In holding a conference on the historical experience with the gold standard, the National Bureau of Economic Research had two motivations, according to Anna Schwartz' introduction, first to test old views with new tools including econometric and statistical techniques and new theories and second, to provide a basis for judging the conservative call in the United States for a return to the gold standard. Dr. Schwartz had been the research director of the U.S. Gold Commission, and Michael Bordo on its staff. The Commission recommended against an attempt to re-establish the gold standard, coming out instead in favor of adopting monetary targets as a basis of macro-economic policy. (There was, however, a minority report favoring a return to gold.) The conference participants were economists and economic historians, for the most part of a monetarist persuasion, though they uncovered sharp differences among themselves over whether the nation or the world was the appropriate unit for assessing the money supply. This fat volume reporting the conference consists of 15 papers divided into five parts, with specific comments on all but A. Schwartz' introduction and L. Yeager's wind-up after-dinner speech, and general discussion among the participants. The first section on "Old and New Interpretations of the Gold Standard" has, in addition to the introduction, a masterly summary of the traditional literature by M. Bordo, and a revisionist paper by D. McCloskey and R. Zecher, putting forward an extreme monetarist view in which only the world money supply and the world price level count and central banks are of no consequence. The second, on "Rules of the Game", has papers by J. Dutton and J. Pippenger, testing various rules ascribed to the prewar Bank of England, with some new evidence and advanced statistical techniques, which produce no firm results. It also includes an account of the 1847 financial crisis in Britain by R. Dornbusch and J. Frenkel. The third section has four country papers: Canada in the interwar period, by R. Shearer and C. Clark; Germany, 1879-1913 by P. McGouldrick; Sweden, 1873-1914 by L. Jonung; and Italy, 1861-1914 by M. Fratianni and F. Spinelli. The three papers of Part IV deal with "International Linkages", and specifically with business cycles (W. Huffman and J. Lothian) and real output in various countries (S. Easton), plus another paper on Canada, this time dealing with borrowing from Britain before the war. The
Read full abstract