Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever (RMSF) is a tick-borne disease caused by Rickettsia rickettsii (R. rickettsii). RMSF presents after a tick bite with fever, rash, and headache but can also cause more serious neurological manifestations. We report a case of RMSF encephalitis presenting with altered sensorium and rapid progression to coma, fever, and petechial rash, and an magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) brain notable for a "starry sky" pattern. A 61-year-old woman presented with confusion and fever and was diagnosed with a urinary tract infection. Two days later, she became comatose. MRI brain revealed lacunar infarcts in the right centrum semiovale and splenium of the corpus callosum. Lumbar puncture was notable for neutrophilic pleocytosis and elevated protein with negative bacterial and viral cultures. Empiric meningitis therapy was initiated, and she was transferred to our institution. On transfer, she was febrile, comatose, and had a diffuse petechial rash. Repeat MRI brain demonstrated diffuse, innumerable punctate foci of diffusion restriction with susceptibility-weighted signal attenuation throughout cerebral hemispheres in a "starry sky" pattern. Skin biopsy revealed perivascular lymphocytic infiltrates. Serologic RSMF antibody titers were obtained, and doxycycline was initiated for presumed RMSF encephalitis. The family opted to pursue palliative measures, given no clinical improvement. RSMF titers and postmortem PCR from brain tissue were positive for R. rickettsii. This case report highlights the clinical presentation of RMSF encephalitis. RMSF encephalitis should be suspected in a patient presenting with encephalopathy, fever, petechial rash, and MRI brain findings of diffuse punctate foci of diffusion restriction and susceptibility-weighted signal attenuation in a "starry-sky" pattern.