VH J558 Research Articles

Variable region sequence analysis of anti-DNA antibodies: evidence for a family of closely related germ-line VH genes encoding lupus autoantibodies.

Cloning and sequencing of the V regions of the anti-DNA monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), H438 and H130, indicate that H438 is encoded by a J558 VH gene, a single D region nucleotide, and unmutated JH1, V kappa-1C and J kappa 1 genes, and the H130 L chain is encoded by a V kappa-21 subgroup gene J kappa 1 gene. Identification of VH438, which shared VH hybridization pattern with 6% of a panel of 352 MRL/lpr hybridomas, suggests that the frequency of J558 use among spontaneously activated B cells in MRL/lpr mice is greater than previously reported. The VHH438 J558 family gene is identical to VHPAR, which encodes the independently derived MRL/lpr autoantibody, MRP-2, and is highly homologous to the previously reported VHH130, which is identical to a BALB/c germ-line VH gene. Comparison of consensus sequences of homologous autoantibodies and previously reported restriction mapping suggest that a minimum of three highly related J558 germ-line genes encode lupus autoantibodies.

Cationic residues in pathogenic anti-DNA autoantibodies arise by mutations of a germ-line gene that belongs to a large VH gene subfamily.

The F1 progeny of autoimmune NZB and normal SWR mice uniformly develop severe and accelerated lupus nephritis. The (SWR x NZB)F1 mice produce an oligoclonally expanded population of nephritogenic anti-DNA autoantibodies that share a recurrent cross-reactive idiotype (Id564), use highly homologous VH genes and surprisingly have the CH region allotype of the normal SWR parent. From extensive library analyses, we isolated 15 SWR germ-line genes which are most closely related to the pathogenic autoantibody VH564 gene and which also belong to the NPb subfamily of J558 VH genes. We found that the pathogenic VH genes are probably somatic variants of a SWR germ-line VH gene, SW6-3, and they have several basic amino acid substitutions, in addition to those already present in the SW6-3 germ-line gene. Since these pathogenic autoantibodies are not detectable in the sera of the normal SWR mice despite the presence of the SW6-3 gene, strong selection and expansion of B cells expressing the SW6-3 VH gene is probably occurring in (SWR x NZB)F1 lupus-prone mice. We also isolated eight germ-line genes from the NZB mouse which are homologous to SW6-3. The autoimmune NZB parent that rarely develops nephritis lacks the SW6-3 gene, but has several highly homologous germ-line VH genes that would encode less cationic antibodies. These results establish a correlation between structure and pathogenic potential of VH genes.

Ig V kappa family repertoire of plasma cells derived from autoimmune MRL mice.

V kappa gene family usage was determined in the resident in vivo-activated plasma cells of individual diseased MRL mice by using in situ hybridization. In this way, the entire autoimmune repertoire could be analyzed. Autoantibody levels and extent of glomerulonephritis were also measured, so that the severity of disease could be assessed. It was found that V kappa expression was highly variable from mouse to mouse. Some animals displayed a V kappa family repertoire similar to mitogen-stimulated cells and consistent with the size of the families. These animals tended to have lower disease indices. Other animals, which had higher disease indices, displayed considerable over- or underutilization of individual V kappa families. However, no particular V kappa families were repeatedly biased in their expression, as was found at the VH level with J558. Importantly, in the 10% of animals that expressed VH J558 exclusively, four or more V kappa families were expressed and multiple antiself specificities were produced. The data are most consistent with a number of J558 genes being expanded in a variety of self-specificities. However, because only VH J558 is expressed in these sicker animals, nonspecific polyclonal activation is highly unlikely. These results underscore the continuing evolution of the autoimmune repertoire, with considerable diversity at early stages followed by a highly selected repertoire in which a potential role for nonspecific polyclonal activation is virtually excluded.

VH gene analysis of spontaneously activated B cells in adult MRL-lpr/lpr mice. J558 bias is not limited to classic lupus autoantibodies.

To determine the genetic origins of lupus auto-antibodies, we analyzed the relationship between VH gene usage and auto-Ag-binding properties of 352 B cell hybridomas derived from MRL-lpr/lpr mice. The hybridomas were derived from neonatal, 1-month-old, 3-month-old, and 6-month-old mice. The experimental strategy provided that the hybridomas were monoclonal at initial evaluation, so the Ag binding and V gene frequencies of the entire population could be determined. Initially, 1032 Ig-producing hybridomas were evaluated for binding to six Ag; VH gene family use was determined in 119 anti-DNA and anti-rabbit thymus extract (RTE) antibodies (autoantibodies) and in 233 age-matched Ig that did not bind to any of the six Ag (nonbinders). Neonatal B cells, including cross-reactive IgM autoantibodies and nonbinder IgM, used relatively 3' VH genes. The majority of B cells in adult mice used VH genes of the J558 family. Although J558 use was significantly higher among the autoantibodies (anti-DNA and anti-RTE) than among the nonbinder Ig, this difference was due to a higher frequency of J558 use by 1-month-old mice. At 3 months, J558 use by the nonbinder Ig increased to the same frequency of J558 use as in the autoantibody population. J558 use in both groups of antibodies exceeded a previously reported estimation of J558 expression in the functional B cell repertoire of young adult MRL-lpr/lpr mice. Several subgroups of antibodies that share properties with pathogenic Ig, including IgG, cross-reactive Ig, and anti-dsDNA autoantibodies, demonstrated a marked preferential expression of the J558 family. These results suggest that there is an age-related bias in the activation of B cells using J558 VH genes in MRL-lpr/lpr mice that is under the influence of a selective force distinct from, or in addition to, an ssDNA or RTE auto-Ag-driven response.

Most peripheral B cells in mice are ligand selected.

Using amplified cDNA and genomic libraries, we have analyzed the VH gene repertoire of pre-B cells and various B cell subsets of conventional mice at the level of VH genes belonging to the J558 VH gene family. The sequence data were evaluated on the basis of a newly established list of 67 J558 VH genes that comprise approximately two-thirds of the J558 VH genes of the murine IgHb haplotype. The results of the analysis demonstrate that VH gene utilization in pre-B cells, although biased to some extent by B cell autonomous VH gene selection, scatters over the whole range of J558 VH genes present in the germline. In contrast, in mature, peripheral B cells comprising long-lived mu + delta high B cells as well as Ly-1 B cells, small overlapping sets of germline VH genes are dominantly expressed. The data indicate that the recruitment of newly generated B cells into the long-lived peripheral B cell pool is mediated through positive selection by internal and/or external antigens. Because of the absence of immunoglobulin class switching and somatic hypermutation, this process is different from the selection of memory B cells in T cell-dependent immune responses.

Organization of the murine immunoglobulin VH complex: Placement of two new VH families (VH10 and VH11) and analysis of VH family clustering and interdigitation

During B cell development, there is an ordered expression of heavy chain variable region (VH) genes during ontogeny such that JH proximal VH genes are rearranged and expressed before the more JH distal VH genes. Thus, the relative chromosomal position of VH genes is biologically significant. We have previously employed deletion mapping to order the nine described murine VH gene families as follows: 3609-J558-(J606/VGAM3-8/S107)-3660-(X24/Q52/7183). (Families within parentheses were not mapped relative to each other.) In this report we continue this analysis by mapping two recently described heavy chain variable region gene families (VH10 and VH11). VH10 is located at the JH proximal end of the major cluster of J558 VH gene segments. VH11 (a very small family) is intermingled with the 3660 family. Although in general VH genes are thought to be clustered, we and others have reported some interspersion between families. To further address this issue, we have analyzed 80 recombinant phage clones containing J558 VH gene segments for the presence of other VH family genes. Our data indicate that the J558 and 3609 VH families are extensively intermingled as has recently been described for the most JH proximal Q52 and 7183 families.

A set of closely related antibodies dominates the primary antibody response to the antigenic site CB of the A/PR/8/34 influenza virus hemagglutinin.

Approximately 50% of the primary antibody response of BALB/c mice to the A/PR/8/34 influenza virus hemagglutinin is directed to the Cb site, one of the four major antigenic regions of the molecule. To determine the structural basis of the anti-Cb site response, we have examined the paratypic and genetic diversity exhibited by a panel of 24 primary and 4 secondary response mAb specific for this antigenic region. Reactivity pattern analysis demonstrated 20 distinct fine specificities among these antibodies, and V region gene sequence analysis showed that they are encoded by 17 different VH gene segments from 6 VH gene families and 14 different VK gene segments from 6 VK gene groups. Despite this overall diversity, many of the antibodies can be placed in a limited number of sets based on the shared expression of VH and/or VK genes. One set contains antibodies encoded by a single gene of the VK4/5 group in combination with one of two closely related genes from the J558 VH family. This set accounts for half of the Cb site-specific primary response hybridomas, indicating that the representation of the various anti-Cb site B cell specificities during the primary response to A/PR/8/34 influenza virus is not uniform. The preferential participation of B cells expressing this VH/VK combination is largely responsible for the dominance of anti-Cb site antibodies in the primary anti-hemagglutinin response.

Selection of VH gene repertoires: differentiating B cells of adult bone marrow mimic fetal development

In the present study we have compared by in situ hybridization and by a CFU-B colony assay VH family usage in the pre-B and B cell compartments of the bone marrow of adult BALB/c and C57BL/6 mice. We have found that the position dependent increased expression of the VH 7183 family, observed in neonatal mice, is characteristic of early differentiating B cells of adult mice. The quantitative analysis for each VH family of the number of pre-B and B cells produced daily and the number of mature B cells present in the peripheral immunocompetent cell pool of adult BALB/c demonstrates the existence of selecting mechanisms operating within the bone marrow at the level of the emergent repertoire and at the level of export of newly formed cells into the periphery. This selective process results in the decreased peripheral representation of the VH 7183 family and in the accumulation of cells belonging to the other VH families. Selection of VH family usage in peripheral repertoires may be determined according to lymphocyte life-span, as we have found a preferential utilization of the VH J558 family in populations of partially enriched, long-lived B cells.

VH gene family repertoire of resting B cells. Preferential use of D-proximal families early in development may be due to distinct B cell subsets.

The fetal VH gene repertoire was shown previously to be characterized by overrepresentation of D-proximal families, VH 7183 and VH Q52, compared with adult bone marrow B cells in which VH genes were expressed in a more stochastic fashion. To determine the underlying mechanisms of these findings, adult vs fetal progenitors were placed in the same supportive microenvironment and the resulting B lineage cells analyzed for VH gene family expression. The supportive microenvironment was provided by established adult bone marrow stromal cell layers. In this way the relative importance of environmental vs genetic influences could be determined. The fetal B cells and pre-B cells that developed on adult stromal cells maintained a fetal-like VH gene family repertoire with preference for D-proximal families VH 7183 and Q52. In contrast, adult cultured B cells maintained the adult-like repertoire with predominance of the largest family VH J558. Only after long-term incubation was there a change in the expression of particular VH gene families. These findings suggest that the D-proximal VH gene family preference observed early in ontogeny is associated more with the inherent genetic potential of B cell progenitors that predominate during fetal life and less with environmental influences.

B cell repertoire in adult antigen‐free and conventional neonatal balb/c mice

Early in ontogeny B cells preferentially use VH gene families which are most adjacent to the genes coding for the constant part of the immunoglobulin molecule. In conventional adult mice, however, a random usage of VH gene families has been found. We investigated the role of exogenous antigenic stimulation on this normalization of VH gene usage by B cells. Therefore, we made use of adult germ-free BALB/c mice fed a chemically defined ultrafiltered antigen-free diet (GF-CD) and neonatal conventional BALB/c mice. Both the adult GF-CD and the newborn conventional mice represent situations with minimal exogenous antigenic stimulation. The results obtained with RNA dot blot hybridization with probes specific for the different VH gene families showed in hybridomas from adult GF-CD BALB/c mice a preferential usage of the CH-proximal VH gene family PC7183. In hybridomas from 5-day-old conventional BALB/c mice a less frequent usage of the J558 VH gene family was found and an increased usage of the PC7183 VH gene family than what would be expected from random usage. Evidence is presented that the RNA giving a positive signal with the PC7183 probe represents functional messages for IgM production.

Molecular analysis and fine specificity of antibodies against an organophosphorus hapten.

We have identified four fine specificity groups reactive with the organophosphorus hapten Soman among 46 hybridomas generated in specific response to immunization with Soman-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH). The different fine specificity groups do not appear to correlate with the use of particular V genes. Molecular analysis of VH genes demonstrates predominant use of VH J558 family members in hybridomas of all fine specificity groups although several different VH genes within this family as well as others are able to contribute. Diversity of VH gene usage was also apparent in primary IgM-producing hybridomas. In contrast, there appears to be restricted L chain usage; a large number (18/46) used the V kappa 1 family. Interestingly, the V kappa 1 family also plays an important role in the memory response to phosphocholine (PC)-KLH, a related organophosphate hapten which shares several structural features with Soman, particularly when coupled to protein carriers. The V kappa 1 C gene appears to predominate in the PC-KLH response. Restriction analysis of DNA from the V kappa 1-positive Soman-KLH-specific hybridomas suggests that a single V kappa 1 gene may be utilized by 17/18 but that this gene is different from V kappa 1 C and may be V kappa 1 A. We propose that members of the V kappa 1 family contribute favorably in generating combining sites that recognize all or part of the structural features shared by the two haptenic structures Soman and PC when they are coupled to protein. This most likely involves recognition of the phenyl linker moiety as the dominant feature. It appears that the L chain rather than the H chain may play a more significant role in forming the phenyl-Soman-specific combining site and perhaps the combining sites for phenyl or ring structures in general.

Ig VH gene family repertoire of plasma cells derived from lupus-prone MRL/lpr and MRL/++ mice.

VH gene family usage was determined in both spontaneous, in vivo activated plasma cells and LPS-induced plasma cells from individual MRL/lpr mice by using in situ hybridization. It was found that VH gene family expression in spontaneous plasma cells varied from mouse to mouse. Some mice expressed VH families in an apparently random manner similar to that obtained with polyclonal activation. Other mice showed an exaggerated expression of particular VH gene families. VH J558 was overrepresented most frequently, but overrepresentation of VH 7183, Q52, and 36-60 was also observed. Importantly, LPS-induced VH gene family expression in these same mice displaying biased VH family usage in spontaneous plasma cells, appeared normal with no evidence for similar biases in the LPS-induced repertoire. Anti-DNA antibody concentrations and the degree of glomerulonephritis were determined for each mouse to measure the severity of disease. The level of expression of the J558 family was positively correlated with disease severity. The results suggest that the initial autoantibody response is highly diverse but becomes more restricted as the disease progresses.

The VH gene sequences of anti‐DNA antibodies in two different strains of lupus‐prone mice are highly related

The heavy and light chain V region sequences of an IgG anti-DNA autoantibody (PME77), derived from a lupus-prone (NZB x NZW)F1 mouse have been determined by mRNA sequencing. The V kappa gene segment belongs to the V kappa 1A gene sub-group and is found in several (NZB x NZW)F1 and MRL lpr/lpr anti-DNA antibodies, as well as in other antibodies of unrelated specificities. The VH gene segment appears to represent a unique gene or a subfamily of the large J558 VH gene family of the mouse, and is highly related to a germ-line sequence of a major anti-DNA idiotype (H130, IgM) of MRL mice. This anti-DNA-related VH segment has not been found, so far, to be expressed in antibodies with specificities for external or synthetic antigens; therefore, expression of such specificities may be regulated by powerful mechanisms of self tolerance in the healthy animal. In addition, both the heavy and light chain of the PME77 IgG antibody were found to contain somatic point mutations with a high ratio of replacement to silent mutations in complementarity determining regions. This IgM to IgG sequence relationship suggests an affinity maturation process, which is driven by the autoantigen.

Diversity of Ig V gene segments found in anti-DNA autoantibodies from a single (NZB x NZW)F1 mouse.

We have studied 18 anti-DNA secreting hybridomas derived from a single, nephritic NZB/NZW mouse. The antibodies were analyzed for the expression of idiotypic families that are enriched in the antibodies to DNA from diseased animals (IdGN2 and IdX), and for the expression of VH and V kappa gene segment subfamilies. Most of the mAb have characteristics similar to those that may be pathogenic because they 1) bound to native DNA, 2) were of the IgG2a or IgG2b isotype, and 3) expressed idiotopes associated with glomerulonephritis in NZB/NZW mice and human lupus. Among the 18 mAb, at least six VH subfamilies and six V kappa subfamilies were expressed. A majority of the antibodies utilized a VH gene segment from the large J558 subfamily. Slot blot analyses of total spleen cell RNA revealed that as NZB/NZW mice aged and developed nephritis, they expressed progressively higher quantities of Ig transcripts. The proportion of these transcripts derived from the VH J558 subfamily also increased. Our results indicate that a diversity of B cell clones participate in the anti-DNA response of a single NZB/NZW mouse. There was no preferential utilization of 3' Ig V gene segment subfamilies. Furthermore, there was no marked difference in the pattern of VH and V kappa gene segment expression in antibodies defined by their isotypes or idiotopes.

Selection of antibody repertoires: transfer of mature T lymphocytes modifies VH gene family usage in the actual and available B cell repertoires of athymic mice

The possible role of T lymphocytes in the selection of antibody repertories was investigated by comparing VH family usage in different B cell compartments of euthymic and athymic B6 mice. Analysis of VH gene family representation at the single cell level by in situ hybridization shows a diminished utilization of the VH J558 family in the effector compartment of the spleen and in small B cells of the lymph nodes of nude mice when compared to euthymic age-matched controls. Transfer of mature T cells from syngeneic donors increases expression of the VH J558 family in these two B cell compartments, not only abrogating the decreased utilization of the VH J558 family found in nude mice but further reinforcing the dominance of this family to levels of expression above those observed in euthymic controls. These changes are already evident by 5 days after T cell transfer and represent a permanent alteration of B cell repertoires as they persist for up to 1 year after T cell injection. Reconstitution of athymic mice with isolated T cell subsets induces different patterns of VH gene repertoires. Thus, while CD4+ cells enhance the expression of the VH J558 family, in CD8+ repopulated mice the utilization of the VH X-24 family increases in the splenic Ig-secreting cell pool. The present findings demonstrate that T lymphocytes modulate the selection of antibody repertoires in normal, non-immunized mice.

Expression of antibody V-regions is genetically and developmentally controlled and modulated by the B lymphocyte environment

In this study we performed a comprehensive analysis of VH family usage in the emergent, available and actual repertoires of neonatal and adult BALB/c and C57BL/6 (B6) mouse strains. For this purpose we used an in situ hybridization technique that allows the detection of VH-gene expression at a single cell level. We have found that VH gene expression in neonatal mice is determined by a non-random position-dependent process which favours the utilization of the most D-proximal VH 7183 family. The preferential usage of the 7183 family is also characteristic of early differentiating bone marrow B cells of adult BALB/c mice. At different stages of ontogeny and B cell development VH family repertoires evolve in a strain-specific manner, with significantly higher utilization of the VH J558 family in B6 mice. In the peripheral immunocompetent cell pool, local environmental factors can further modulate VH family expression and lead to increased representation of the VH J558 family in peripheral lymph nodes and of the VH X-24 family in intestinal Peyer's patches. In conclusion, our present results indicate that VH family usage is controlled by genetic, developmental and environmental factors and suggest that selection of antibody repertoires can occur at multiple stages in B cell development.

Strain-dependent expression of VH gene families.

The tremendous diversity of the antibody specificity repertoire stems from the ability of each developing B cell to select one out of many possible variable, diversity, and joining gene segments by specific rearrangement of the DNA. The mechanism by which V region gene segments is selected is not known. Moreover, evidence for both random and nonrandom expression of VH genes in mature B cells has been presented previously. In this report, the technique of in situ hybridization is used to accurately measure at the single cell level VH gene family expression in LPS-induced cells from several strains. In this way, at least one-third of the B cells are stimulated and a large sampling of activated splenocytes from each strain analyzed. The use of in situ hybridization eliminates any potential biases resulting from transformation protocols. In addition, because all populations of cells are analyzed by both in situ hybridization and immunocytochemical staining with anti-IgM, the proportion of cells detected by in situ hybridization could be compared with the proportion of B cells, blasts, and plasma cells in the population. It was concluded from these comparisons that the cells being detected by in situ hybridization under the conditions described are plasmablasts and plasma cells. Therefore, an accurate measure of the functional and expressed VH gene repertoire could be made. The results clearly demonstrate strain-dependent variation in VH gene family expression, particularly VH 7183 and VH J558 with up to three-fold differences observed. Thus, either there is considerable strain variation in the number of functional VH gene family segments or the expression of VH genes is not entirely random.

Structural basis of stimulatory anti-idiotypic antibodies

In order to design and produce effective vaccines based upon the idiotype network hypothesis of Jerne, a thorough understanding of the biological and structural aspects underlying the stimulating activities of anti-idiotypic antibodies is needed. Here we determined the nucleotide sequence of the variable heavy and light chain regions of two monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies which induce different anti-phosphorylcholine responses. The nucleotide sequences of the variable domains of two monoclonal anti-TEPC 15 (T15) antibodies (F6-3 and 4C11) were determined by the primer extension and Maxam-Gilbert techniques. The nucleotide sequence data show that 4C11 and F6-3 have homologous VH segments and JH segments, but different D regions. The VH segments of both clones belongs to the J558 VH family. Most of the differences among the VH segments are located in CDR2. The VK segments of 4C11 and F6-3 are homologous to the VK gene group 4 and group 8, respectively. Comparison of the sequences of 4C11 and F6-3 with other published anti-idiotype antibodies shows that there is no preferential utilization of immunoglobulin genes. An analysis of the distribution of charged residues and hydropathic comparison studies were used to interpret the sequence of 4C11 in terms of the biological mimicry of antigenic stimulation.

Autoantibodies of various specificities encoded by genes from the VH J558 family bind to foreign antigens and share idiotopes of antibodies specific for self and foreign antigens.

We examined the binding to foreign antigens and the expression of crossreactive idiotypes by a panel of 20 murine monoclonal autoantibodies encoded by V genes from the VH J558 family. 9 of 20 antibodies bound to foreign antigens such as bacterial polysaccharides, poly(Glu50, Tyr50), poly(Glu54,Lys37,Phe9), arsonate, and lysozyme, known to interact with antibodies encoded by genes from the VH J558 family. A high proportion of our panel of autoantibodies expressed crossreactive idiotypes originally borne by monoclonal rheumatoid factors, anti-Sm, and anti-DNA antibodies, all encoded by V genes from the VH J558 family. Some of these VH J558+ autoantibodies shared crossreactive idiotypes with VH J558+ antibodies directed against foreign antigens such as influenza virus hemagglutinin, poly(Glu60,Ala30,Tyr10), arsonate, and dextran. The implications of these findings are discussed with respect to the process of activation of self-reactive clones.

Specificity and molecular characteristics of monoclonal IgM rheumatoid factors from arthritic and non-arthritic mice.

Two-hundred twenty-four hybridomas secreting monoclonal IgM rheumatoid factor (hIgMRF) derived from MRL-lpr/lpr, MRL-+/+ and C57BL/6-lpr/lpr autoimmune mice were analyzed with regard to IgG subclass and domain specificity, and some for VH gene expression patterns. Among these mice, only MRL-lpr/lpr develop arthritis. Clonotypes specific for each of the four mouse IgG subclasses and clonotypes reacting with more than one IgG subclass were identified. Although each panel contained several clonotypes, the predominant one differed in each strain (MRL-lpr/lpr, anti-IgG2a; MRL-+/+, combined anti-IgG2a and 2b; C57BL/6-lpr/lpr, anti-IgG1 or combined anti-IgG1, 2a, and 3). The IgG domains recognized by these monoclonals were defined with mutant Ig carrying IgG1 heavy chains that lacked either the CH1 or CH3 domains, variant Ig carrying hybrid IgG2b-2a heavy chains, and IgG fragments. Inhibition of hIgMRF binding to IgG substrates by protein A was also assessed. Most determinants were assigned to the CH3 domain, but determinants in the hinge region, CH2 domain, and in some instances, even in the Fab portion, could also be identified. Hybridization of cytoplasmic RNA from 35 classes of diverse IgG subclass specificity with VH gene probes representing seven of the approximately 10 VH families (7183, S107, Q52, J558, J606, 36-60, X24) indicated that approximately 90% of these clones expressed VH genes belonging to the large J558 gene family. The results indicate that murine IgMRF are extremely heterogeneous in IgG subclass and domain specificities; the genetic background influences RF specificity characteristics that may relate to pathogenicity; and considering the complexity of the J558 VH gene family and reported RF heavy chain assignments to additional VH gene families, it appears that VH genes encoding RF are diverse.