IN late summer I765, as Boston began to resist the Stamp Act, the prominent merchant Richard Clarke sat uneasily under the whiggish preaching of Jonathan Mayhew at the West Church. On August 25 Mayhew delivered a sermon which even he admitted had been composed in a high strain of liberty. Clarke, among others, believed that this sermon helped to incite the riot that destroyed Lieutenant Governor Thomas Hutchinson's mansion on the following day. Refusing to hear his pastor's profuse expressions of regret, Clarke angrily withdrew his family from the congregation.' One might expect Clarke to have found a new spiritual home in of the town's three Anglican churches, for instance at King's Chapel, the rector of which characterized Mayhew's composition as one of the most seditious Sermons ever delivered. Instead, he took a pew at the Brattle Street Congregational Church. Here, without fear of contaminating his family with disturbing political or religious doctrines, he could listen to the soothing preaching of Dr. Samuel Cooper, in the company of such whig leaders as John Hancock, James Bowdoin, Dr. Joseph Warren, and, from time to time, John Adams. Apparently pleased with his choice, Clarke remained in this congregation until he became a loyalist exile in I775. As late as I773, only a short time before he stubbornly supported Britain in the tea crisis, he purchased an expensive pew in the handsome new meetinghouse just erected by this affluent congregation.2
Read full abstract