In this study, the enrichment sequencing batch biofilm reactor (SBBR) and conventional enrichment reactor (SBR) were established, and a new strategy was developed to achieve higher biomass yield and polyhydroxyalkanoate (PHA) production from food waste than those achieved through the conventional method. After the 10th day of an expanded cultivation period, the respective active biomass concentrations in SBR and SBBR were 5.16 and 13.92 g/L, indicating a significant improvement in the biomass yield of mixed microbial culture in the SBBR. The PHA accumulation test revealed that maximum PHA concentration in SBR and SBBR reached 6.60 and 12.70 g/L, respectively, after 80 days of enrichment, indicating that compared to SBR, the SBBR could more effectively improve the PHA accumulation capacity. Meganema, Thauera, and Paracoccus were the dominant PHA-accumulating bacteria in the SBR and SBBR. Additionally, the volumetric productivity of the SBBR was 3.22 g COD/L/d, twice that of the SBR. This study provides new strategies and insights for improving PHA production and reducing the costs of PHA production and reactor investment.