Teachers are subject to exceptionally high vocal stress throughout their lives and have an increased prevalence of voice disorders. The aim of this study was to evaluate the long-term efficiency of voice training in student teachers during their lifelong career as a teacher. In addition, we investigated the relationship between vocal aptitude tests and teachers' vocal health. In a multicentre case-control study, 202 teachers (median age: 48 years, 165 women, 37 men) were examined. The examination consisted of a standardised anamnesis, analysis of the voice, laryngostroboscopy and audiometry. Subjects were attributed to the case group if at least two of the following criteria were met: pathological videolaryngostroboscopic findings, pathological analysis of the voice, subjective vocal complaints. 65/202 teachers were categorised as cases. Comparing the groups, cases were older (p=0.001), worked more often in primary schools (p=0.008) and had more problems with reflux (p=0.002). 63.8% of the controls had completed a vocal aptitude test before starting their studies, compared to 47.6% of the cases (p=0.031). A multivariate analysis showed an OR of 1.6 for developing dysphonia if neither voice training nor a vocal aptitude test has taken place during the course of study. Many risk factors associated with dysphonia in teachers are often difficult or impossible to change. Vocal aptitude tests and voice training during the studies represent a primary prevention of occupational dysphonia in the teaching profession.
Read full abstract