the ‘double boomerang’ type radio morphology of this XRG. It appears plausible that the peculiar spectral gradient in this XRG is owed to particle acceleration associated with the rebounding of the collimated backflows of synchrotron plasma streaming through its two primary lobes, as they impinge upon and encounter the magnetic tension in the prominent dusty disk of the elliptical galaxy hosting this XRG. We also draw attention to an intriguing new morphological peculiarity among XRGs, namely, a lateral offset observed between the (parallel) axes of the two primary radio lobes.

The X-shaped Radio Galaxy J0725+5835 is Associated with an AGN Pair

X-shaped radio galaxies (XRGs) are those that exhibit two pairs of unaligned radio lobes (main radio lobes and wings). One of the promising models for the peculiar morphology is jet reorientation. To clarify this, we conducted a 5 GHz observation with the European VLBI Network (EVN) of XRG J0725+5835, which resembles the archetypal binary active galactic nuclei (AGNs) 0402+379 in radio morphology, but it is larger in angular size. In our observation, two milliarcsecond-scale radio components with nonthermal radio emission are detected. Each of them coincides with an optical counterpart with similar photometric redshift and (optical and infrared) magnitude, corresponding to dual active nuclei. Furthermore, with the improved Very Large Array (VLA) images, we find a bridge between the two radio cores and a jet bending in the region surrounding the companion galaxy. This further supports the interplay between the main and companion galaxies. In addition, we also report the discovery of an arcsecond-scale jet in the companion. Given the projected separation of ∼100 kpc between the main and companion galaxies, XRG J0725+5835 is likely associated with a dual jetted-AGN system. In both EVN and VLA observations, we find signatures that the jet is changing its direction, which is likely responsible for the X-shaped morphology. For the origin of jet reorientation, several scenarios are discussed.

Modelling X-shaped radio galaxies: Dynamical and emission signatures from the Back-flow model

Context. Active galactic nuclei typically show the presence of radio jets ranging from sub-kiloparsec to megaparsec scales. Some of these radio galaxies show distortion in their jets, forming tailed or winged sources. X-shaped radio galaxies (XRGs) are a sub-class of winged sources, the formation mechanism of which is still unclear. Aims. The focus of this work is to understand hydro-dynamical back-flows and their role in dynamics and non-thermal emission signatures (in the presence of radiative losses and diffusive shock acceleration) during the initial phase of these galaxies. Methods. We performed relativistic magneto-hydrodynamic (RMHD) simulations of an under-dense jet travelling in a tri-axial ambient using a hybrid Eulerian-Lagrangian framework to incorporate effects of micro-physical processes. Results. We demonstrate the dominant role played by pressure gradient in shaping XRGs in thermally dominated cases. We show that the prominence of the formed structure decreases as the jet deviates from the major axis of the ambient. The wing evolution is mainly governed by re-energised particles due to shocks that keep the structure active during the evolution time. The synthetic intensity maps of the radio galaxy show similarities with morphologies that are typically found in observed XRGs. This includes the cases with wider wings than the active lobes. The characteristic emission signatures in terms of its synchrotron spectra and the implication of equipartition condition in age estimation are also discussed here. Additionally, we show that age discrepancies can be attributed to the mixing of different aged particle populations. Furthermore, the effect of the viewing angle on the difference of spectral index (Δα) of the active lobes and the wings shows a large variation and degenerate behaviour. We demonstrate the role of diffusive shocks in the obtained variation and conclude that the Δα spread is not a dependable characteristic in determining the formation model of XRGs.

“Winged” Radio Sources from the LOFAR Two-meter Sky Survey First Data Release (LoTSS DR1)

A small number of extragalactic radio sources disclose a pair of low-surface-brightness radio lobes, known as “wings,” aligned at a certain angle to the primary jets. Such exotic sources are known as “winged” radio sources. Here we report the new identification of a total of 26 “winged” radio sources from the LOFAR Two-meter Sky Survey First Data Release (LoTSS DR1). Out of the 26 “winged” sources, 14 are identified as X-shaped radio galaxies and the remaining 12 as Z-shaped radio galaxies. The available optical counterpart of each radio galaxy is cataloged along with its estimated redshift. Among the 26 sources, 15 candidates are classified as FR-II radio galaxies, and two are classified as FR-I type. For nine candidates, no conclusions are drawn due to their complex morphology. We also calculate the physical parameters such as spectral index, radio luminosity, and power of the sources. We have made a statistical study of the spectral index by combining our estimated value with the spectral index collected from previous works. A mean value of spectral index of 0.71 is obtained.

Search for X/Z-shaped radio sources from TGSS ADR 1

ABSTRACTA small subclass of radio galaxies, exhibiting a pair of secondary low-surface-brightness radio lobes oriented at an angle to the primary high-surface-brightness lobes, is the group known as X-shaped radio galaxies (XRGs). In some cases, it is seen that less luminous secondary lobes emerge from the edges of the primary high-brightness lobes, giving a Z-symmetric morphology. These objects are known as Z-shaped radio galaxies (ZRGs). From the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research (TIFR) Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (GMRT) Sky Survey at 150 MHz, we present systematic search results for XRGs and ZRGs. We identified a total of 58 radio sources, out of which 40 are XRGs and 18 are ZRGs. Taking advantage of the large sample size of XRGs and ZRGs reported in the current work, different properties of XRGs and ZRGs are studied. Out of 58 XRGs and ZRGs presented here, 19 (32 per cent) are FR I and 33 (57 per cent) are FR II radio galaxies. For four XRGs and three ZRGs, the morphology is so complex that they could not be classified. We have estimated the radio luminosity and spectral index of newly discovered winged radio galaxies and made a comparative study with previously detected XRGs and ZRGs. Most of the XRGs show a steep spectral index between 150 and 1400 MHz and only 14 per cent of the sources show a flat spectrum, but for ZRGs a good proportion of the sources (36 per cent) show a flat spectrum.

Discovery of X-shaped morphology of the giant radio galaxy 0503-286

The high surface-brightness sensitivity of the galactic and extragalactic all-sky mwa survey (GLEAM) image of the giant radio galaxy (GRG) 0503-28 at 70–230 MHz has revealed an inversion-symmetric bending of its two lobes, while maintaining a ∼200 kpc wide strip-like radio emission gap between their bent portions. This lends the source the appearance of a mega-sized X-shaped radio galaxy. Identifying the emission gap with the presence of a gaseous layer, probably a WHIM-filled sheet in the cosmic web, we suggest that the layer is the most likely cause of the inversion-symmetric bending of the two radio lobes. Multiple observational manifestations of such gaseous layers are noted. The two lobes of this GRG, known to extend very asymmetrically from the host galaxy, are remarkably symmetric about the emission gap, confirming a curious trend noted earlier for double radio sources of normal dimensions. The anomalous radio spectral gradient reported for the northern lobe of this GRG is not substantiated.

Understanding the interplay between jets and ISM for winged radio galaxies

AbstractIn this work, we investigate the formation and early evolution phase of X-shaped radio galaxies using the Back-flow model. We show how the X-like winged morphology evolves over time in a tri-axial ambient medium, naturally. At this early stage of formation, we demonstrated that both the pair of jet lobes are actively pushing the ambient material out of their path of propagation, forming (X-ray) cavities that are surrounded by a shocked shell (X-ray bright rims) of swept materials. We also noticed how turbulent the wing is in comparison to the active lobe, generating sites of random shocks, indicating that the wings are not passively evolving structures. This study demonstrated that the ambiguous morphology observed in jets is also imprinted over the ambient medium, providing an alternative perspective in understanding the underlying physical process causing such ambiguities. Finally, we indicate that shearing instabilities cause mixing of ambient material at the shearing interface.

The great Kite in the sky: A LOFAR observation of the radio source in Abell 2626

Context.The radio source at the center of the galaxy cluster Abell 2626, also known as the Kite, stands out for its unique morphology composed of four symmetric arcs. Previous studies have probed the properties of this source at different frequencies and its interplay with the surrounding thermal plasma, but the puzzle of its origin is still unsolved.Aims.We use a new LOw-Frequency ARray (LOFAR) observation from the LOFAR Two-meter Sky Survey at 144 MHz to investigate the origin of the Kite.Methods.We present a detailed analysis of the new radio data, which we combined with archival radio and X-ray observations. We produced a new, resolved spectral index map of the source with a resolution of 7″ and we studied the spatial correlation of radio and X-ray emission to investigate the interplay between thermal and nonthermal plasma.Results.The new LOFAR data changed our view of the Kite because we discovered two steep-spectrum (α &lt; −1.5) plumes of emission connected to the arcs. The spectral analysis shows, for the first time, a spatial trend of the spectrum along the arcs with evidence of curved synchrotron spectra and a spatial correlation with the X-ray surface brightness. On the basis of our results, we propose that the Kite was originally an X-shaped radio galaxy whose fossil radio plasma, after the end of the activity of the central active galactic nucleus, has been compressed as a consequence of motions of the thermal plasma encompassing the galaxy. The interplay between the compression and advection of the fossil plasma, with the restarting of the nuclear activity of the central galaxy, could have enhanced the radio emission of the fossil plasma producing the arcs of the Kite. We also present the first, low-frequency observation of a jellyfish galaxy in the same field, in which we detect extended, low-frequency emission without a counterpart at higher frequencies.

Numerical modelling of X-shaped radio galaxies using back-flow model

AbstractThe focus of this work is to comprehensively understand hydro-dynamical back-flows and their role in dynamics and non-thermal spectral signatures particularly during the initial phase of X-shaped radio galaxies. In this regard, we have performed axisymmetric (2D) and three dimensional (3D) simulations of relativistic magneto-hydrodynamic jet propagation from tri-axial galaxies. High-resolution dynamical modelling of axisymmetric jets has demonstrated the effect of magnetic field strengths on lobe and wing formation. Distinct X-shape formation due to back-flow and pressure gradient of ambient is also observed in our 3D dynamical run. Furthermore, the effect of radiative losses and diffusive shock acceleration on the particle spectral evolution is demonstrated, which particularly highlights how crucial their contributions are in the emission signature of these galaxies. This imparts a significant effect on the galaxy’s equipartition condition, indicating that one must be careful in extending its use in estimating other parameters, as the criterion evolves with time.