New trace element and Hf^Nd isotope data on post-glacial basalts from Iceland’s main rift zones are used in conjunction with literature data to evaluate the relative importance of source heterogeneity and the melting process for the final melt composition. Correlations between Hf and Nd isotope compositions and trace element ratios indicate that at least two source components are sampled systematically as a function of the degree and pressure of melting beneath Iceland. Strong depletion in Rb, Ba, U and Th and enrichment in Nb and Ta compared with La in the most enriched samples from the Reykjanes Peninsula and Western Rift Zone suggests that the enriched source component is similar to ancient recycled enriched mid-ocean ridge basalt (E-MORB) crust. Highly incompatible trace element ratios such as Nb/La and Nb/U and Pb isotope ratios are variable across Iceland. This observation suggests that either the enriched component is intrinsically heterogeneous, or that there is a larger proportion of the enriched source component beneath the Southwestern Rift Zone compared with the Northern Rift Zone. The relative effect of source heterogeneity and melting on the final melt composition was evaluated with a one-dimensional polybaric melt mixing model in which accumulated melts from a depleted MORB mantle and a recycled E-MORB crust are mixed in different ways. Two styles of melt mixing were simulated: (1) complete mixing of melts with variable proportions of the depleted mantle and recycled E-MORB components; (2) incomplete mixing with a fixed initial proportion of the two source components. Calculated pressure-dependent compositional changes using these simple two-component melting models can explain the observed trends in trace element ratio and isotope ratio diagrams for Icelandic basalts, even in cases where conventional binary mixing models would require more than two source components. The example of Iceland demonstrates that melt mixing during extraction from the mantle is a key process for controlling the trace element and isotope variability observed in basaltic lavas and must be evaluated before inferring the presence of multiple source components.
Read full abstract