This research provides a comprehensive exploration into sextortion, specifically focusing on adult male victims—an understudied demographic in the realm of Image Based Sexual Abuse. Through seven in-depth interviews, a narrative approach was employed to uncover both objective and subjective victim experiences. While the objective narratives presented a homogeneous storyline, the subjective accounts revealed a profound impact that goes beyond the immediate incident of victimization, deeply influencing respondents' self-perception and outlook towards the future. Key findings highlighted feelings of vulnerability, deception, powerlessness, and self-blame. Concerns regarding the perceived safety of online platforms emerged, emphasizing an urgent need for heightened protection and accountability measures. A significant reluctance among victims to report their experiences was identified, suggesting potential underreporting in official channels. The research underscores the pressing need for specialized therapeutic interventions and enhanced data collection methods to better serve this vulnerable population. In conclusion, this study acts as a foundational piece, urging further research and practical interventions to both diminish sextortion risks and provide robust support for adult male victims.