The official verdict of China's government is that the Cultural Revolution, which lasted from May 1966 to October 1976, “was responsible for the most severe setback and the heaviest losses suffered by the party, the state, and the people since the founding of the People's Republic” (1). After a decade of upheaval, the Chinese economy had come to the verge of collapse, and its political system was in disarray. State leaders began to redesign development strategies, policies, and plans. However, academic research on this period is rather scarce and lacks systematic studies on county-level factional politics throughout the entire Cultural Revolution. Dong Guoqiang and Andrew G. Walder's A Decade of Upheaval fills the void.This fascinating book is split into nine chapters plus a preface, chronology, glossary of names, bibliography, and index. It is organized chronologically and thematically, with the result being a historical cloud in which the reader is left to discern causality on their own. The book analyzes political struggle and violence during the Cultural Revolution in a rural Chinese county, grounded in evidentiary detail and making a number of novel observations. The authors focus their study on a remote and marginal county of northwest China, Feng County, and on Zhang Lianshen, a major rebel leader and a founder of one of the county's two factional alliances (Paolian and Liansi), who was intimately involved in all of the major political events in the county over the upheaval decade.Through researching Feng County's Cultural Revolutionary history, the authors shed light on four essential themes of political conflicts that have long been obscure. First, the authors point out that the remote location did not insulate the county from national political trends but only delayed their initial impact. County-level political conflicts were deeply affected by national political trends to a remarkable degree, as each twist and turn in Beijing's policies reverberated in the county in ways that altered the balance of power between two deeply opposed and clearly defined political factions.Second, the authors show that once the factions had clearly formed, and after violent encounters between them spread, the driving force of the escalating conflict was the realization that defeat would mean victimization at the hands of one's enemies. They also reveal in remarkable detail the deep involvement of China's armed forces in the definition and perpetuation of county-level factionalism. The struggle in Feng County was pushed forward by the absence of a neutral authority that could credibly enforce a cease-fire and ensure the evenhanded treatment of the two sides. Essentially, it was a struggle for survival.Third, the conflicts in Feng County were connected to broader factional disputes in the surrounding prefecture and province. Finally, the authors show how the prolonged deterioration of political authority and public order, and in many ways a deep fracturing of the social fabric, public trust, and citizen morale, resulted from this decade of conflict and oppression.This book creatively utilizes the methodology of historical anthropology and sociology and combines observations in the field with documentary analysis, drawing on an unusual level of evidentiary detail. Through interviewing key participants in the events, such as sixteen former activists, local officials, leaders of both factions, soldiers, and local collectors of Cultural Revolution memorabilia, the authors gained access to firsthand historical materials. Even more essential than these oral testimonies, the authors accessed the work notebooks and diaries of those involved in the events of the period, which were taken during conferences, study classes, and other meetings. They also extensively collected documents from several levels of government authorities, including the flow of directives and notices from authorities in Beijing, the provincial authorities in Jiangsu, and the prefectural authorities in Xuzhou. They also draw on internal bulletins and documents issued by a range of interim authorities in the county during the long period in which it remained under some form of military control, from March 1967 to September 1969.Additionally, the authors supplement official documents with unofficial materials issued by each of the county's two political factions, such as handbills and wall posters, selected copies of periodicals, chronologies of events, confessions, and self-criticisms written by individuals and by leaders of factions, and several unpublished memoirs and book drafts.This book has made a number of significant contributions to our current knowledge of the history of the Cultural Revolution. By examining rural Feng County, the authors add a new research dimension that should offer a deeper understanding of the Cultural Revolution as a whole, as well as help to explain the structural flaws of the Stalinist-Maoist political model.
Read full abstract