AbstractEl Niño‐related sea surface temperature (SST) anomalies over the tropical Pacific Ocean impact global climates, but these impacts differ substantially for conventional cold tongue El Niño (CT El Niño) and the central Pacific El Niño (CP El Niño) events. This study is motivated by the need for a better understanding of the recharge/discharge processes associated with these two different flavors of El Niño. Composite analysis based on improved CT and CP El Niño identification methods applied to the Simple Ocean Data Assimilation demonstrates that the recharge/discharge processes are active during CT El Niño events. In contrast, for CP El Niño events, the recharge/discharge processes do not play a significant role. Prior to a CT El Niño, warm water accumulates over the western Pacific due to off‐equatorial anticyclonic wind stress curl. The onset of a CT El Niño is closely associated with the formation of a cyclonic atmospheric circulation over the northwest Pacific in the winter and spring, which induces westerly wind anomalies in the equatorial western Pacific and initiates eastward warm water transport. This leads to peak warming in the eastern equatorial Pacific the following winter, followed by the poleward discharge of warm water. This quasi‐cyclical behavior provides a measure of predictability. In contrast, the CP El Niño events do not show a precursor subsurface warming signal along the tropical Pacific thermocline. Instead, modest warm SST anomalies appear in boreal summer and peak in the fall, with weak subsurface warming mainly in the fall during CP El Niños. Hence, CP El Niños are less predictable in terms of an equatorial thermocline precursor than CT El Niño events.