BOOK REVIEWS107 Copious notes followed by a thorough bibliography are proof of sound scholarship. All are deeply indebted to Father Ennis, now deceased. R.I.P. Hugh J. Nolan Wayne, Pennsylvania Mission and Memory: A History of the Catholic Church in Arkansas. By James M. Woods. (Little Rock: August House, Inc., Publishers for the Diocese of Little Rock, P.O. Box 3223, Little Rock, Arkansas 72203. 1993. Pp. 415. 824.95.) The year 1993 marked the 1 50tii anniversary of the erection of the Diocese of Little Rock in 1843. Mission andMemory is the history commissioned for the occasion. Many important details concerning the Church in Arkansas appear for the first time. Catholicism came to the Arkansas territory with the expedition of Hernando de Soto in 1541. Until the territory passed under the control of the United States in 1803, the Church was under Spanish and French ecclesiastical jurisdiction . During this "colonial" period it barely survived. There was little religious activity, small population, few clergy, immense distances, and slow travel. Yet a Catholic presence was preserved. Once a part ofthe United States, die Church in Arkansas had to start anew. Most settlers in the Early National period were English-speaking Protestants, and Arkansas became a state which even now has a Catholic population of only about three percent of the total population. Mission and Memory begins with two chapters of prediocesan development , hitherto little known. With the appointment of the first bishop, Andrew Byrne, the story continues, built around each bishop. Two chapters capture me era of Bishop Byrne; two chapters continue the story of Bishop Fitzgerald; diree chapters are devoted to the church under Bishop John Morris, and one chapter each outlines the contributions of Bishop Albert Fletcher and Bishop Andrew McDonald. This centering around the bishop is one of the merits of this book. The most significant bishop is Edward Fitzgerald (1867-1907). Fitzgerald is largely known because of his voting against the constitution on papal infallibility in the First Vatican Council and the "rumor" that he was under a cloud at die Vatican for the rest of his life. Here Bishop Fitzgerald emerges as a human, energetic, and respected man in church and state. The author shows that Fitzgerald was not "condemned" to remain a bishop of a remote diocese but turned down considerations for appointments to Cincinnati , New Orleans, and Kansas City to remain in his first diocese. In 1893 he was asked to administer the diocese of Dallas and the same year was chosen to represent the New Orleans Province in greeting the newly-elected Leo 108BOOK REVIEWS XIII. In 1884 he was chosen to give the opening address at the Third Plenary Council of Baltimore. Immigrant Irish, Germans, Italians, Polish, and Czechs formed the largest groups of Catholics. The Irish forged the way until after the Civil War. In more recent decades Hispanic and Vietnamese Catholics have left their marks on Arkansas Catholicism. Dr. Wood studies the immigrant era interestingly comparing the proportions offoreign-born Catholics with the general population. Chapter XI, "Sisters, Schools and Services: Some Catholic Contributions to Arkansas, 1838—1992," outlines this phase of Catholic life and ministry from die arrival of the Sisters of Loretto around 1840. A minor criticism might be that religious orders of men receive recognition in chapters on the regular development of the church, whereas the orders of women, for the most part, are treated in this chapter. Bishop Andrew J. McDonald has written in his prologue: ". . . We have opened our hearts and our archives to Professor James M. Woods of Georgia Southern University. A native Arkansan, he is a man of integrity and honesty, and a professional historian." Mission andMemory is a valuable contribution to American Catholic history. Hugh Assenmachhr, O.S.B. Subiaco Abbey Subiaco, Arkansas Religion and Society in Frontier California By Laurie F. Maffly-Kipp. (New Haven, Connecticut: Yale University Press. 1994. Pp. x, 241. 825.00.) This book is a remarkable piece of scholarship. It draws on a wide variety of primary sources including the letters and diaries of gold-seekers, sermons, the records of home mission societies, and other sources to present an innovative interpretation of the attempt of four...