Weak Protein-protein Interactions Research Articles

A DNA-Assisted Binding Assay for Weak Protein–Protein Interactions

We describe a new method used for quantitating weak interactions between proteins in which the weak interaction is "assisted" by a known DNA-DNA interaction. Oligonucleotides, which are conjugated to proteins of interest, contain short complementary DNA sequences that provide additional binding energy for protein-protein interactions. A stretch of unpaired bases links the protein to the hybridizing DNA sequence to allow formation of both protein-protein and DNA-DNA interactions with minimal structural interference. We validated the DNA-assisted binding method using heterodimerizing coiled-coil proteins. The method was then used to measure the predicted weak interaction between two domains of the Escherichia coli L-arabinose operon regulatory protein AraC. The interaction between domains has the expected magnitude (K(d)=0.37 mM) in the absence of arabinose. Upon addition of arabinose, we detected a weaker and unexpected interaction, which may necessitate modification of the proposed mechanism of AraC. The DNA-assisted binding method may also prove useful in the study of other weak protein-protein interactions.

Investigation of Stoichiometry of T4 Bacteriophage Helicase Loader Protein (gp59)

The T4 bacteriophage helicase loader (gp59) is one of the main eight proteins that play an active role in the replisome. gp59 is a small protein (26 kDa) that exists as a monomer in solution and in the crystal. It binds preferentially to forked DNA and interacts directly with the T4 helicase (gp41), single-stranded DNA-binding protein (gp32), and polymerase (gp43). However, the stoichiometry and structure of the functional form are not very well understood. There is experimental evidence for a hexameric structure for the helicase (gp41) and the primase (gp61), inferring that the gp59 structure might also be hexameric. Various experimental approaches, including gel shift, fluorescence anisotropy, light scattering, and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy, have not provided a clearer understanding of the stoichiometry. In this study, we employed single-molecule photobleaching (smPB) experiments to elucidate the stoichiometry of gp59 on a forked DNA and to investigate its interaction with other proteins forming the primosome complex. smPB studies were performed with Alexa 555-labeled gp59 proteins and a forked DNA substrate. Co-localization experiments were performed using Cy5-labeled forked DNA and Alexa 555-labeled gp59 in the presence and absence of gp32 and gp41 proteins. A systematic study of smPB experiments and subsequent data analysis using a simple model indicated that gp59 on the forked DNA forms a hexamer. In addition, the presence of gp32 and gp41 proteins increases the stability of the gp59 complex, emphasizing their functional role in T4 DNA replication machinery.

Modulation of Protein Dimerization by a Supramolecular Host–Guest System

Two sets of cyan and yellow fluorescent proteins, monomeric analogues, and analogues with a weak affinity for dimerization were functionalized with supramolecular host-guest molecules by expressed protein ligation. The host-guest elements induce selective assembly of the monomeric variants into a supramolecular heterodimer. For the second set of analogues, the supramolecular host-guest system acts in cooperation with the intrinsic affinity between the two proteins, resulting in the induction of a selective protein-protein heterodimerization at a more dilute concentration. Additionally, the supramolecular host-guest system allows locking of the two proteins in a covalent heterodimer through the facilitated and selective formation of a reversible disulfide linkage. For the monomeric analogues this results in a strong increase of the energy transfer between the proteins. The protein heterodimerization can be reversed in a stepwise fashion. The trajectory of the disassembly process differs for the monomeric and dimerizing set of proteins. The results highlight that supramolecular elements connected to proteins can both be used to facilitate the interaction between two proteins without intrinsic affinity and to stabilize weak protein-protein interactions at concentrations below those determined by the actual affinity of the proteins alone. The subsequent covalent linkage between the proteins generates a stable protein dimer as a single species. The action of the supramolecular elements in concert with the proteins thus allows the generation of protein architectures with specific properties and compositions.

Dynamic Organization of Aminoacyl-tRNA Synthetase Complexes in the Cytoplasm of Human Cells

The localization in space and in time of proteins within the cytoplasm of eukaryotic cells is a central question of the cellular compartmentalization of metabolic pathways. The assembly of proteins within stable or transient complexes plays an essential role in this process. Here, we examined the subcellular localization of the multi-aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase complex in human cells. The sequestration of its components within the cytoplasm rests on the presence of the eukaryotic-specific polypeptide extensions that characterize the human enzymes, as compared with their prokaryotic counterparts. The cellular mobility of several synthetases, assessed by measuring fluorescence recovery after photobleaching, suggested that they are not freely diffusible within the cytoplasm. Several of these enzymes, isolated by tandem affinity purification, were copurified with ribosomal proteins and actin. The capacity of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases to interact with polyribosomes and with the actin cytoskeleton impacts their subcellular localization and mobility. Our observations have conceptual implications for understanding how translation machinery is organized in vivo.

Deconstructing Viral Shells To Understand Its Building Blocks

Bacteriophages are known to carry their highly compressed genome under pressure in nanometer sized protein containers (capsids). f29 is a double-stranded DNA Bacillus subtilis phage whose capsids are prolate icosahedrons elongated along a 5-fold symmetry axis. The prohead is an assembly intermediate that is made by a reduced number of structural components. To withstand the considerable internal stresses, the prohead combines unexpected strength and resilience despite the fact that only weak protein-protein interactions are keeping the capsids structure together. Here we use Scanning Force Microscopy to study the mechanical properties of shell proteins as a function of their position with in the prohead. While gently probing the capsid, causing small deformations, we observe changes in the local elasticity revealing pentameric structures. When we break the shells in a controlled fashion we find that the capsids fracture along well-defined lines. The observed fracture lines are analyzed and classified according to the known monomer organization from the recently solved pseudoatomic structure. We found that the mechanically coherent building block of the protein shell is a trimer of monomers, organized according to the triangulation net of the icosahedron. Moreover, we find that the interactions between proteins in the equatorial belt are nearly twice weaker than the interactions within the icosahedral end-caps.

The Fas–FADD death domain complex structure unravels signalling by receptor clustering

The Death Inducing Signaling Complex (DISC) formed by Fas receptor, FADD and caspase-8 is a pivotal trigger of apoptosis1-3. The Fas/FADD DISC represents a receptor platform, which once assembled initiates the induction of programmed cell death. A highly oligomeric network of homotypic protein interactions comprised of the death domains (DD) of Fas and FADD is at the center of DISC formation4, 5. Thus characterising the mechanistic basis for the Fas/FADD interaction is paramount for understanding DISC signaling but has remained enigmatic largely due to a lack of structural data. We have successfully formed and isolated the Fas/FADD DD complex and here we report the 2.7 Å crystal structure. The complex shows a tetrameric arrangement of four FADD DDs bound to four Fas DDs. We show that an opening of the Fas DD exposes the FADD binding site and simultaneously generates a Fas/Fas bridge. The result is a regulatory Fas/FADD complex bridge governed by weak protein:protein interactions revealing a model where the complex functions as a mechanistic switch. This switch prevents accidental DISC assembly, yet allows for highly processive DISC formation and clustering upon a sufficient stimulus. Thus besides depicting a previously unknown mode of death domain interactions, these results further uncover a mechanism for receptor signaling solely by oligomerization and clustering events.

Structure of an isolated unglycosylated antibody CH2 domain

The C(H)2 (C(H)3 for IgM and IgE) domain of an antibody plays an important role in mediating effector functions and preserving antibody stability. It is the only domain in human immunoglobulins (Igs) which is involved in weak interchain protein-protein interactions with another C(H)2 domain solely through sugar moieties. The N-linked glycosylation at Asn297 is conserved in mammalian IgGs as well as in homologous regions of other antibody isotypes. To examine the structural details of the C(H)2 domain in the absence of glycosylation and other antibody domains, the crystal structure of an isolated unglycosylated antibody gamma1 C(H)2 domain was determined at 1.7 A resolution and compared with corresponding C(H)2 structures from intact Fc, IgG and Fc receptor complexes. Furthermore, the oligomeric state of the protein in solution was studied using size-exclusion chromatography. The results suggested that the unglycosylated human antibody C(H)2 domain is a monomer and that its structure is similar to that found in the intact Fc, IgG and Fc receptor complex structures. However, certain structural variations were observed in the Fc receptor-binding sites. Owing to its small size, stability and non-immunogenic Ig template, the C(H)2-domain structure could be useful for the development by protein design of antibody domains exerting effector functions and/or antigen specificity and as a robust scaffold in protein-engineering applications.

P110 CUX1 Cooperates with E2F Transcription Factors in the Transcriptional Activation of Cell Cycle-Regulated Genes

The transcription factor p110 CUX1 was shown to stimulate cell proliferation by accelerating entry into S phase. As p110 CUX1 can function as a transcriptional repressor or activator depending on promoter context, we investigated its mechanism of transcriptional activation using the DNA polymerase alpha gene promoter as a model system. Linker-scanning analysis revealed that a low-affinity E2F binding site is required for transcriptional activation. Moreover, coexpression with a dominant-negative mutant of DP-1 suggested that endogenous E2F factors are indeed needed for p110-mediated activation. Tandem affinity purification, coimmunoprecipitation, chromatin immunoprecipitation, and reporter assays indicated that p110 CUX1 can engage in weak protein-protein interactions with E2F1 and E2F2, stimulate their recruitment to the DNA polymerase alpha gene promoter, and cooperate with these factors in transcriptional activation. On the other hand, in vitro assays suggested that the interaction between CUX1 and E2F1 either is not direct or is regulated by posttranslational modifications. Genome-wide location analysis revealed that targets common to p110 CUX1 and E2F1 included many genes involved in cell cycle, DNA replication, and DNA repair. Comparison of the degree of enrichment for various E2F factors suggested that binding of p110 CUX1 to a promoter will favor the specific recruitment of E2F1, and to a lesser extent E2F2, over E2F3 and E2F4. Reporter assays on a subset of common targets confirmed that p110 CUX1 and E2F1 cooperate in their transcriptional activation. Overall, our results show that p110 CUX1 and E2F1 cooperate in the regulation of many cell cycle genes.

Plasma viscosity: A forgotten variable

Evaluation of plasma viscosity has been underutilized in the clinical practice. Plasma viscosity is determined by water-content and macromolecular components. Plasma is a highly concentrated protein solution, therefore weak protein-protein interactions can play a role that is not characterized by electrophoresis. The effect of a protein on plasma viscosity depends on its molecular weight and structure. The less spheroid shape, the higher molecular weight, the higher aggregating capacity, and the higher temperature or pH sensitivity a protein has, the higher plasma viscosity results. Plasma is a Newtonian fluid, its viscosity does not depend on flow characteristics, therefore it is simple to measure, especially in capillary viscosimeters. Its normal value is 1.10-1.30 mPa s at 37 degrees C and independent of age and gender. The measurement has high stability and accuracy, thus little alterations may be pathologically important. Inflammations, tissue injuries resulting in plasma protein changes can increase its value with high sensitivity, though low specificity. It can increase in parallel with erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR), but it is not influenced by hematocrit (anemia, polycytemia), or time to analysis. Based on these favorable features, in 1942 plasma viscosity was recommended to substitute ESR. In hyperviscosity syndromes plasma viscosity is better in follow-up than ESR. In rheumatoid arthritis, its sensitivity and specificity are better than that of ESR or C-reactive protein. Plasma fibrinogen concentration and plasma viscosity are elevated in unstable angina pectoris and stroke and their higher values are associated with higher rate of major adverse clinical events. Elevation of plasma viscosity correlates to the progression of coronary and peripheral artery diseases. In conclusion, plasma viscosity should be measured routinely in medical practice.

Study and selection of in vivo protein interactions by coupling bimolecular fluorescence complementation and flow cytometry

We present a high-throughput approach to study weak protein-protein interactions by coupling bimolecular fluorescent complementation (BiFC) to flow cytometry (FC). In BiFC, the interaction partners (bait and prey) are fused to two rationally designed fragments of a fluorescent protein, which recovers its function upon the binding of the interacting proteins. For weak protein-protein interactions, the detected fluorescence is proportional to the interaction strength, thereby allowing in vivo discrimination between closely related binders with different affinity for the bait protein. FC provides a method for high-speed multiparametric data acquisition and analysis; the assay is simple, thousands of cells can be analyzed in seconds and, if required, selected using fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS). The combination of both methods (BiFC-FC) provides a technically straightforward, fast and highly sensitive method to validate weak protein interactions and to screen and identify optimal ligands in biologically synthesized libraries. Once plasmids encoding the protein fusions have been obtained, the evaluation of a specific interaction, the generation of a library and selection of active partners using BiFC-FC can be accomplished in 5 weeks.

Profiling of the CD4 receptor complex proteins

Intermolecular complexes produced by the CD4 molecule were studied. To preserve the integrity of weak protein-protein interactions of the CD4 antigen, cells were lysed in a mild nonionic detergent Brij97. Protein constituents of the complex were identified by our previously proposed fluorescence immunoprecipitation assay with subsequent mass spectrometry. In total, 26 proteins associated with CD4 were identified on CEM cells. The CD4 complex included the following major components: tyrosine phosphatase CD45, transferrin receptor CD71, tyrosine kinase Lck, and a lymphocyte phosphatase-associated phosphoprotein LPAP. The CD4 complex also contained some components of cytoskeleton and heat shock proteins. The association between CD4, CD71, and CD45 molecules was confirmed by immunoblotting. The CD4 complexes were not detected on the U937 myeloid cells lacking Lck and LPAP. We attempted to quantitatively characterize the CD4 complex composition.

Let's Get Together

Proteins in the eukaryotic plasma membrane mediate many different functions and are largely partitioned into clusters. Using the SNARE protein syntaxin 1 as an example, Sieber et al . (see the Perspective by White) investigate the mechanism of clustering using high-resolution optical imaging, quantitative biochemistry, and molecular dynamics simulations. Weak protein-protein interactions are balanced by steric repulsion to give densely crowded clusters containing about 75 syntaxins. Proteins within the cluster are immobile but can exchange with freely diffusing molecules. This conceptual framework likely applies to many other membrane proteins. J. J. Sieber, K. I. Willig, C. Kutzner, C. Gerding-Reimers, B. Harke, G. Donnert, B. Rammner, C. Eggeling, S. W. Hell, H. Grubmüller, T. Lang, Anatomy and dynamics of a supramolecular membrane protein cluster. Science 317 , 1072-1076 (2007). [Abstract] [Full Text] S. H. White, Crowds of syntaxins. Science 317 , 1045-1046 (2007). [Summary] [Full Text]

Anatomy and Dynamics of a Supramolecular Membrane Protein Cluster

Most plasmalemmal proteins organize in submicrometer-sized clusters whose architecture and dynamics are still enigmatic. With syntaxin 1 as an example, we applied a combination of far-field optical nanoscopy, biochemistry, fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) analysis, and simulations to show that clustering can be explained by self-organization based on simple physical principles. On average, the syntaxin clusters exhibit a diameter of 50 to 60 nanometers and contain 75 densely crowded syntaxins that dynamically exchange with freely diffusing molecules. Self-association depends on weak homophilic protein-protein interactions. Simulations suggest that clustering immobilizes and conformationally constrains the molecules. Moreover, a balance between self-association and crowding-induced steric repulsions is sufficient to explain both the size and dynamics of syntaxin clusters and likely of many oligomerizing membrane proteins that form supramolecular structures.

The Intrinsic Affinity between E2 and the Cys Domain of E1 in Ubiquitin-like Modifications

Ubiquitin-like modifications, which are carried out by similar biochemical mechanisms, regulate nearly every aspect of cellular function. Despite the recent advancements in characterizing their enzymology, our knowledge about the dynamic processes of these modifications is still fragmentary. In this study, we have uncovered an intrinsic affinity between the SUMO E2 and the Cys domain of SUMO E1. NMR studies in combination with paramagnetic spin labeling demonstrate that this interaction is mediated by previously unknown interfaces on both E1 and E2 and places the two catalytic Cys residues of the two enzymes in close proximity. Site-directed mutagenesis and enzymatic assays indicate that the interaction is fundamentally important for the transfer of SUMO from E1 to E2. Results from this study suggest that the interaction between E2 and the Cys domain of E1 participates in guiding the E2's translocation to E1's enzymatic active site in ubiquitin-like modifications.

Protein Tyrosine Phosphatase Oligomerization Studied by a Combination of 15N NMR Relaxation and 129Xe NMR. Effect of Buffer Containing Arginine and Glutamic Acid

15N NMR relaxation and 129Xe NMR chemical shift measurements offer complementary information to study weak protein-protein interactions. They have been applied to study the oligomerization equilibrium of a low-molecular-weight protein tyrosine phosphatase in the presence of 50 mM arginine and 50 mM glutamic acid. These experimental conditions are shown to enhance specific protein-protein interactions while decreasing nonspecific aggregation. In addition, 129Xe NMR chemical shifts become selective reporters of one particular oligomer in the presence of arginine and glutamic acid, indicating that a specific Xe binding site is created in the oligomerization process. It is suggested that the multiple effects of arginine and glutamic acid are related to their effective excluded volume that favors specific protein association and the destabilization of partially unfolded forms that preferentially interact with xenon and are responsible for nonspecific protein aggregation.

Detection of transient protein–protein interactions by bimolecular fluorescence complementation: The Abl‐SH3 case

Protein-protein interactions are essential in most biological processes. Many proteomic approaches have succeeded in the identification of strong and obligatory interactions but the study of weak and transient protein-protein interactions is still a challenge. The aim of the present study was to test the ability of bimolecular fluorescence complementation to detect and discriminate in vivo weak intracellular protein interactions. As a test case, the interaction of the SH3 domain from the c-Abl tyrosine kinase with both natural and designed targets has been chosen. The reassociation of functional yellow fluorescent protein (YFP) from its fragments requires previous binding between the SH3 domain and its partners; but once this occurs, the complex is trapped, turning transient SH3 interactions into stable, easily detectable ones. The method is very sensitive and can be implemented for proteomic analysis of weak protein interactions using flow cytometry. The fluorescence emission is dependent on the strength of the interaction, in such a way that it can be used, at least qualitatively, to screen for best binding candidates among similar proline-rich peptides. In addition, it is illustrated how this method can be used to gain structural insights into particular c-Abl SH3 interactions.

Src Tail Phosphorylation Is Limited by Structural Changes in the Regulatory Tyrosine Kinase Csk

Src family tyrosine kinases are down-regulated through phosphorylation of a single C-terminal tyrosine by the nonreceptor tyrosine kinase Csk. Despite the fundamental role of Csk in controlling cell growth and differentiation, it is unclear what limits this key signaling reaction and controls the production of catalytically repressed Src. To investigate this issue, stopped-flow fluorescence experiments were performed to determine which steps modulate catalysis. Both Src binding and phosphorylation can be monitored by changes in intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence. Association kinetics are biphasic with the initial phase corresponding to the bimolecular interaction of both proteins and the second phase representing a slow conformational change that coincides with the rate of maximum turnover. The kinetic transients for the phosphorylation reaction are also biphasic with the initial phase corresponding to the rapid phosphorylation and the release of phospho-Src. These data, along with equilibrium sedimentation and product inhibition experiments, suggest that steps involving Src association, phosphorylation, and product release are fast and that a structural change in Csk participates in limiting the catalytic cycle.

Immunoprecipitation of spliceosomal RNAs by antisera to galectin-1 and galectin-3

We have shown that galectin-1 and galectin-3 are functionally redundant splicing factors. Now we provide evidence that both galectins are directly associated with spliceosomes by analyzing RNAs and proteins of complexes immunoprecipitated by galectin-specific antisera. Both galectin antisera co-precipitated splicing substrate, splicing intermediates and products in active spliceosomes. Protein factors co-precipitated by the galectin antisera included the Sm core polypeptides of snRNPs, hnRNP C1/C2 and Slu7. Early spliceosomal complexes were also immunoprecipitated by these antisera. When splicing reactions were sequentially immunoprecipitated with galectin antisera, we found that galectin-1 containing spliceosomes did not contain galectin-3 and vice versa, providing an explanation for the functional redundancy of nuclear galectins in splicing. The association of galectins with spliceosomes was (i) not due to a direct interaction of galectins with the splicing substrate and (ii) easily disrupted by ionic conditions that had only a minimal effect on snRNP association. Finally, addition of excess amino terminal domain of galectin-3 inhibited incorporation of galectin-1 into splicing complexes, explaining the dominant-negative effect of the amino domain on splicing activity. We conclude that galectins are directly associated with splicing complexes throughout the splicing pathway in a mutually exclusive manner and they bind a common splicing partner through weak protein–protein interactions.

Protein assembly and DNA looping by the FokI restriction endonuclease

The FokI restriction endonuclease recognizes an asymmetric DNA sequence and cuts both strands at fixed positions upstream of the site. The sequence is contacted by a single monomer of the protein, but the monomer has only one catalytic centre and forms a dimer to cut both strands. FokI is also known to cleave DNA with two copies of its site more rapidly than DNA with one copy. To discover how FokI acts at a single site and how it acts at two sites, its reactions were examined on a series of plasmids with either one recognition site or with two sites separated by varied distances, sometimes in the presence of a DNA-binding defective mutant of FokI. These experiments showed that, to cleave DNA with one site, the monomer bound to that site associates via a weak protein–protein interaction with a second monomer that remains detached from the recognition sequence. Nevertheless, the second monomer catalyses phosphodiester bond hydrolysis at the same rate as the DNA-bound monomer. On DNA with two sites, two monomers of FokI interact strongly, as a result of being tethered to the same molecule of DNA, and sequester the intervening DNA in a loop.

Purification, stabilization, and concentration of very weak protein-protein complexes: Shifting the association equilibrium via complex selective adsorption on lowly activated supports

Very weak protein-protein interactions are very difficult to detect because these complexes could be under the detection limit or they tend to dissociate. Here, using as a model the antibody-antigen interaction weaken by the presence of dioxane, we have shown a strategy for the protein complexes purification by selective adsorption of the associated proteins. This strategy is based on the use of poorly activated anionic exchanger supports to selectively adsorb large complexes. This selective adsorption of the associated proteins shifted the association equilibrium of the soluble proteins toward the associated form. Thus, in the presence of 15% v/v dioxane, a concentration that is able to almost fully break the immunocomplex (less that 3% of the immunocomplex appeared associated when soluble antigen-antibody mixture was cross-linked with aldehyde-dextran), we can obtain more than 90% of the fully pure immunocomplex from the non-associated protein, adsorbed on anionic exchanger supports having a very low activation. This simple strategy may be a very useful tool to solve one of the most relevant challenges in the modern proteomics, the detection of very weak protein-protein interactions.