The case for variable magnetic fields, in the range 1–15 kG, in three of the X-ray binary candidate stars, is discussed. We refer to electronic Zeeman polarimetry by Kemp and Wolstencroft (1973a and b) and by Angel et al. (1973). Our detections in Hβ showed: (1) definite magnetic fields, roughly constant over periods of 2 h, in θ2 Orionis and HD 77581; and (2) complex time behavior in HD 153919, with field reversals over periods of ~ 10 min, but with usually small values (≲ 2 kG) as averaged over times of 1–2 h. (Photographic Zeeman spectroscopy is therefore unlikely to show detectable fields, i.e. > 2 kG, in the latter star.) The essentially null results of Angel et al. (1973) in Hβ, in HD 77581 and HD 153919, indicate that the emission is non-magnetic; only the underlying absorption (which is far weaker than the emission in Hβ) shows Zeeman effects. A plot of the Zeeman measure for HD 77581, against the 8.95-day period, is shown: our points are suggestive of periodicity; and the points of Angel et al. (1973) which unfortunately have larger relative error bars, are consistent with the indicated variation and with the general scale of our results.
Read full abstract