VOS Viewer Research Articles

Forty-seven years of Iranian cardiovascular disease scientific publication: A bibliometric and altmetric analysis.

The present study was conducted to investigate the scientific contributions of Iranians in the field of cardiovascular research, as indexed in the Scopus database, using bibliometric and altmetric methods. This applied study was conducted with a scientometric approach, utilizing bibliometric and altmetric indicators. The research population consisted of the scientific works of Iranian researchers in the field of cardiovascular diseases, indexed in the Scopus database over a period of 47 years. For bibliometric analysis and the generation of co-citation, co-occurrence, and co-authorship maps, the authors employed VOS Viewer software and the bibliometrix package in the R programming language. In the final stage, articles mentioned on social media were analyzed and evaluated using an altmetric approach. The results indicated that the commencement point for the publication of documents was 1975, and there has been a steep increase in recent years. Moreover, the documents were primarily research articles out of 6853 retrieved documents, and a limited number of documents were single-authored. Other findings also revealed the co-authorship map of authors and the co-occurrence of words, highly cited authors and institutions, and highly frequent keywords, signifying the scientific collaboration of Iranian researchers with the United States and England. Altmetric analysis also demonstrated that 43.41% of documents were shared at least once on social media and had an Altmetric Attention score. Furthermore, the analysis of altmetric indices showed that Mendeley, Twitter, and News had the highest share of document mentions on social media, respectively. The findings of the study can offer valuable information to researchers, managers, and policy makers to become aware of the current state of research in the field of cardiovascular diseases and implement the necessary policies to inform society and enhance public health status.

Missmatch Industri Dan SMK: Fenomena SMK Penyumbang Angka Pengangguran Tinggi

Vocational High Schools (SMK - Sekolah Menengah Kejuruan) have become the largest contributor to unemployment figures, contrary to their intended purpose of preparing graduates for the workforce. This issue is attributed to a mismatch between the needs of the industry and the education provided by vocational schools. The aim of this research is to identify steps that should be taken to reduce the industry-school mismatch. The method employed involves biometric analysis using Vos Viewer, with data sourced from Google Scholar, including scientific articles in journals and in English. The results and findings of this research indicate that the mismatch is caused by a lack of synchronization between industrial advancements and the curriculum in vocational schools, students' lack of preparedness for the job market, and various supporting skills. This study suggests further investigation into industry-school mismatches based on specific fields of expertise in each vocational school. Consequently, in the future, vocational schools should no longer be the leading contributor to unemployment but rather contribute to the workforce in various fields within industries, aligning with the demands of the respective industries.

Analisis Literatur terkait dengan Model Pemimpin dan Kepemimpinan dalam Islam (Kasus Penggabungan Tiga Bank Syariah Besar Menjadi BSI)

This article is about a literature review regarding good leadership models in Islam as seen from the experience of the merger of 3 (three) Sharia Banks in Indonesia to become Bank Syariah Indonesia (BSI), which is currently approximately three years old and the Indonesian Sharia banking market until compete and occupy the position as a sharia bank with the most significant asset position compared to 6 (six) other conventional banks which have dominated the Indonesian market for decades. The type of data used in this research is qualitative data, with the data source coming from secondary sources and the data collection technique used being a documentation technique through literature review using the Systematic Literature Review (SLR) data analysis technique by utilizing the Published or Perish (POP) metadata tool and VOS Viewer. The research method used is a qualitative method, with research results showing that the leadership model of Bank Syariah Indonesia has accommodated the best leadership criteria in Islam, which can be adaptive, fast response, and solutions while still implementing the traits and characteristics of leaders who are sincere, trustworthy, Katonah, and tabligh. This leadership character was demonstrated by leading the previous three large banks into one with one vision, mission, and work culture, as well as the synergy of all human resources that supported joint achievements to success in the three years of its existence.

Green awareness and green product: a direction for sustainable consumption

Various parties are trying to prevent and overcome this problem in various ways. People are beginning to receive news, invites, education, and ads to raise their awareness of environmental sustainability. Consumers are becoming more conscious of the damaging effects that their purchases have on the environment. With green awareness increasing among consumers, they take steps to support the sustainability of the environment, one way is to use environmentally friendly products or green products. This study aims to find out how trends in research on how green awareness encourage consumer interest in buying and using green products. Descriptive bibliometric analysis is the research methodology employed. The Scopus database was utilized by researchers to locate data. Through four refinement procedures (identification, screening, eligibility assessment, and inclusion), 102 publishing data were acquired. The VOS Viewer tool will be used to examine the data. Compared to previous years, 2022 has published the most articles (28 publications). Citation trends related to green awareness and green products occurred in 2016 with 456 citations. China is the most influential nation in this field, with 29 publications and 14 connections to international collaboration. Research on Green Products and Green Awareness is centered on 1) consumption, green consumption, and manufacturer; 2) green purchase behavior, green purchase, and environmental knowledge; 3) policy maker, TPB, and perception.

Green Economy: Sistematic Literatur Review

This research aims to reveal how research topics and issues regarding the Green Economy are developing. The research method used was Systematic Literature Review (SLR) with VOS Viewer Data Analysis Software. The articles reviewed were 429 articles sourced from the Scopus database. The research results show that the development of research topics and issues regarding the Green Economy reflects a positive evolution in understanding of environmental and sustainability challenges in the context of the global economy. Involving researchers from various countries, this research focuses on topic clusters that develop along with socio-economic needs and dynamics. Wang J., as the main contributor with the largest number of articles, discusses major issues such as environmental pollution, carbon emissions, and environmentally friendly tourism.

Bibliometric analysis of peer-reviewed literature on perinatal depression in Mexico

Background. Perinatal depression (PND) is a clinical disease developed in any stage during the pregnancy and postpartum period with serious health and economic implications. Objective. The aim of this work was to analyze via bibliometrics indicators Mexico’s production on PND to provide a view of the academic landscape and a comprehensive reference for subsequent research in the country. Method. The Scopus and Web of Science (WoS) databases were used to perform a search for peer reviewed papers related to PND in México. The search was made following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA). The extracted data were processed with VOS Viewer to examine link strength and clusters associations of diverse bibliometrics variables. Results. A total of 132 records were retrieved and we included 70 studies in the bibliometric analysis after application of the exclusion criteria. The authors with more papers were Navarrete L., and Asunción Lara M. The institutions with more papers were the National Institute of Perinatology, Ramón de la Fuente National Institute of Psychiatry, and National Institute of Public Health of Mexico. A diminution of the research considered in PND is observed in the last two years. Four keyword clusters were identified related to PND: symptoms, prevalence, pregnancy. Discussion and conclusion. The scarce literature concerning PND in Mexico compared with other countries could be due the limited collaboration between the health institutes. An urgent need to increase research on PND in Mexico is evident to be applicable in the management of resources in the healthcare system.

Knowledge Management Systems in Higher Education: A Comprehensive Study through Systematic Literature Review and Bibliometric Analysis (2019-2023)

The objective of this study is to critically examine the existing body of literature on Knowledge Management Systems (KMS) in the context of higher education. The research employed the PRISMA technique (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) together with a bibliometric approach and computational mapping analysis utilizing VOS Viewer. The study period used as literature data material is Scopus-indexed articles and conference papers from 2019 to 2023. The keywords used were "knowledge, management, system, and higher education". From 313 references that were considered relevant, data reduction was carried out with inclusion and exclusion criteria. Analysis was conducted on 10 articles with the highest number of citations and 5 articles that specifically used the keyword "human resource management". The findings of this study offer a comprehensive outline for future research on human resource management in higher education, specifically focusing on knowledge management systems.

Developing Critical Thinking Indicators and Research Trends in Islamic Religious Education with VOSviewer

This research aims to develop indicators of students' critical thinking and find the state of the art by using Vos Viewer. One way to develop critical thinking indicators is through research. The teacher's job besides teaching is to conduct research. Research is said to be good if it finds elements of new findings so that it has a contribution both to science and to life. One of the difficulties in research is finding novelty, nowadays with the Vos Viewer application it is easy to find the novelty of a research variable, such as the critical thinking variable. The research subject is students in Islamic educational institutions. The object or focus of the research is to develop indicators of students' critical thinking in learning Islamic religious education. In addition, the research aims to analyze the opportunities and development of research trends related to critical thinking in Islamic learning. This research is important as a way to help Islamic religious education teachers develop critical thinking indicators as an effort to familiarize students with reading literacy and numeracy in accordance with the demands of the independent curriculum. The method used is bibliometric by collecting article data from 2018-2022 through Google Scholar and Scopus sites with Publish or Perish software for 1,000 journals. The results of the study describe that critical thinking indicators can be developed through familiarizing students with analyzing, evaluating, and analyzing.

A comprehensive mixed-methods study on cross-border e-commerce SMEs, digital transformation and dynamic managerial capabilities

The development of the digital trade ecosystem heavily relies on the expansion of cross-border e-commerce (CBEC) platforms. CBEC companies are actively involved in digital transformation (DT) initiatives to bolster their core competencies and market share. E-commerce has experienced rapid growth in recent years, particularly since the global market faced significant disruptions due to the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. As the market continues to globalize, more Chinese entrepreneurs are shifting their focus towards the international arena. They aim to increase investments in high-tech productivity within their organizations while also concentrating on enhancing their dynamic managerial capabilities to drive transformation within cross-border e-commerce companies. Therefore, the current study examines how organizational DT impacts the management capabilities of Chinese cross-border e-commerce managers from the perspective of dynamic managerial capabilities. The research employed a mixed-method approach. Firstly, a bibliometric analysis was conducted using VOS Viewer and R studio. Data was collected from two databases, Web of Science and Scopus, to analyze publication trends across countries and identify journals with the highest number of publications and citations. This analysis aimed to provide a comprehensive understanding of the context of the subject. Secondly, seven in-depth interviews were conducted using purposive and chain-referral sampling techniques, drawing insights from CEOs based on their real-life experiences with organizational DT. The results of the study revealed that technology has led to the decentralization and flattening of organizational structures. Managers are increasingly using social platforms to connect with experts and potential collaborators. Furthermore, the study highlights the role of psychological support in bolstering dynamic managerial capabilities.

Navigating the Nexus between Rural Revitalization and Sustainable Development: A Bibliometric Analyses of Current Status, Progress, and Prospects

Achieving sustainable rural development is challenging. However, revitalizing the rural economy is one of the most suitable strategies to overcome sustainable development problems. The rural revitalization strategy aims to create an idealized sustainable development model for rural areas which can avoid the current crisis and utilize institutional advantages to overcome the survival challenges of mostly small-scale peasant economies. The logic of the rural revitalization strategy lies in its essential value implication and practical orientation for consolidating the foundation in rural areas, including its characteristics and its ability to realize long-term sustainable development. There is growing interest in research on rural revitalization and sustainable development, but the current status, trends, and progress are unknown. This study examines the most recent advancements in research patterns for rural revitalization and the promotion of sustainable development from 1995 to 2023. It accomplishes this by thoroughly evaluating and analyzing published scholarly material. We performed a bibliometric analysis of the literature obtained from the Scopus database using VOS Viewer software version 1.6.15. We examined a total of 403 articles and evaluated them, focusing on the precise terms “Rural Revitalization” and “Sustainable Development”. We found that post-2018, there has been a notable surge in the popularity and acceptance of research related to these topics. China ranks first in terms of publishing the greatest number of research articles. The journal Sustainability has published the most articles on sustainable development and rural revitalization, followed by Land and the International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. The Journal of Rural Studies published the most cited document. Exciting research areas include the conservation of natural resources, ecosystem cities, and rural revitalization strategies. The research findings thoroughly evaluate academic output and propose thematic areas for further investigation.

The relationship between kidney disease and mitochondria: a bibliometric study

Background Due to its highly reabsorptive function, the kidney is a mitochondria-dependent organ. Research on the association between mitochondria and kidney disease has always been a serious focus of researchers, with many publications. Bibliometrics is a secondary analysis of published literature that extracts relevant information to gain insights into hotspots and trends in the field. Through bibliometric analysis, we aimed to understand the development trends and hotspots in the field of research on the association between kidney disease and mitochondria. Method Three bibliometric mapping tools (Biblimetrix R Package, VOS Viewer, CiteSpace) were used to provide an overview of the literature and analyze the co-occurrence of keywords and reference citations. Results A total of 2672 relevant research articles were included. The co-occurrence network identified three clusters related to the association between mitochondria and kidney disease, including experimental methods, research mechanisms, and disease phenotypes. We found that research in this field has shifted from disease-level studies to mechanism-based studies, with the most prominent disease being diabetic nephropathy and the most prominent pathogenic mechanism being related to mitochondrial ROS production. Conclusion The bibliometric analysis provided a comprehensive understanding of the progress of research on the role of mitochondria in kidney disease, enriching the review literature in this field.

Global Growth and Trends of In-Body Communication Research—Insight From Bibliometric Analysis

A bibliometric analysis was conducted to examine research on in-body communication. This study aimed to assess the research growth in different countries, identify influential authors for potential international collaboration, investigate research challenges, and explore future prospects for in-body communication. A total of 148 articles written in English from journals and conference proceedings were gathered from the Scopus database. These articles cover the period from 2006 until August 2023. VOS Viewer 1.6.19 and Tableau Cloud were used to analyze the data. The analysis reveals that research on in-body communication has shown fluctuations but overall tends to increase. The United States, Finland, and Japan were identified as the leading countries (top three) in terms of publication quantity, while researchers from Norway, Finland, and Morocco received the highest number of citations. The University of Oulu in Finland has emerged as a productive institution in this field. Collaborative research opportunities exist with the countries mentioned above or with authors who have expertise in this topic. The dominant research topic within this field pertains to ultra-wideband (UWB) technology. One of the future challenges in this field is the exploration of optical wireless communication (OWC) as a potential communication medium for in-body devices, such as electronic devices implanted in the human body. This includes improving performance to meet the requirements for in-body communication devices. Additionally, this paper provides further insights into the progress of research on OWC for in-body communication conducted in our laboratory.

Public Service Innovation in Indonesia 2013-2023: Combination Analysis of Open Knowledge Map and VOSViewer

Public service innovation is important to overcome the imbalance between human resources and the high level of demand for services by the community. However, this is still not understood by public sector organizations in general. This study is here to examine the dynamics of implementing innovation in Indonesia in the last 10 years. The study was carried out using the literature review search method which combines the Open Knowledge Map (OKM) and Vos Viewer (VV) applications. The data were processed by following the application procedures used, then analyzed by adopting some of the principles of qualitative methods. OKM is used to map public service innovation clusters, while VV’s role is to look at public service innovation clusters with different analyses and sources. The results of the analysis show that innovation in Indonesia is dependent on leadership, which can be an obstacle to the long-term sustainability of innovation. The level of participation and competitiveness of public service innovations has not been evenly distributed throughout Indonesia. There is still a need for strategies and policy directions for collaboration and involvement of the private sector in public service innovation. The combination of digitalization and administration innovations is an innovation that has been carried out in the last 10 years. Barriers to the implementation of public service innovations are generally a problem that often occurs in other public organizations.
 Keywords: innovation, public service, public organization

SWEBoK-based Bibliometric Analysis of Software Engineering

In our research study spanning 2015-2021, we analyzed Software Engineering (SE) across 15 Knowledge Areas (KAs) outlined by SWEBoK. Using Web of Science (WoS) database, we examined 32,232 articles (2015-2017), 31,459 articles (2018-2020), and 6,919 articles (2021). Collaborative and co-word networks were generated using VOS Viewer. Our findings reveal SE's influence in 81 research areas. English dominated, but Spanish and Portuguese were notable. Europe led in publications, with USA and China prominent. Stronger collaboration networks, especially in the USA and China, correlated with increased research output. Asian countries' rise was evident from 2018-2021. Top 10 highly cited papers and co-word analysis were included, aiding researchers and educators. SE's impact crossed domains, enabling cross-disciplinary research and informing educators' course designs. Institutional and country productivity influenced partnerships and academia-industry collaborations. Multinational companies gauged research potential through active countries. Analyzing co-words depicted trends, and highly cited papers set industry standards. Bibliometric analysis offered qualitative and quantitative research evaluation.

A Systematic Review and Bibliometric Analysis on Beekeeping: Using Vos Viewer

A Systematic Review and Bibliometric Analysis on Beekeeping: Using Vos Viewer

Research trends and hotspot evolution of exercise-regulated myokines: a bibliometric analysis from 2003 to 2023.

The lack of physical activity is a common issue in modern society and is considered a major risk factor for various chronic non-communicable diseases. Bioactive factors secreted by skeletal muscle during exercise play a crucial role in inter-organ interactions. Since the concept of "myokines" was proposed in 2004, hundreds of regulatory myokines have been identified. Visual analysis of research on exercise-regulated myokines is significant to explore research hotspots and frontiers in this field. Research literature on exercise-regulated myokines from 2003 to 2023 in the "Web of Science" database was used as the data source. Knowledge maps were drawn using "VOS Viewer, CiteSpace, and R-bibliometrix" software. A total of 1,405 papers were included, showing a fluctuating yet slow growth in annual publications. The United States and China led in the number of publications and collaboration networks. Harvard University ranked first with 120 publications. CIBER (centrality 0.16) and the University of California System (centrality 0.16) were pivotal in advancing this field. PEDERSEN BK led author rankings with 41 publications and 1,952 citations. FRONTIERS IN PHYSIOLOGY ranked first among journals with 64 publications and the highest g-index (39), while PLoS One had the highest h-index (25) and most citations (2,599). Key co-cited reference clusters included #1 skeletal muscle dysfunction, #2 obesity, #6 ASCs, and #7 adaptive immunocytes. Pontus Boström's paper had a notable citation burst intensity of 77.37. High-frequency keywords were "exercise" (509), "skeletal muscle" (452), and "expression" (293), with long-term keywords such as #0 irisin, #2 insulin resistance, #3 transcription, and #6 physical activity. Recently, keywords like "physical exercise," "resistance exercise," "aerobic exercise," "insulin," and "oxidative stress" have emerged. Research in the field of exercise-regulated myokines shows an overall upward trend. The focus areas include myokines mediated by different types of exercise, the interaction of irisin-mediated muscle with other organs, and the important role of myokine-mediated oxidative stress in exercise simulation.

Sustainable Banking: A Literature Review and Bibliometric Analysis

Sustainable banking is a banking model that integrates environmental, social and governance (ESG) criteria into its operations and decision-making processes. It is focused on promoting sustainable development by considering the long-term impact of its activities on society, the economy and the environment. During the beginning of 80’s, the extensive literatures on sustainable banking were unproductive and this issue continues to the end of 2000’s. Based on this situation, the researchers used Bibliometric analysis of various literatures of about 719 studies which includes articles, reviews, conference papers, book chapters from Scopus and Web of Science (WoS) categories during the period 2000–2021. About 2324 studies were identified from the database. To undergo the research, we acknowledged the main domains which are closely related to sustainable banking from its evolution. The main domains such as corporate social responsibility, banking sector, economic growth, ethical banking, financial stability, green banking, sustainable finance, banking industry, banking system, micro finance and banking regulations. Further we mapped with this into VOS Viewer and analysed how these domains can contribute to sustainability in the banking sector. It is found that, several climatic risks are faced by the banking sector all over the world and hence, the financial sector must make necessary alterations to environmentally friendly strategies to climate sensitive sectors. Sustainability is still under a question mark in the banking sector as several advancements are being introduced not only in technology but also in physical appearance day by day. Finally, to say, the banks must engage in green sustainable strategies towards sustainable banking in the banking industry.

Current status and future of cancer vaccines: A bibliographic study

BackgroundCancer vaccines are an important component of tumour immunotherapy. An increasing number of studies have shown that cancer vaccines have considerable clinical benefits. With the development of tumour precision medicine, cancer vaccines have become important because of their individualised targeting effects. However, few bibliometric studies have conducted comprehensive systematic reviews in this field. This study aimed to assess the scientific output and trends in cancer vaccine research from a global perspective. MethodsWe collected publications on cancer vaccines from the Web of Science Core Collection database, which was limited to articles and reviews in English. Microsoft Excel, VOS Viewer, and CiteSpace V were used for quantitative and visual analyses. ResultsA total of 7807 articles were included. From 1991 to 2022, the number of publications increased annually. The United States had the highest number of articles published in this field (48.28 %), the highest citation frequency (183,964 times), and the highest H-index (182). The National Institutes of Health topped the list with 476 articles. Schlom J had the highest number of published articles (128) and was the main investigator in this field. The journal, Cancer Immunology Immunotherapy, had published the highest number of articles in related fields. In recent years, tumour microenvironment, immune checkpoint inhibitors, particle vaccines, tumour antigens, and dendritic cells have become research hotspots related to cancer vaccines. ConclusionCancer vaccines are a popular research topic in the field of tumour immunotherapy. Related research and publications will enter a boom stage. “Immune checkpoint inhibitors”, “tumour microenvironment” and “dendritic cells” may become future research hotspots, while “T-cell suppressor” is a potential puzzle to be solved.

An Overview of Publications on Extracellular Vesicles in Osteoarthritis from 2012 to 2022: A Bibliometric Analysis

Background. Extracellular vesicles, particularly those derived from stem cells, have demonstrated promising potential in osteoarthritis in recent years. However, there has been no bibliometric analysis focusing on the relationship between extracellular vesicles and osteoarthritis. This study aimed to investigate trends and hotpots of publications on extracellular vesicles in osteoarthritis. Methods. This study collected publications on extracellular vesicles in osteoarthritis from the Web of Science Core Collection database, focusing on English‐language articles and reviews. Quantitative and visual analysis was performed using Microsoft Excel, R shiny, SCImago Graphica, VOS Viewer, and CiteSpace. The data set comprised information on keywords, authors, institutions, journals, and the country or region of the included literature. Journal impact factors and H‐index values were obtained from the 2021 Journal Citation Reports and SJR‐International Science Ranking. Furthermore, we conducted a frequency analysis of annual publications number and fitting curves of the growth trends in the publications. Moreover, we conducted a citation burst analysis of the top 20 keywords and a related bibliometric analysis (word frequency analysis and cocitation analysis) using CiteSpace. Results. A total of 715 documents were analyzed. The number of publications increased annually from 2012 to 2022. China had the highest number (n = 394, 55.1%) of publications and total citations during the decade, followed by the United States (n = 105, 14.7%). Shanghai JiaoTong University contributed the highest number of publications (n = 28, 3.9%). Wang Y has the highest number of publications (n = 40, 5.6%), and Stem Cell Research & Therapy is the journal with the highest number of publications (n = 64, 9.0%). The hotspots of extracellular vesicle research in recent years are umbilical cord blood, drug delivery, and scaffolds. Conclusion. Our findings indicate an increase in publications on the topic in utilizing extracellular vesicles in the context of osteoarthritis. Extracellular vesicle therapy for cartilage regeneration and repair of bone defects in osteoarthritis holds significant potential. Future research will focus on the development of novel drug delivery systems that utilize extracellular vesicles, the creation of novel biomaterials that incorporate extracellular vesicles, and the potential of extracellular vesicles as early diagnostic markers of disease.

Global evolution of nanotechnology research with special emphasis on health sciences : A bibliometric approach

Purpose: The scientific impact of every scientific publication is widely measured through bibliometric analysis. In this article we have conducted evidence-based bibliometric analysis of articles on nanotechnology. Literature on nanotechnology applications that has been published in journals across all fields of science and technology. The data is retrived from Medline database via Pubmed., Total 267 publications were retrieved and analyzed, The New England Journal of Medicine achieved the highest citation, “Corcoy Rosa” is the most productive author. Most of the publications are classified as Randomized controlled trials, despite this, there hasn’t been a lot of indepth research on the publication trends of nanotechnology in journals of the health sciences. Objective: The objective of this study was to evaluate the publication trends in the field of Nanotechnology with special emphasis on health sciences. Methods: The data was acquired from the MEDLINE database via PubMed on January 4, 2021, covering the years 2001 through 2020. The articles were sorted according to the Publication Type, Number of Publications (Pub), Relative Citation Ratio (RCR) and Total Citations (TC) influence. The tables are created in excel spread sheet which is download from “iCite” tool. Highly cited journals and author tables are created usning “VOS Viewer” visualization bibliometric tool. Findings: A total number of 267 records were retrieved, and a systematic review was carried out over 20 years between 2001 and 2020. The total number of RCR and citations are 545.44 and 5307 respectively. The New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) received more citation which is n=214. “Corcoy Rosa” was the most productive author during the study period, with n=9 publications with 608 citations aggregated. Most of the publications are classified as Randomized controlled trials, which account for 37% of all publications retrieved. The year 2019 has the most publications, with a total of n=29. European countries have leading publications and authors in this field of research; however, the rest of the world needs to apply more concentration to improve the development of this field. Limitations: The study was limited to twenty years period from 2001 to 2020, and the data was obtained from single database PubMed.