MLR, I02.4, 2007 I I 5 I of leaving itbehind, though at themoment that sounds a pious hope inmuch of theworld rather than a believable reality.Stout wishes to enlarge the concept ofwar poetry, so that itextends beyond thenarrow category of 'trenchpoets', who wrote out of their front-line experience, or the poets inuniform who wrote about war without seeing any direct action. Stout extends it to take in any poets who responded towar and expressed loss and grief, and she has chapters on thewomen poets of the two world wars (some ofwhom came close to the action as nurses or ambulance drivers). Stout is on familiar ground in her discussion of Sassoon and Owen, who changed the concept ofwar poetry. But likemany other commentators she assumes that their reaction against thewar was more representative of opinion at large, inor out of the armed forces, than itwas. The most substantial poetic memorial to theGreat War by a British writer, David Jones's In Parenthesis, gets only a fleetingmention in the notes. Reasonably enough, Stout's frame of reference isAmerican, and after the dis cussion of theFirstWorld War British poets tend tomake just the occasional guest appearance. Nevertheless, inher account of the run-up to theSecond World War she includes a long and admiring account ofLouis MacNeice's evocation of the eve ofwar, AutumnyJournal,which she rightlyregards as a little-knownmasterwork. When she comes to thewar itselfStout concentrates on American poets, in readings ofRandall Jarrell,Louis Simpson, and other soldier poets, and, on the civilian sidelines,Wallace Stevens. The only British poet inuniform she discusses isGavin Ewart, an attractive but minor talent in comparison with thosewho are ignored, such as Keith Douglas, Roy Fuller, Alun Lewis, and Hamish Henderson. She does, though, provide a good analysis of 'LittleGidding' as a poem ofwartime experience. Stout is ultimately concerned with cultural history, and her reading of poetry is supported by studies of thevisual arts and music thatcame out of thewars; Britten's War Requiem is a famous example of the latter, though her range iswide enough to include a lively (and to this reviewer evocative) discussion of the popular songs of World War II. She shows how theUnited States went to great lengths to instil a patriotic mythology into a population forwhom thewar was remote and incompre hensible. The British, whose cities were being bombed and had Nazi Europe twenty miles from theircoast, had a greater sense ofwhat it was all about. This isan enjoyable and informativebook, even if it lacks an overall sense of direction. UNIVERSITY OFWARWICK BERNARDBERGONZI Ethics and Nostalgia in theContemporary Novel. By JOHNJ.SU. Cambridge: Cam bridgeUniversityPress. 2005. vii+226pp. C45. ISBN 978-o-52i-85440-5. On revisiting St Lucia, thepoet narrator inDerek Walcott's Omeros (London: Faber & Faber, i99i) reflects, 'Art isHistory's nostalgia, itprefers a thatched Iroof to a concrete factory,and the huge church Iabove a bleached village' (p. 228). John Su cites The Odyssey as the foundational text regarding a yearning fororigins, for the home leftbehind, and notes itsappeal tomany twentieth-centurywriters, including Joyce andWalcott, but rejects the criticism implicit in Walcott's lines.His book sets out to question what he sees as the fashionable valuing ofmemory over and against nostalgia, wherein "'[m]emory" signifies intimate personal experience, which often counters institutional histories; "nostalgia" signifies inauthentic or commodified ex periences inculcated by capitalist or nationalist interests' (p. 2). Su eschews a long tradition which has valued nostalgia as central toworks by esteemed European and American literary authors, including Rousseau, Proust, Thoreau, Eliot, andMarquez. Indeed, his discussion is mainly informedbymore con temporarywriting and critical discussion, and the literarytextshe studies all date from I 152 Reviews after World War II. In opposition to thosewho deplore thekind ofnostalgia embodied in theheritage industry,or perhaps in the idyllic childhood memories celebrated by negritude poets like Senghor, he cites Svetlana Boym's recent The Future ofNostal gia, which explores theways inwhich nostalgia can be either restorative or reflective, shaping a certainway of thinkingabout a particular time and place, and granting such memories a transformative and reconstructive power. But whereas Boym focuses on artists exiled fromRussia and Eastern Europe (including Nabakov, Brodsky, Stravin sky,and Benjamin), Su takes a...