Shameless: The Visionary Life of Mary Gove Nichols. By Jean L. Silver-- Isenstadt. (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2002. Pp. xii, 342. Illustrations. Cloth, $24.95.) Shameless is the first book-length biography to chronicle the amazing life of Mary Gove Nichols, health and sex reformer who was in the public eye, on the public stage, and in the public prints for two decades, starting in 1838. This forceful advocate for women's freedom has long deserved far more prominent place in our histories of antebellum reform and women's rights, and Jean Silver-Isenstadt restores her to that prominence in an artfully written book that is pleasure to read. This is the biography that Mary Gove Nichols and her husband Dr. Thomas L. Nichols expected, anticipated, indeed probably ached to have. They had formidably sure sense of their own fame, and why it eluded them for so long is an interesting question. The two show up in cameo roles in number of excellent books on nineteenth-century social movements. But no one, until now, has advanced our biographical knowledge of Mary Gove Nichols beyond the basic outlines. Silver-Isenstadt, who holds an M.D. as well as Ph.D., brings to the project firm foundation in medicine, which is helpful for understanding woman who from her adolescent years studied medical books with obsessive intensity. With sure hand, Silver-Isenstadt appraises the health scene of the 1840s and makes sense of this determined woman's professional rise as medical specialist. When Mary Gove made her 1838 lecturing debut in towns across the Northeast on the subject of women's anatomy and physiology, only handful of women were public lecturers. Her immodest topics-tight lacing, reproduction, and marital sex-drew ridicule from the press and disownment from her Quaker meeting. In 1840 she edited health journal based on the teachings of the diet and sex reformer Sylvester Graham; in many ways, Gove appears to have been female Graham, espousing his anti-sex and anti-meat regimens. Her first pamphlet publication, in 1839, addressed the solitary vice (i.e., masturbation) in females. By 1845 she was committed to the water cure and secured her first posts as paid medical practitioner, seeing women patients, teaching classes, and writing for the Water-Cure Journal. In 1847, Mary Gove- disaffected and separated wife of the churlish Hiram Gove-met Thomas Low Nichols. Mary Gove, Nichols was journalist and editor with strong medical interests. During an early stint at Dartmouth Medical School, he heard Sylvester Graham lecture and adopted his dietary program. Like trains on parallel tracks, Thomas and Mary would spend the next fourteen years [1834-48] living two versions of the same experience (111). And when their trains hooked up, in their 1848 marriage, the two became unstoppable. Over the next ten years, this ambitious couple established several health schools, issued regular periodical, and published half dozen books. Their critique of the sexual system moved in new directions, too, as they relocated to Modem Times on Long Island, joined forces with Stephen Pearl Andrews, and wrote three remarkable books that attacked indissoluble marriage and were widely regarded as promoting Free Love. In this same time period, Mary's talents as medium blossomed, and Spiritualism became central to the Nicholses' lives. And then, quite suddenly, the two converted to Catholicism in 1857, dropped from the reform scene, and in 1861 moved to England, citing moral objections to the Civil War. Silver-Isenstadt notes compelling reasons why these two once-notorious reformers have not gotten their due: they disappeared to England, they passed through many movements instead of sticking with consistent set of allies, their free love program was a liability that made other reformers shun them, and their turnabout conversion has disappointed scholars (8). She offers an intriguing psychological explanation for Mary Gove Nichols's embrace of Catholicism: that baptism and devotion to the Virgin Mary cleansed this woman of an early dread of sex, product of her hateful marriage to Hiram Gove. …
Read full abstract