Taupō volcano lies underneath the largest lake in New Zealand. It undergoes unrest roughly every ten years, has minor eruptions every few hundred years, and has supereruptions. Understanding volcanic seismic signals provides insights into the volcano dynamics and helps to anticipate eruptions. Harmonic and non-harmonic volcanic tremor are common signals that indicate fluid mobilisation in volcanic systems. We observed a signal that resembled non-harmonic tremor during 2019 at Taupō volcano. Careful time-frequency analysis of seismic data and weather data from around the lake revealed that the signals were not magmatic in origin, but were most likely from lake microseisms caused by special conditions of the wind, which generates wind-driven waves in the lake. The frequency range of lake microseisms at Taupō starts and ends with a dominant frequency of 0.7–1.0 Hz, and during the maximum energy peak, the dominant frequency is of 0.50–0.56 Hz. Such signals may be common in caldera lakes, which need to be distinguished from tremor caused by volcanic activity, so as not to exaggerate the probability of eruptions.