Wastewater treatment using green technologies contributes significantly to a circular economy. Constructed wetlands (CW) using green substrates or recycled materials are low-cost cleaner technologies that further contribute to a closed circuit. This study assessed the performance of two recycled materials, Waste Clay Brick (WCB) and Palm Kernel Shells (PKS), as suitable substrates in a CW for wastewater treatment. Five (5) horizontal subsurface flow constructed wetlands (HSSF CW), designed and fabricated using galvanized steel, were set up for the treatment of domestic wastewater (sewage). The wetland cells were packed with small (WCBS, PKSS) or large (WCBL or PKSL) particle size substrates with one cell using sand as control. The CW operated under two hydraulic loading rates (HLR), 50l/d (HLR-1) and 80l/d (HLR-2). Overall, the effluent quality of HLR-1 was relatively better than HLR-2. pH and turbidity of effluent were satisfactory and within the Ghana Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) guidelines for discharge of wastewater into surface water bodies. For both hydraulic loading rates, the highest removal efficiencies of BOD5 (73.97%), COD (71.89%), TSS (90.82%), TP (71.13%), TN (49.41%) were recorded for WCB. Coliform removal was highest in the Palm Kernel Shell (98.6%), followed by the control (97.39%). Wastewater treatment efficiency decreased with increasing wastewater loading rates for all parameters in Waste Clay Brick and BOD5 and TP in Palm Kernel Shell. WCB demonstrated superior treatment potential compared to PKS for all parameters except coliform removal.