MLR, 96.I, 200I MLR, 96.I, 200I documented and Nodnagel's presentation compared with Bettine's selfpresentation . Bettine'smother Maximiliane, and her sisterSophie, are the focus of an essay by Ursula Puschel, who transcribesan interestingmanuscript,Lebensregeln, written for Sophie by Maximiliane, which offersinsight into the Brentano family patriarchy, but follows this with pedestrian comments that merely reinforce establishedviews of theprotagonists.Essaysby UlrikeLandfesterandJudith Purver give biographicaland bibliographicalinformationon lesswell-knownwomen of the restorationperiod:Anna von Arnim, Bettine'sdaughter-in-law,whose correspondence with her husband Freimunddocuments the events of I848 and offersinsight into the Arnim familycircle, and Caroline Auguste Fischer,whose short storiesare shown to representa specificallyfemale voice of the times throughcomparisonand contrast with Kleist's stories and the Grimms' Mdrchen. Forgotten males of the period are spotlighted by Wolfgang Bunzel, who edits the correspondence of two Young Hegelians, Eduard Meyen and Arnold Ruge, importantin their time, who contributed to the public debate. The letters refer constantly to this debate and thereforehave a high informationvalue. Roger Paulin investigates nineteenth-century expeditions to New Zealand and discusses the now forgotten explorer Andreas Reischek's Sterbende Welt as a contemporaryculturaldocument. The volume also containscontributionson Polish and Dutch Romanticism (Marek Zybura and Carel ter Haar), both of which are probably relativelyunknown to Germanistsand so offernew comparative sources. Each contributorgoes beyond the purely descriptiveto consider certainissuestheir particular comparison raises. Walter Schmitz's contribution is also comparative in nature. He analyses the presentation of society and art in Mdrchenby E. T. A. Hoffnann, Hans ChristianAndersen and the neglected Wilhelm Hauff, to identifycertaincommon thematic complexes. The new, the little-known,and the foreignprovide usefulnew sourcematerialon nineteenth-centuryliteratureand culture in this collection of essays. Commentary on thesetextsprovidesfurthercontextualmaterialand offersinterpretativeavenues. Forthese reasonsthis volume is a worthwhileventure and the overallqualityof the contributionsmakesit a solid collection of scholarship. UNIVERSITY OF STRATHCLYDE SHEILA DICKSON Zwischen Metaphysik undPolitik.7Thomas MannsRomanJosephundseineBriider' in seiner Zeit. By DIERKWOLTERS.Tubingen: Niemeyer. 1998. 331 pp. DM 96. It is tempting to think of Thomas Mann's Josephtetralogy as an escape, from the threateningpolitical and personal upheavalsof the period 1926 to 1942 in which it was written, into the biblical world of 'Patriarchenluft'(Goethe). It is usually conceded, though, that the last of the four novels, JosephderEmdhrer, reflects something of Mann's fascinationin exile with Roosevelt and his New Deal and has acquireda more obviouslypolitical dimension. DierkWolters,however, arguespersuasivelyin thiscomprehensiveand brilliantly written study that by placing the four novels firmly in the changing intellectual, philosophical, and cultural context of the sixteen years of their genesis we can simultaneouslytrace Mann's own intellectual development and understandmuch more how significantthey really are. The core concern of Mann's own intellectual strugglewas the attemptto balance the opposingpull of two complex forceshe liked to conceive of as 'Geist' and 'Leben', or as the title suggests as 'Metaphysik'and 'Politik'. Notwithstanding the terminological awkwardnessof these concepts and their ever-shiftingmeaning, Wolters successfullydemonstratesthat the issues they documented and Nodnagel's presentation compared with Bettine's selfpresentation . Bettine'smother Maximiliane, and her sisterSophie, are the focus of an essay by Ursula Puschel, who transcribesan interestingmanuscript,Lebensregeln, written for Sophie by Maximiliane, which offersinsight into the Brentano family patriarchy, but follows this with pedestrian comments that merely reinforce establishedviews of theprotagonists.Essaysby UlrikeLandfesterandJudith Purver give biographicaland bibliographicalinformationon lesswell-knownwomen of the restorationperiod:Anna von Arnim, Bettine'sdaughter-in-law,whose correspondence with her husband Freimunddocuments the events of I848 and offersinsight into the Arnim familycircle, and Caroline Auguste Fischer,whose short storiesare shown to representa specificallyfemale voice of the times throughcomparisonand contrast with Kleist's stories and the Grimms' Mdrchen. Forgotten males of the period are spotlighted by Wolfgang Bunzel, who edits the correspondence of two Young Hegelians, Eduard Meyen and Arnold Ruge, importantin their time, who contributed to the public debate. The letters refer constantly to this debate and thereforehave a high informationvalue. Roger Paulin investigates nineteenth-century expeditions to New Zealand and discusses the now forgotten explorer Andreas Reischek's Sterbende Welt as a contemporaryculturaldocument. The volume also containscontributionson Polish and Dutch Romanticism (Marek Zybura and Carel ter Haar), both of which are probably relativelyunknown to Germanistsand so offernew comparative sources. Each contributorgoes beyond the purely descriptiveto consider certainissuestheir particular comparison raises. Walter Schmitz's contribution...
Read full abstract