VH Gene Family Expression Research Articles

Increased Utilization of the VH6 Gene Family in Patients with Autoimmune Idiopathic Thrombocytopenic Purpura

The VH gene family utilization pattern among pokeweed mitogen-stimulated immunocompetent B cells (available repertoire) and naturally activated B cells (actual repertoire) from the spleen was analysed in a group of patients with autoimmune idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura (AITP). For this purpose a non-radioactive RNAin situhybridization technique was employed, allowing detection of VH gene family expression in single cells. The results show that the VH gene family expression pattern in patients with AITP does not correlate with genomic complexity of the VH genes. Furthermore, the pattern of VH gene family utilization in AITP patients is statistically different from that of healthy controls in the available, but not in the actual repertoire. The VH5 gene family is used at a frequency of 11.3% in patients’ resting B lymphocytes, compared to 23.9% in controls. The VH6 gene family is used more frequently in patients (23.0% compared to 3.8% in controls). The increase in VH6 gene expression is not reflected in the actual repertoire, where the frequency of expression is 6.4%, and can therefore not be directly related to the presence of disease specific autoantibodies.

Selective usage of VH genes in adult human B lymphocyte repertoires.

The authors have compared the VH gene utilization patterns among small resting immunocompetent B cells and large naturally activated B lymphocytes of healthy human adults. They employed a non-radioactive RNA in situ hybridization technique that allows detection of VH gene family expression at the single cell level. Pokeweed mitogen stimulated and unmanipulated mononuclear cells from peripheral blood and spleen of unrelated individuals were hybridized to digoxigenin-labelled antisense RNA probes specific for human VH families 1-6 and for the constant region genes C mu and C gamma. The observed VH gene family utilization patterns did not correlate with the genomic complexity of human VH genes. The VH3 gene family was most frequently used among resting B cells in both peripheral blood and spleen. Among naturally activated lymphocytes the VH6 gene was markedly over-represented, while expression of the VH1 and VH3 gene families was decreased. The data show that V-region mediated selection participates in shaping the peripheral antibody repertoire in healthy adults.

Contribution of the V lambda light chain to the development of the primary antibody repertoire.

The experiments outlined here provide evidence that most VH gene families are expressed in association with either of three V lambda genes available in kappa-deficient mice, though their expression is nonrandom. An exclusive use of V lambda L-chain genes, where predominantly expressed V lambda 1 and V lambda 2 differ by only seven amino acid substitutions in the germline, results in a higher degree of self-reactive antibodies to conserved natural antigens like albumin, thyroglobulin, and stress proteins. The higher levels of self-reactive antibodies, characteristic of preimmune B-cell repertoire, are likely to be a product of nonrandom VH gene family expression and their restricted pairing with three V lambda L-chain genes. These data suggest that a low lambda L-chain expression in normal mice is due, in part, to endogenous selection against lambda L chain in order to restrict self reactivity within the homeostatic threshold.

Regulation of VH-gene expression is a lineage-specific developmental marker.

We have previously shown that in IgH congenic mice VH-gene family usage in neonatal spleen B cells and adult Ig-secreting cells is entirely determined by the IgH locus, while in adult resting B cells it is regulated by genetic element(s) located outside the IgH locus. Two observations reported here demonstrate that the differential expression of VH genes is an intrinsic property of the respective cell populations, determined by both the IgH locus and by a cis element(s) operating independently in the same animal. First, the study of F1 hybrids between the IgH congenic B6a and CB.20 strains demonstrates that cis elements control VH-gene family expression. Second, studies in irradiation chimeras showed that the environment in which cell differentiation proceeds is unable to overcome those controls. In chimeras of IgH congenic donors, VH-gene expression in fetal liver-derived splenic B cells and Ig-secreting cells is dictated by the IgH haplotype, while in bone marrow-derived B cells is entirely determined by the cis element(s). These results show a developmental and cell lineage-related restriction in VH-gene expression, and suggest that most adult splenic Ig-secreting cells may originate from precursors originally present in fetal liver, but which are rare among adult bone marrow precursors and CD5+ B cells.

Molecular analysis of spontaneous nephrotropic anti-laminin antibodies in an autoimmune MRL-lpr/lpr mouse.

To explore the genetic relationship between anti-laminin and anti-DNA autoantibodies (autoAb), VH gene and gene family expression were determined among autoAb derived from an individual 6-mo-old MRL-lpr/lpr mouse. Whereas 85% of the anti-DNA Ig were identified by one of two VH family probes, 7183 and VHJ558, none of the anti-laminin antibodies (Ab) examined were recognized by these probes. Subsequent V region sequence analysis of three of the anti-laminin Ab revealed that they in fact utilized a J558 VH gene (VH50). Furthermore, FR2 and CDR2 oligonucleotide probes complementary to VH50 recognized multiple anti-laminin Ab by Northern blot analysis; the FR2 probe recognized two control anti-DNA Ab, but neither probe recognized anti-DNA Ab from the same mouse. Polymerase chain reaction amplification of MRL-lpr/lpr genomic liver DNA using primers generated from VH50 and Vk50 sequences indicated that all three anti-laminin Ig have a single replacement mutation in both their VH and Vk genes. Search of the nucleic acid databases revealed that both germline VH and Vk genes are expressed unmutated by murine lupus anti-dsDNA autoAb, previously sequenced in other laboratories. Sequence comparisons suggest that differences in anti-DNA and anti-laminin reactivity may be dependent upon somatically generated differences in the CDR3 regions of the H and L chains. The results indicate that lupus anti-laminin Ab can arise from distinct B cell populations but express the same unmutated germline V region genes as lupus anti-dsDNA autoAb. They further raise the possibility that these distinct B cell populations may be activated and expanded either: independently, by distinct Ig receptor ligands such as the Ag, laminin and DNA; or simultaneously, by a common ligand such as an anti-Id recognizing a common V region epitope.

Differential expression of VH gene families in peripheral B cell repertoires of newborn or adult immunoglobulin H chain congenic mice.

The pattern of VH gene family expression in the primary B cell repertoire of the mouse is strain dependent. In C57Bl/6 mice, the VH J558 family is expressed by more than 45% of the cells, while the expression of VH 7183, VH Q52, and VH 36-60 families together does not exceed 20%. In BALB/c mice, relative expression of VH J558 is lower than 35%, while the sum of the other three families reaches 25%. To assess which genetic loci control strain-specific VH gene family expression, we studied VH gene family usage in splenic B cell repertoires of different congenic strains of mice. Changes in major histocompatibility complex or immunoglobulin (Ig) K light chain genes did not modify VH gene family expression in adult mice. Differences at the IgH locus, however, modified VH gene family usage. In 1-d-old mice, the strain-specific VH gene family expression pattern is determined by the IgH haplotype. In adult mice, the VH gene family expression pattern of resting B cells is independent of the IgH locus and follows the genetic background of the congenic strain, while it is determined by the IgH haplotype among Ig-secreting spleen cells. In F1(B6 x BALB/c) mice, each of the two spleen B cell populations, sorted on the basis of mu heavy chain allotype expression, shows an independent VH gene family expression pattern, determined by the IgH locus. The implications of these results in the control of VH gene family expression, and in the selection of peripheral B cell repertoires are discussed.

Preferential VH/V lambda pairings occur in the available B cell repertoire of adult BALB/c mice.

To gain insights into the composition of the B cell repertoire, we have investigated VH gene family expression associated with individual light chains. For this purpose, we have examined the use of 12 VH gene families in a large collection of hybridomas expressing one of the four lambda light chains [lambda 1 (V1J1), lambda 2 (V2J2 and V x J2) and lambda 3 (V1J3)]. Our results show that the distribution of the VH families is very different from one lambda subtype to another. This suggests that a few substitutions between VL regions are sufficient to generate very different associated repertoires by strong selection mechanisms. Moreover, we assume that the global VH expression pattern is not random but rather composed of many preferential VH/VL associations.

VH gene family expression in mice with the xid defect.

Preferential use of particular VH gene families in the response to specific antigens has been demonstrated in several systems. The lack of responses to certain types of antigens, therefore, could be the result of deletion of or failure to express some VH genes. Because CBA/N mice, which carry the X-linked immunodeficiency (xid) gene defect, have been shown to be unresponsive to thymus-independent polysaccharide antigens, it was of interest to examine if this unresponsiveness could be accounted for by abnormal expression of particular VH gene families. Using in situ hybridization on B cell colonies, we determined the expression of nine VH gene families in CBA/CaHN females (genotypically normal), CBA/N males (xid) and females (xid), and (CBA/N x CBA/CaHN)F1 males (xid) and females (phenotypically normal). Our results indicate that VH gene family expression, including the S107 family, in CBA/N males and F1 males, is similar to that of CBA/CaHN and F1 females with predominant expression of J558, the largest gene family, in all individuals. Interestingly, CBA/N female mice, which carry two defective X chromosomes, as a group expressed significantly reduced levels of the J558 gene family, and as individuals showed variation in which family was predominantly expressed. We conclude that the unresponsiveness of mice with the xid defect to polysaccharide antigens can not attributed to a failure to express the nine VH gene families that we examined. Our findings do not support previous studies (Primi, D., and P.-A. Cazenave 1986. J. Exp. Med. 165:357), which found an absence of expression of the S107 family in xid mice.

Normal serum immunoglobulins participate in the selection of peripheral B-cell repertoires.

In B-cell development, expression of immunoglobulin heavy-chain variable-region (VH) gene repertoires is determined by genetic mechanisms that favor rearrangement of the most D-proximal genes, resulting in overutilization of the VH7183 gene family early in ontogeny and in differentiating B cells of the adult bone marrow. Maturation of the immune system is accompanied by a decreased expression of VH7183 genes in the peripheral immunocompetent B-cell pool of adult animals. By comparing VH gene family expression in the bone marrow (emergent) and peripheral (available and actual) B-cell repertoires of germ-free and conventionally raised BALB/c mice, we found that peripheral selection of VH gene family utilization does not occur in germ-free animals. Reconstitution of germ-free mice with normal serum immunoglobulins purified from syngeneic donors reestablishes selection of VH7183-expressing B cells. Our results indicate that preimmune B-cell repertoires are selected in normal animals by environmental antigens and serum immunoglobulins.

Endogenous VH gene family expression in immunoglobulin-transgenic mice: evidence for selection of antibody repertoires

VH gene family expression in single cells of the emergent, available and actual B cell repertoires of C57BL/6 mice was compared to that of two immunoglobulin (Ig)-transgenic B6 lines (B6-Sp6 and M54). We found that less than 5% of bone marrow cells of transgenic mice express endogenous VH genes and that the vast majority (95%) of the peripheral, mature B cell repertoire in these animals is composed of cells expressing the VHJ558 transgenic family. Unimmunized transgenic mice, however, diversify VH gene family usage by 'background' Ig-secreting cells in the spleen, greater than 50% of which express endogenous VH genes. The pattern of endogenous VH gene family expression in the actual repertoire of B6-Sp6 mice is indistinguishable from that of normal B6 mice. In contrast, actual repertoires of M54 mice differ by a 4- to 5-fold higher representation of the VHQ52 family. These results demonstrate a powerful positive selection of B cells into the secretory compartments of unimmunized animals, show that actual and available repertoires differ very markedly, and suggest that V region interactions participate in the selection of 'natural antibody' repertoires.

VH gene family repertoire of resting B cells. Preferential use of D-proximal families early in development may be due to distinct B cell subsets.

The fetal VH gene repertoire was shown previously to be characterized by overrepresentation of D-proximal families, VH 7183 and VH Q52, compared with adult bone marrow B cells in which VH genes were expressed in a more stochastic fashion. To determine the underlying mechanisms of these findings, adult vs fetal progenitors were placed in the same supportive microenvironment and the resulting B lineage cells analyzed for VH gene family expression. The supportive microenvironment was provided by established adult bone marrow stromal cell layers. In this way the relative importance of environmental vs genetic influences could be determined. The fetal B cells and pre-B cells that developed on adult stromal cells maintained a fetal-like VH gene family repertoire with preference for D-proximal families VH 7183 and Q52. In contrast, adult cultured B cells maintained the adult-like repertoire with predominance of the largest family VH J558. Only after long-term incubation was there a change in the expression of particular VH gene families. These findings suggest that the D-proximal VH gene family preference observed early in ontogeny is associated more with the inherent genetic potential of B cell progenitors that predominate during fetal life and less with environmental influences.

Ig VH gene family repertoire of plasma cells derived from lupus-prone MRL/lpr and MRL/++ mice.

VH gene family usage was determined in both spontaneous, in vivo activated plasma cells and LPS-induced plasma cells from individual MRL/lpr mice by using in situ hybridization. It was found that VH gene family expression in spontaneous plasma cells varied from mouse to mouse. Some mice expressed VH families in an apparently random manner similar to that obtained with polyclonal activation. Other mice showed an exaggerated expression of particular VH gene families. VH J558 was overrepresented most frequently, but overrepresentation of VH 7183, Q52, and 36-60 was also observed. Importantly, LPS-induced VH gene family expression in these same mice displaying biased VH family usage in spontaneous plasma cells, appeared normal with no evidence for similar biases in the LPS-induced repertoire. Anti-DNA antibody concentrations and the degree of glomerulonephritis were determined for each mouse to measure the severity of disease. The level of expression of the J558 family was positively correlated with disease severity. The results suggest that the initial autoantibody response is highly diverse but becomes more restricted as the disease progresses.

Comparative study of VH gene family usage by newborn xid and non-xid mice, newborn NZB and adult NZB mice, and by splenic and peritoneal cavity B cell compartments.

RNA from 170 different Ig-secreting hybridomas was hybridized with VH gene probes 7183, QUPC52, S107, J558, J606, 36-60, V31, X-24 and V-GAM 3.8, with the aim of comparing xid to non-xid mice, neonatal NZB to adult NZB, and the peritoneal cavity with the splenic compartments for VH gene family expression. Our results indicate that (a) defective F1 male xid mice express with high frequency 36-60 and J606 5' proximal VH families, when compared to non-xid F1 females of the same matings. (b) Neonatal NZB mice express 3' proximal 7183 and QUPC52 families with high frequency, when compared to adult mice and to the expected values derived from VH complexity. (c) Natural antibodies against cytoskeleton proteins, DNA, rabbit IgG and 2,4,6-trinitrophenyl did not appear to prefer a particular VH family. The only difference found is related to age; neonatal clones preferentially employ 7183 and QUPC52 while J558 predominates among adult clones. (d) All the 15 antibodies directed against bromelin-treated mouse red blood cells failed to hybridize with any of the nine VH probes employed. These results confirm previous findings indicating the highly homogeneous pattern of these latter antibodies, and suggest that they are encoded by a new VH family (VH11).

Comparison of the fetal and adult functional B cell repertoires by analysis of VH gene family expression.

The functional B cell repertoire in BALB/c mice was assessed at various stages in ontogeny. This was done by analyzing VH gene family expression using the sensitive technique of in situ hybridization. The B cell repertoire was probed with the mitogen, LPS, and the antigen DNP. DNP was chosen because B cells responsive to this hapten appear very early in ontogeny. The APCs that developed after stimulation with LPS or DNP were analyzed for VH gene expression by in situ hybridization of individual cells using radiolabeled VH gene family probes. The results indicated that VH gene expression in fetal B cells after stimulation was distinct from adult B cells in that there was a biased expression of D proximal families. The results indicated that this bias was associated with developmental age and not a given differentiation stage in the B cell lineage. In addition, stimulation of fetal B cells with DNP resulted in a large increase in expression of member(s) of VH 36-60, suggesting that the early appearance of DNP-responsive B cells is not strictly correlated with preferential rearrangement of D proximal families, VH 7183 and VH Q52. However, the results suggested that a large proportion of pre-B cells that preferentially rearrange D proximal families early in ontogeny become part of the functional developing repertoire.

Strain-dependent expression of VH gene families.

The tremendous diversity of the antibody specificity repertoire stems from the ability of each developing B cell to select one out of many possible variable, diversity, and joining gene segments by specific rearrangement of the DNA. The mechanism by which V region gene segments is selected is not known. Moreover, evidence for both random and nonrandom expression of VH genes in mature B cells has been presented previously. In this report, the technique of in situ hybridization is used to accurately measure at the single cell level VH gene family expression in LPS-induced cells from several strains. In this way, at least one-third of the B cells are stimulated and a large sampling of activated splenocytes from each strain analyzed. The use of in situ hybridization eliminates any potential biases resulting from transformation protocols. In addition, because all populations of cells are analyzed by both in situ hybridization and immunocytochemical staining with anti-IgM, the proportion of cells detected by in situ hybridization could be compared with the proportion of B cells, blasts, and plasma cells in the population. It was concluded from these comparisons that the cells being detected by in situ hybridization under the conditions described are plasmablasts and plasma cells. Therefore, an accurate measure of the functional and expressed VH gene repertoire could be made. The results clearly demonstrate strain-dependent variation in VH gene family expression, particularly VH 7183 and VH J558 with up to three-fold differences observed. Thus, either there is considerable strain variation in the number of functional VH gene family segments or the expression of VH genes is not entirely random.