Nineteen taxa representing all six sections and 17 of the 22 species of Lopezia have been examined for restriction site mutations of chloroplast DNA using homologous probes from Lopezia miniata subsp. miniata. Restriction sites were analyzed using maximum parsimony, weighted parsimony, maximum likelihood, and neighbor-joining. The results of these analyses support the monophyly of sect. Riesenbachia. Sections Jehlia and Lopezia may, however, be paraphyletic depending on the placement of L. racemosa subsp. racemosa. Section Nannolopezia is clearly derived from within sect. Lopezia and should be reduced to synonymy. A single reduced consensus cladogram is presented that fails to resolve the placement of sect. Riesenbachia and the placement of L. racemosa subsp. racemosa, L. miniata subsp. miniata, and L. concinna within sect. Lopezia. The chloroplast DNA results indicate that stamens, a means of mechanically depositing pollen on visiting pollinators, have evolved only once in the genus. Hummingbird pollination, which is plesiomorphic in the genus, may have been secondarily regained in sect. Jehlia after its loss to fly pollination. Lopezia (Onagraceae: Lopezieae) consists of 22 species and seven subspecies (26 taxa) unequally divided among six morphologically well-marked sections (Plitmann et al. 1973; Raven 1977, 1988). The genus has been variously divided into several segregate genera in the tribe Lopezieae, primarily by affording the hummingbird-pollinated species generic status because of their striking morphological characteristics (e.g., Munz 1961). Morphological and anatomical studies, however, emphasize similarities and shared features that mark members of the Lopezieae as a monophyletic group better considered a single genus (Eyde and Morgan 1973; Plitmann et al. 1973). Lopezia is distinct in the Onagraceae by possessing a four-merous perianth and a two-merous androecium. The genus is mainly restricted to Mexico, but one species ranges to El Salvador, and a second as far south as Costa Rica (Plitmann et al. 1973). Members of the genus have long attracted interest because of their morphological diversity and intricacy of floral structures (e.g., Bolivar 1940; Baehni and Bonner 1948; Endress 1994). Also of interest is the large range of chromosome numbers (n = 7-11, 20, 22) (Plitmann et al. 1975). Lopezia is an excellent subject for detailed molecular studies because of the large body of information available from morphology (Plitmann et al. 1973, 1975), anatomy (Eyde and Morgan 1973; Eyde 1982), cytology (Plitmann et al. 1975), and ecology (Plitmann et al. 1973, 1975). Previous work and a recent cladistic analysis of morphological characters (Hoch et al. 1993a) supplies a wealth of testable phylogenetic hypotheses. A brief description of the sections of Lopezia (Table 1; Plitmann et al. 1973) illustrates the phenotypic diversity of the genus. Section Diplandra, consisting of L. lopezioides, is monotypic, hummingbird-pollinated, and is unique in the genus in possessing two fertile stamens. All other species have a single fertile stamen and a staminode. Section Riesenbachia consists of two morphologically very distinct species: L. semeiandra is a hummingbirdpollinated shrub, and L. riesenbachia is an autogamous annual herb. The two species, however, share the unique character of a floral tube that is internally divided by a septum forming two deep pockets lined with nectariferous tissue. Section Pelozia contains species that have the upper three sepals and upper two petals adnate at their bases. These species are either outcrossing and fly-pollinated or are primarily autogamous. Section Jehlia consists of three species of hummingbird-pollinated shrubs that have floral parts free above the ovary. In L. grandiflora and L. langmaniae, the stamen and staminode are united at their bases around the style. Section Lopezia s. str. is unique within the genus and the family because of its snapping stamens. In these species the fertile stamen is held under tension by the expanded tip of the subtending staminode. When triggered by a visiting insect, the stamens explosively separate, dusting the venter of the insect with a loose aggregation of pollen held together with viscin threads. Most of these species
Read full abstract