Vibrational Sum Frequency Generation Spectra Research Articles

Sum frequency generation vibrational spectra of perovskite nanocrystals at the single-nanocrystal and ensemble levels

Determination of molecular structures of organic-inorganic hybrid perovskite (OIHP) nanocrystals at the single-nanocrystal and ensemble levels is essential to understanding the mechanisms responsible for their size-dependent optoelectronic properties and the nanocrystal assembling process, but its detection is still a bit challenging. In this study, we demonstrate that femtosecond sum frequency generation (SFG) vibrational spectroscopy can provide a highly sensitive tool for probing the molecular structures of nanocrystals with a size comparable to the Bohr diameter (∼10 nm) at the single-nanocrystal level. The SFG signals are monitored using the spectral features of the phenyl group in (R-MBA)PbBr3 and (R-MBA)2PbI4 nanocrystals (MBA: methyl-benzyl-ammonium). It is found that the SFG spectra exhibit a strong resonant peak at 3067±3 cm−1 (ν2 mode) and a weak shoulder peak at 3045±4 cm−1 (ν7a mode) at the ensemble level, whereas a peak of the ν2 mode and a peak at 3025±3 cm−1 (ν20b mode) at the single-nanocrystal level. The nanocrystals at the single-nanocrystal level tend to lie down on the surface, but stand up as the ensemble number and the averaged sizes increase. This finding may provide valuable information on the structural origins for size-dependent photo-physical properties and photoluminescence blinking dynamics in nanocrystals.

Vibrational Sum Frequency Generation Spectroscopy of Surface Hydroxyls on Nickel Phyllosilicate Nanoscrolls.

Phyllosilicate clays are layered structures with diverse nanoscale morphology depending on the composition. Size mismatch between the sheets can cause them to form nanoscrolls, a spiral structure with different inner and outer surface charges. The hydroxyls on the exposed surface of the nanoscrolls determine the adsorption properties and hydrophilicity of the surface. Vibrational sum frequency generation (VSFG) spectroscopy was applied to study the surface hydroxyls of nickel phyllosilicate (Ni3Si2O5(OH)4), revealing three distinct in-phase OH-stretch modes: 3642, 3645, and 3653 cm-1. The relative signs of the peaks allow their assignment as "outward" and "inward" pointing hydroxyls on the opposite sides of the scrolled sheet, consistent with the crystal structure. Orientational analysis of polarization-selected VSFG spectra is consistent with a broad (140-164°) step-function distribution of the OH-stretch tilt angles, which we attribute to the uncompensated portion of the scroll rolled more than a whole number of full turns.

Wettability of graphene and interfacial water structure

<h2>Summary</h2> Understanding the wettability of graphene is important for various applications, such as water desalination, energy storage, and catalysis. However, the detailed water hydrogen-bonding structure at the water-graphene interface is not yet fully understood. Using vibrational sum-frequency-generation (VSFG) spectroscopy, we elucidate the water structure at a water-graphene interface. As the number of graphene layers increases, water molecules with dangling OH groups become more populated, indicating the transition from transparency to translucency. We compare the water contact angles on the graphene surfaces with VSFG results, showing an excellent correlation between the water adhesion energy of graphene and the fraction of dangling OH groups estimated from the VSFG spectrum. This observation suggests that the VSFG could be an incisive technique for measuring water's adhesion energy on any spatially confined interface where the water contact angle cannot be measured. We anticipate that the VSFG results will help to elucidate the wettability of low-dimensional materials. <h3>Video Abstract</h3>

The interaction of chondroitin sulfate with a lipid monolayer observed by using nonlinear vibrational spectroscopy.

The first vibrational sum-frequency generation (VSFG) spectra of chondroitin sulfate (CS) interacting with dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine (DPPC) at air–liquid interface are reported here, collected at a laser repetition rate of 100 kHz. By studying the VSFG spectra in the regions of 1050–1450 cm−1, 2750–3180 cm−1, and 3200–3825 cm−1, it was concluded that in the presence of Ca2+ ions, the head groups together with the head-group-bound water molecules in the DPPC monolayer are strongly influenced by the interaction with CS, while the organization of the phospholipid tails remains mostly unchanged. The interactions were observed at a CS concentration below 200 nM, which exemplifies the potential of VSFG in studying biomolecular interactions at low physiological concentrations. The VSFG spectra recorded in the O–H stretching region at chiral polarization combination imply that CS molecules are organized into ordered macromolecular superstructures with a chiral secondary structure.

Structure and sum-frequency generation spectra of water on neutral hydroxylated silica surfaces.

Structural organization and vibrational sum-frequency generation (VSFG) spectra of water on crystalline and amorphous neutral silica surfaces were investigated by classical molecular dynamics simulations. The liquid phase represented with neat water and 1 M NaCl solution was analysed in terms of bonded interfacial layer (BIL), diffuse layer (DL) and bulk region. The simulations show that the structure of BIL depends on the surface morphology and density of surface OH groups. The water-silanol H-bond network and BIL structure are mainly insensitive to the presence of ions in the liquid phase. Molecules in DL of SiO2/neat water interfaces preferentially orient their OH bonds towards the surfaces. This effect is directly related to an effective negative charge of formally neutral surfaces. Ions of the electrolyte solution affect the intermolecular structure in DL by screening the surface electric field and by the chaotropic effect. Calculated phase-sensitive VSFG (Im[χ(2)]) spectrum of BIL features low-frequency negative and high-frequency positive bands. Characteristics of the positive band reflect the strength of water-surface interactions and surface crystallinity, while the position and shape of the negative band are common to all interfaces. The Im[χ(2)] spectrum of DL is dominated by a contribution from the third-order χ(3) susceptibility with the sign of the contribution directly related to the sign of electrostatic potential in the interfacial region. The DL spectrum is strongly affected by the presence of solvated ions. The computed intensity and Im[χ(2)] spectra of the amorphous silica/NaCl solution interface are in a good agreement with the conventional and phase-sensitive experimental VSFG spectra of fused SiO2/water system at low pH, in contrast to the spectra of the amorphous silica/neat water interface. Origins of the discrepancy are discussed.

Structural Effects of Cation Binding to DPPC Monolayers.

Ions at the two sides of the plasma membrane maintain the transmembrane potential, participate in signaling, and affect the properties of the membrane itself. The extracellular leaflet is particularly enriched in phosphatidylcholine lipids and under the influence of Na+, Ca2+, and Cl- ions. In this work, we combined molecular dynamics simulations performed using state-of-the-art models with vibrational sum frequency generation (VSFG) spectroscopy to study the effects of these key ions on the structure of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine. We used lipid monolayers as a proxy for membranes, as this approach enabled a direct comparison between simulation and experiment. We find that the effects of Na+ are minor. Ca2+, on the other hand, strongly affects the lipid headgroup conformations and induces a tighter packing of lipids, thus promoting the liquid condensed phase. It does so by binding to both the phosphate and carbonyl oxygens via direct and water-mediated binding modes, the ratios of which depend on the monolayer packing. Clustering analysis performed on simulation data revealed that changes in area per lipid or CaCl2 concentration both affect the headgroup conformations, yet their effects are anticorrelated. Cations at the monolayer surface also attract Cl-, which at large CaCl2 concentrations penetrates deep to the monolayer. This phenomenon coincides with a radical change in the VSFG spectra of the phosphate group, thus indicating the emergence of a new binding mode.

Wettability of Graphene and Interfacial Water Structure

Understanding the graphene-water interaction, referred to as ‘wettability,’ is important for various applications, such as water desalination, filtration, energy storage, and catalysis. However, most studies on graphene's wettability have been performed with either macroscopic water contact angle measurements or molecular dynamics simulations. The detailed hydrogen-bonding network structure of water molecules at the graphene-water interface has not been fully understood at the molecular level. Here, using vibrational sum frequency generation (VSFG) spectroscopy, we elucidate the interfacial water structure and graphene hydrophobicity at a multilayer graphene-water interface. As the number of graphene layers increases, water molecules with dangling OH group become more populated. We compare the contact angles of water on the multilayer graphene surfaces with VSFG results. An excellent correlation between water adhesion energy of graphene and fraction of dangling OH groups estimated from the water OH stretch VSFG spectrum is established. This observation suggests that the VSFG could be an incisive technique for measuring water's adhesion energy on any spatially confined or blocked surface where the water contact angle cannot be measured. We further anticipate that the VSFG result on the transition from wetting transparency to translucency upon increasing the number of graphene layers will be used to understand the wettability of low-dimensional materials and the role of water structure on electric double layers of graphene-based electrodes.

Resolving the Controversy over Dipole versus Quadrupole Mechanism of Bend Vibration of Water in Vibrational Sum Frequency Generation Spectra.

Recently, there has been controversy over whether the HOH bend signal of water in the vibrational sum frequency generation (VSFG) spectrum arises from the conventional dipole mechanism or the quadrupole mechanism. Here, we show that the Im χ(2) (the imaginary part of the second-order nonlinear susceptibility) spectra of the HOH bend mode of water at oppositely charged monolayer/water interfaces all exhibit positive bands, irrespective of the difference in the sign of the charge at the interface. Furthermore, it is found that the peak frequency of the HOH bend band substantially changes depending on the chemical structure of the charged headgroup located at the interface. These results demonstrate that the VSFG signal of the HOH bend vibration is generated from interfacial water with the interfacial quadrupole mechanism that is associated with the large field gradient of incident lights localized in a very thin region at the interface.

Vibrational Sum Frequency Generation Study of the Interference Effect on a Thin Film of 4,4'-Bis(N-carbazolyl)-1,1'-biphenyl (CBP) and Its Interfacial Orientation.

Molecular organization of vapor-deposited organic molecules in the active layer of organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs) has been a matter of great interest as it directly influences various optoelectronic properties and the overall performance of the devices. Contrary to the general assumption of isotropic molecular orientation in vacuum-deposited thin-film OLEDs, it is possible to achieve an anisotropic molecular distribution at or near the surface under controlled experimental conditions. In this study, we have used interface-specific vibrational sum frequency generation (VSFG) spectroscopy to determine the orientation of a low-molecular weight OLED material, 4,4'-bis(N-carbazolyl)-1,1'-biphenyl (CBP), at free (air) and buried (CaF2) interfaces. VSFG spectra were measured at four different polarization combinations for five different thicknesses of the CBP film. The spectral shift and VSFG intensity changes with the film thickness can be accurately modeled by considering the optical interference effect of the signals coming from the CBP/air and CBP/CaF2 interfaces. A global fitting of the experimental spectra for all thicknesses along with theoretical simulations reveal that the long molecular axis of CBP is oriented at an angle of ∼58° (47-70°) from the surface normal at the air/CBP interface, whereas at the CBP/CaF2 interface, the angle is ∼48° (43-52°). Such a change in the angle (∼10°) suggests that the CBP molecule tends to orient more vertically (edge-on) at the buried CaF2 interface, which may be attributed to the intermolecular π-π stacking interaction between adjacent CBP molecules.

Structure Determination of Hen Egg-White Lysozyme Aggregates Adsorbed to Lipid/Water and Air/Water Interfaces.

We use vibrational sum-frequency generation (VSFG) spectroscopy to study the structure of hen egg-white lysozyme (HEWL) aggregates adsorbed to DOPG/D2O and air/D2O interfaces. We find that aggregates with a parallel and antiparallel β-sheet structure together with smaller unordered aggregates and a denaturated protein are adsorbed to both interfaces. We demonstrate that to retrieve this information, fitting of the VSFG spectra is essential. The number of bands contributing to the VSFG spectrum might be misinterpreted, due to interference between peaks with opposite orientation and a nonresonant background. Our study identified hydrophobicity as the main driving force for adsorption to the air/D2O interface. Adsorption to the DOPG/D2O interface is also influenced by hydrophobic interaction; however, electrostatic interaction between the charged protein's groups and the lipid's headgroups has the most significant effect on the adsorption. We find that the intensity of the VSFG spectrum at the DOPG/D2O interface is strongly enhanced by varying the pH of the solution. We show that this change is not due to a change of lysozyme's and its aggregates' charge but due to dipole reorientation at the DOPG/D2O interface. This finding suggests that extra care must be taken when interpreting the VSFG spectrum of proteins adsorbed at the lipid/water interface.

Nuclear Quantum Effect on the χ(2) Band Shape of Vibrational Sum Frequency Generation Spectra of Normal and Deuterated Water Surfaces.

In the vibrational sum frequency generation (VSFG) spectrum of the air/water interface, there is an open question whether the imaginary spectrum of nonlinear susceptibility Im[χ(2)] has a positive band in the low-frequency tail of the OH stretching band. We previously elucidated by molecular dynamics (MD) analysis of the VSFG spectrum that the positive band could arise from particularly strong hydrogen-bonded water pairs at the water surface. This mechanism should be emphasized in OD stretching in comparison to OH, because OD forms stronger hydrogen bonds. Therefore, we calculated the Im[χ(2)] spectra of normal and deuterated water surfaces by MD simulation including the nuclear quantum effect and demonstrated that the low-frequency positive feature could arise in the tail of the OD stretching band. This positive feature is sensitive to the oxygen-oxygen distance of hydrogen-bonding pairs at the surface and hence the temperature and disappears with increasing temperature.

Quadrupolar mechanism for vibrational sum frequency generation at air/liquid interfaces: Theory and experiment

Vibrational sum frequency generation (VSFG) spectroscopy has been widely utilized to investigate various interfaces through molecular vibration. VSFG is usually attributed to the breakdown of the inversion symmetry at the interface within the electric dipole approximation. Although the electric dipole approximation is a very good approximation in the isotropic bulk, its validity is questionable at the interface because a large electric field gradient exists in the thin interface region. Thus, the quadrupole contribution may become significant at the interface. Here, we discuss the quadrupole contribution in VSFG from theoretical and experimental viewpoints. We describe a theory as to how the quadrupole contribution appears in experimental VSFG spectra by deriving the vibrational selection rule and discussing the interface selectivity. With this theoretical framework, we examine the mechanism of VSFG at the air/benzene and air/decane interfaces. The accurate determination of the vibrational frequencies realized by heterodyne-detected VSFG spectroscopy reveals that VSFG at the air/benzene interface arises from the quadrupolar mechanism. This means that the observation of VSFG does not imply a molecular alignment so that interfacial benzene molecules may be randomly oriented. Meanwhile, at the air/decane interface, it is concluded that the VSFG signal arises from the ordinary dipolar mechanism. This implies that decane molecules are aligned in a preferential direction at the interface despite their low polarity. This study demonstrates the importance of examining the mechanism of VSFG before discussing the interfacial structure based on VSFG spectra. A strategy to distinguish different mechanisms is also proposed. The present study further shows that the quadrupolar mechanism, if properly taken into consideration, enables us to obtain information about interfacial molecules beyond the restriction of the inversion symmetry breaking required by the dipolar mechanism, through the large electric field gradient localized at the interface.

Local Ordering of Lattice Self-Assembled SDS@2β-CD Materials and Adsorbed Water Revealed by Vibrational Sum Frequency Generation Microscope.

VSFG (vibrational sum frequency generation) microscopy was used to study the SDS@2β-CD system, a synthetic capsid-like self-assembled material. We found because of strong hydrogen-bond interactions between water and the assemblies, water molecules are template to adopt the local mesoscopic ordering of the self-assemblies, which allows VSFG to probe water on nonflat interfaces. We show that the origin of the VSFG signal from the self-assembly is a combination of individual molecular chirality and highly coordinated ordering of the self-assembly, which gives rise of anisotropic signals, e.g., under SSS polarization. A similar strategy could be applied to other self-assembled materials composed by molecules without inversion symmetry. Using an imaging process, VSFG spectra of different self-assembly sheets were spatially resolved. We found heterogeneity among different domains, which can be attributed to variations in the hydration level of different domains. Since the SDS@2β-CD system is a synthetic lattice self-assembly, such heterogeneity could also exist in other natural lattice assemblies such as a virus and tubulin.

Effect of Frequency-Dependent Fresnel Factor on the Vibrational Sum Frequency Generation Spectra for Liquid/Solid Interfaces

Vibrational sum frequency generation (VSFG) spectroscopy is a powerful tool for selective probing of interfaces based on second-order nonlinear optics. The line shapes of observed VSFG spectra are governed by second-order nonlinear susceptibility as well as Fresnel factors for constituent light fields. Hence, determination of the second-order nonlinear susceptibility requires exact knowledge about the Fresnel factors for the light fields. However, the latter has been less examined than the former for interpretation of VSFG spectra to date and is sometimes hard to calculate due to a lack of optical constants, especially in the infrared regions. The present work employs ATR-IR measurements and model fitting to determine the complex refractive indices of organic solvents and clarifies the effect of the Fresnel factor on the line shape analysis of VSFG spectra. As an example, we determine the complex refractive indices of organic carbonates, which are typical solvents for lithium-ion battery, in the C═O and C...

Heterodyne transient vibrational SFG to reveal molecular responses to interfacial charge transfer.

We demonstrate heterodyne detected transient vibrational sum frequency generation (VSFG) spectroscopy and use it to probe transient electric fields caused by interfacial charge transfer at organic semiconductor and metal interfaces. The static and transient VSFG spectra are composed of both non-resonant and molecular resonant responses. To further disentangle both contributions, we apply phase rotation to make the imaginary part of the spectra be purely molecular responses and the real part of the spectra be dominated by non-resonant signals. By separating non-resonant and molecular signals, we can track their responses to the transient electric-fields at interfaces independently. This technique combined with the phase sensitivity gained by heterodyne detection allows us to successfully identify three types of photoinduced dynamics at organic semiconductor/metal interfaces: coherent artifacts, optical excitations that do not lead to charge transfer, and direct charge transfers. The ability to separately follow the influence of built-in electric fields to interfacial molecules, regardless of strong non-resonant signals, will enable tracking of ultrafast charge dynamics with molecular specificities on molecular optoelectronics, photovoltaics, and solar materials.

Simplified sum frequency generation using a narrow free-spectral-range etalon.

We report the implementation of a narrow free-spectral-range Fabry-Perot etalon for multiplex vibrational sum frequency generation (VSFG) spectroscopy. Moreover, we demonstrate the use of the etalon reflection to simultaneously generate a broadband infrared pulse, which enables a multiplex VSFG spectrometer using a total of 0.58W. VSFG spectra with and without a nonresonant-suppressed background were simultaneously collected utilizing time asymmetry in the upconverting pulse. Two examples are demonstrated in which spectral perturbations can be induced by the time-asymmetric pulse even without nonresonant suppression.

Effects of tert-Butyl Alcohol on Water at the Liquid–Vapor Interface: Structurally Bulk-like but Dynamically Slow Interfacial Water

We have investigated the effects of tert-butyl alcohol (TBA) on the structure and dynamics of water at the liquid–vapor interface. The structure of interfacial water has been studied by calculating the structural correlations and vibrational sum frequency generation (VSFG) spectrum from molecular dynamics simulations. It is found that the dangling peak of the VSFG spectrum of the air–water interface near ∼3700 cm–1 almost disappears in presence of TBA at the chosen concentration which means that the interfacial region is covered by the solute molecules. The hydrogen-bonded peak in the VSFG spectrum is found to be red-shifted by ∼100 cm–1 as compared to that of pure the air–water interface despite the fact that the strength of hydrogen bonds in the interfacial region is found to be similar to that of the bulk. This red shift in the VSFG spectrum is found to be a consequence of the cancellation of the nonlinear responses from “up-” and “down”-oriented O–H modes of water in that region. The local structure a...

Surface Spectroscopic Signatures of Mechanical Deformation in High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE).

High-density polyethylene (HDPE) has been extensively studied, both as a model for semi-crystalline polymers and because of its own industrial utility. During cold drawing, crystalline regions of HDPE are known to break up and align with the direction of tensile load. Structural changes due to deformation should also manifest at the surface of the polymer, but until now, a detailed molecular understanding of how the surface responds to mechanical deformation has been lacking. This work establishes a precedent for using vibrational sum-frequency generation (VSFG) spectroscopy to investigate changes in the molecular-level structure of the surface of HDPE after cold drawing. X-ray diffraction (XRD) was used to confirm that the observed surface behavior corresponds to the expected bulk response. Before tensile loading, the VSFG spectra indicate that there is significant variability in the surface structure and tilt of the methylene groups away from the surface normal. After deformation, the VSFG spectroscopic signatures are notably different. These changes suggest that hydrocarbon chains at the surface of visibly necked HDPE are aligned with the direction of loading, while the associated methylene groups are oriented with the local C2v symmetry axis roughly parallel to the surface normal. Small amounts of unaltered material are also found at the surface of necked HDPE, with the relative amount of unaltered material decreasing as the amount of deformation increases. Aspects of the nonresonant SFG response in the transition zone between necked and undeformed polymer provide additional insight into the deformation process and may provide the first indication of mechanical deformation. Nonlinear surface spectroscopy can thus be used as a noninvasive and nondestructive tool to probe the stress history of a HPDE sample in situations where X-ray techniques are not available or not applicable. Vibrational sum-frequency generation thus has great potential as a platform for material state awareness (MSA) and should be considered as part of a broader suite of tools for such applications.

Interaction of l-Phenylalanine with Lipid Monolayers at Air–Water Interface at Different pHs: Sum-Frequency Generation Spectroscopy and Surface Pressure Studies

We employed vibrational sum-frequency generation (VSFG) spectroscopy to obtain molecular level understanding of interaction of l-phenylalanine (Phe) with lipid monolayers of zwitterionic 1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPPC) at the air–water interface. The measured VSFG spectra in the CH stretch region due to the lipid and Phe, and the OH stretch region due to interfacial water molecules were analyzed. These results in combination with surface pressure studies reveal that the Phe molecules at acidic pH of 5.6 intercalate into DPPC monolayers, and replace some interfacial water molecules. Consequently, there is a decrease in the VSFG intensity in the OH stretch region in the Phe subphase, and a concomitant increase in the surface pressure of the DPPC monolayer. The exclusion of the water molecules is controlled by both the bulk concentration of Phe, and the surface concentration of DPPC. In contrast, at the neutral pH of 7.3 there is an increase in the VSFG intensity due to the interfacial wat...

Effect of Temperature on the Organization of Acetonitrile at the Silica/Liquid Interface

Liquid acetonitrile at a silica surface is known to organize in a manner that, in some respects, resembles a supported lipid bilayer. Here we use broadband vibrational sum-frequency generation (VSFG) spectroscopy to study how this organization depends on temperature. We find that VSFG spectra in the methyl-stretching region of the spectrum decrease in magnitude and shift to the blue for all polarization combinations (SSP, SPS, and PPP) as the temperature is raised from 25 to 60 °C. The observed decrease in intensity with increasing temperature is unexpected and suggests that the dynamics of the second sublayer of acetonitrile molecules plays an important role in the spectral behavior of this system. We propose that the decrease in intensity with increasing temperature arises largely from the more static first sublayer becoming more disordered. This picture is supported by the observed blue shift at high temperature, which is consistent with faster reorientation-induced spectral diffusion. The rapid dynamics and average orientation of the second sublayer are biased by the first sublayer, but this bias is not influenced substantially by increasing the temperature.