Vertical Take-off And Landing Research Articles

Innovation strategies for non-existent markets - Profiting from urban air mobility

Technological advances have paved the way for urban air mobility (UAM) as a new mode of transportation, providing solutions for both inner-city and regional transportation. Novel vertical take-off and landing (VTOL) vehicles promise to be less noisy and safer than existing helicopters, thus allowing for an integration of UAM into current mobility systems. However, as this market is non-existent today, companies engaged in this field face several uncertainties. Strategic decision factors supporting VTOL manufacturers to successfully commercialize their innovation are still mainly unassessed. Looking into the innovation strategy literature we find little guidance on how high-technology companies can profit from innovation in so far non-existent markets. We therefore conduct expert interviews that allow us to identify eight decision factors that VTOL manufacturers are expected to take into account when setting up their commercial strategy. Building on the findings from these interviews we suggest to enhance the Profiting from Innovation (PFI) framework by a peripheric sphere that incorporates the impact of external factors on commercial success. This approach on the one hand, allows to provide insights into strategic management approaches of VTOL manufacturers, while on the other hand, this research adds to the scientific literature on strategic decision factors in non-existent markets.

Extended state observer-based continuous finite time control for a fixed-wing vertical take-off and landing unmanned aerial vehicle

Dual system Vertical Take-Off and Landing (VTOL) fixed-wing Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) combine the advantages of both the rotorcraft and fixed-wing UAV, characterizing horizontal and vertical flight capabilities. However, they face challenges such as aerodynamic coupling between propulsion systems, model uncertainty, and external disturbances, significantly deteriorating the tracking accuracy and robustness. This paper proposes an Extended State Observer based Continuous Finite-Time Control (ESO-CFTC) scheme to solve the attitude and trajectory tracking problem of such a VTOL fixed-wing UAV. Initially, the Nonsingular Fast Terminal Sliding Mode (NFTSM) controller guarantees the tracking errors reach a prescribed manifold in finite time with a continuous reaching law, then converge to the origin in finite time while avoiding singularities. To suppress the inherent chattering problem of the sliding mode control, an ESO technique is incorporated into the ESO-CFTC scheme, which is completely decoupled with the basic NFTSM controller. The supremum of the estimation residual set is derivated theoretically. The scheme forces the tracking errors to converge into the neighborhood of the origin in finite time without requiring prior knowledge of lumped disturbance supremum values. Finally, the numerical simulation results in a Matlab/Simulink environment demonstrate that the presented method outperforms existing benchmark in terms of disturbance estimation, tracking accuracy, convergence rate, and robustness.

Controllability Evaluation for VTOL Aircraft in Velocity Envelope: A Distance-Based Metric

This paper introduces an approach for evaluating and quantifying the controllability of vertical takeoff and landing (VTOL) aircraft across various flight states. By employing the controllability theory for linear systems subject to bounded control, this study derives sufficient conditions for the local controllability of the nonlinear VTOL system. These conditions are cohesively integrated with the trimmability condition directly derived from nonlinear dynamics, establishing a comprehensive criterion that facilitates the assessment of both trimmability and controllability of VTOL aircraft. This unified criterion elucidates the relation between desired and achievable specific forces and moments with clear implications for flight mechanics. Building upon this criterion, a distance-based metric is proposed to quantify the controllability, with an optimization-based algorithm developed for its calculation. Focusing on an exemplary lift plus cruise VTOL aircraft, this study investigates controllability variations within the aircraft’s velocity envelope and assesses the impact of rotor failures on controllability. These applications demonstrate the proposed method’s effectiveness in quantifying the controllability of VTOL aircraft in various flight conditions.

Investigation of the Internal Flow Characteristics of a Tiltrotor Aircraft Engine Inlet in a Gust Environment

In the vertical take-off and landing (VTOL) state of tiltrotor aircraft, the inlet entrance encounters the incoming airflow at a 90° attack angle, resulting in highly complex internal flow characteristics that are extremely susceptible to gusts. Meanwhile, the flow quality at the inlet exit directly affects the performance of the aircraft’s engine. This work made use of an unsteady numerical simulation method based on sliding meshes to investigate the internal flow characteristics of the inlet during the hover state of a typical tiltrotor aircraft and the effects of head-on gusts on the inlet’s aerodynamic characteristics. The results show that during the hover state, the tiltrotor aircraft inlet features three pairs of transverse vortices and one streamwise vortex at the aerodynamic interface plane (AIP). The transverse vortices generated due to the rotational motion of the air have the largest scale and exert the strongest influence on the inlet’s performance, which is characterized by pronounced unsteady features. Additionally, strong unsteady characteristics are present within the inlet. Head-on gusts mainly affect the mechanical energy and non-uniformity of the air sucked into the inlet by influencing the direction of the rotor’s induced slipstream, thereby impacting the performance of the inlet. The larger head-on gusts have beneficial effects on the performance of the inlet. When the gust velocity reaches 12 m/s, there is a 1.01% increase in the total pressure recovery (σ) of the inlet, a 25.72% decrease in the circumferential distortion index (DC60), and a reduction of 62.84% in the area where the swirl angle |α| exceeds 15°. Conversely, when the gust velocity of head-on gusts reaches 12 m/s in the opposite direction, the inlet’s total pressure recovery decreases by 1.13%, the circumferential distortion index increases by 14.57%, and the area where the swirl angle exceeds 15° increases by 69.59%, adversely affecting the performance of the inlet. Additionally, the presence of gusts alters the unsteady characteristics within the inlet.

Composite quadratic Lyapunov function event-triggered control of vertical take-off and landing aircraft systems with actuator saturation

This paper deals with the problem of event-triggered control (ETC) for vertical take-off and landing (VTOL) aircraft systems under actuator saturation. By introducing the VTOL system with saturated actuators, a composite quadratic Lyapunov function (CQLF) approach is first proposed to describe the problem of the event triggering mechanism. The proposed transfer mechanism not only further saves communication resources, but also further suppresses the conservatism of the attraction domain estimation. Then, sufficient conditions are established via linear matrix inequality (LMI) by incorporating new event triggering mechanism condition and prescribed passive performance metrics under the closed-loop system that is asymptotically stable and strictly passive, respectively. Finally, the method proposed in this paper can effectively reduce the number of triggers and expand the domain of attraction. The validity and feasibility of the obtained results are demonstrated by two example simulations.

Full-Envelope Flight Control for Compound Vertical Takeoff and Landing Aircraft

This paper presents a flight control design for compound vertical takeoff and landing (VTOL) vehicles. With their multitude of degrees of controllability as well as the significant variations in their flight characteristics, VTOL vehicles present challenges when it comes to designing their flight control system, especially for the transition phase where the vehicle transitions between near-hovering and high-speed wing-borne flights. This work extends previous research on the design of unified and generic control laws that can be applied to a broad class of vehicles such as hovering vehicles and fixed-wing aircraft. This paper exploits this unifying property and presents an extension for the case of compound VTOL vehicles. The proposed control approach consists of nonlinear geometric control laws that are continuously applicable over the entire flight envelope, excluding the use of switching policies between different control algorithms. A transition strategy consisting of a sequence of high-level set points is associated with the flight control laws; it is defined with respect to flight envelope limitations and is applied in this work to a commercially available compound unmanned aerial vehicle. The control algorithms are implemented on a Pixhawk controller; they are evaluated via hardware-in-the-loop simulations and finally validated in a flight experiment.

Comparative analysis of European vertical landing reusable first stage concepts

AbstractReusable launch systems have the potential to significantly impact the space launch service market if both a high reliability and low refurbishment costs can be achieved. This study delves into the Vertical Takeoff and Vertical Landing (VTVL) methodology, as currently employed by SpaceX, and forms a segment of the ENTRAIN study by DLR. This broader study encompasses an examination of both Vertical Takeoff Horizontal Landing (VTHL) and VTVL reusable first stages, exploring their performance across high-level design parameters. This manuscript’s primary objective is to assess the quantitative impact of high-level design factors on launch vehicle performance, particularly in relation to the development of a future European reusable launch system featuring a VTVL first stage. For a two-stage vehicle with a payload performance of 7.5t into GTO, the effect of varying propellant combinations, staging velocities and engine cycles are assessed. The study encompasses an iterative, multidisciplinary analysis and sizing process for ten different configurations. Each design iteration not only entails a structural design analysis but also includes optimization of the ascent and descent trajectories. Finally, the developed vehicle concepts are compared to derive quantitative insights into the trade-offs associated with key design choices.

Innovative Hybrid UAV Design, Development, and Manufacture for Forest Preservation and Acoustic Surveillance

The research described in this paper focuses on the development of an innovative unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) tailored for a specific mission: detecting the acoustic signature emitted by chainsaws, identifying deforestation, and reporting its location for legality assessment. Various calculations were conducted to determine the optimal solution, resulting in the choice of a fixed-wing UAV. A comparative analysis between tri-rotor and quadcopter systems was performed, leading to the selection of the tri-rotor configuration. The primary objective of this study is to design an innovative hybrid UAV concept with key features including a fixed-wing design and integrated VTOL (vertical takeoff and landing) capability in the experimental model. The aircraft has been constructed using advanced materials such as fiber-reinforced polymer composites, manufactured using both conventional and advanced techniques like continuous fiber additive manufacturing and the use of a polymer matrix. Additionally, the aerodynamic configuration is optimized to achieve a cruise speed of approximately 50 km/h and a flight autonomy exceeding 3 h. The UAV has been equipped with payloads for mounting sensors to collect meteorological data, and crucially, the VTOL system has been optimized to vectorize thrust for improved performance during the transition from hover to cruise flight. This paper details the entire manufacturing and assembly process of the drone, covering both the structural framework and associated electrical installations. A dedicated sound detection system is incorporated into the drone to identify chainsaw noise, with the aim of preventing deforestation.

Preliminary Design and Optimization of Primary Structures for a Tilt-Duct UAV

Tilt-duct Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAV) combine the high-speed efficiency of fixed-wing aircrafts with vertical takeoff and landing (VTOL) and the hover capabilities of rotary-wing aircrafts while maximizing the advantages of ducted fans in terms of noise reduction, efficiency, and safety, making it a pivotal direction for the future of aviation such as urban air mobility. This paper concentrates on the design and optimization of the primary structures of a laboratory-designed reference tilt-duct UAV. Firstly, the general data of the reference tilt-duct UAV are presented. According to the load conditions, the overall structural layout design for the wing, fuselage, and empennage is carried out, where special attention has been paid to account for the requirements of VTOL/hover and cruise flight modes. Based on the structural layout, finite element models (FEM) are established and static analyses are performed. The results indicate that the design can fulfill the structural requirements during a flight mission. Furthermore, based on the Method of Feasible Directions (MFD) algorithm, we have carried out the optimization of the composite wing box that incorporates manufacturing constraints. Via optimization, the total mass of the wing box is reduced by 38.6%, i.e., from 3.73 kg to 2.29 kg. The results indicate that the combination of composite materials with a tilt-duct configuration holds significant potential for future high-efficiency and environmentally friendly aviation.

The Modeling and Control of a Distributed-Vector-Propulsion UAV with Aero-Propulsion Coupling Effect

A novel distributed-vector-propulsion UAV (DVPUAV) is introduced in this paper, which has the capability of Vertical takeoff and landing (VTOL), and can realize relatively high-speed cruise. As the core of the DVPUAV, the propulsion wing designed under the guidance of the integration idea is not only a lifting body but also a propulsion device and a control mechanism. However, this kind of aircraft has a series of difficult problems with complex aero-propulsion coupling, flight modes switching, and so many inputs and control coupling. In order to describe this coupling effect to improve the accuracy of dynamics, an aero-propulsion coupling model is developed, considering both computation reliability and real-time. Afterward, a unique control framework is designed for the DVPUAV. By optimizing control logic, this control framework realizes the decoupling of longitudinal and lateral directional control and even the decoupling of roll and yaw control. Next, based on the Iterative linear quadratic regulator (ILQR), a new Model Predictive Control (MPC) controller with the ability to solve complex nonlinear problems is proposed which achieves the unification of the controller for the full flight envelope. Finally, the good performance of the control framework and controller is verified in the whole process of the flight simulation from take-off to landing.

Urban Air Mobility Profitability and Operational Sensitivity to Battery and Charging Technology

Designs for electric vertical takeoff and landing (VTOL) aircraft deviate from traditional aircraft designs and include a wide variety of different configurations. Significant uncertainty also exists regarding the status of future battery technology, including energy density and charge rates. This paper presents a simple analytic model to estimate the profitability of an urban air mobility electric VTOL aircraft for a variety of vehicle configurations, battery technology parameters, and economic factors. Five main elements are considered by the framework: aircraft performance, battery technology, mission profile, mission economics, and electrical grid parameters. A sensitivity analysis is provided, comparing the operational performance and profitability of three electric VTOL concepts (lift plus cruise, quadcopter, and side by side), with respect to electrical grid and battery technology factors. The takeoff weight to maximize the number of completed routes or the overall profitability is also examined. Interestingly, results show that these two values do not coincide across the entire design space due to the nonlinearity of the battery life cycle with respect to the depth of discharge, which strongly affects battery replacement cost.

Low-cost development of a fully composite fixed-wing hybrid VTOL UAV

Fixed-wing hybrid vertical take-off and landing (VTOL) unmanned aerial vehicles (UAV) are popular due to their interoperability in the military and civilian domains, primarily where significant terrain difficulties exist for humans. Additionally, they can operate without requiring any runway infrastructure and have extended air endurance and efficiency. Since the hybrid UAV operates in distinct flight modes, viz., (a) VTOL and (b) fixed-wing cruise, carrying different payloads, the airframe structure requires careful design and manufacturing to realize sufficient strength. This experimental study aimed to identify the best combinations of various composite materials for manufacturing a lightweight, low-altitude long endurance (LALE) hybrid VTOL UAV. Primary materials include carbon fiber, Kevlar, fiber-reinforced plastic (FRP), resins, etc. Different rectangular test specimens of 120 × 5 mm size were made from ten different grades of carbon fiber, FRP, and resins using vacuum bagging. After properly curing these test specimens, we quantified their dynamic mechanical characteristics using various bending load experiments on a universal testing machine (UTM). An analysis of the experimental data facilitated the identification of the best composite combinations that provide maximum strength while reducing overall weight. Thus, we could understand the dynamic interplay between peak stress and test specimen weight. We also manufactured a UAV prototype using the identified combination and instrumented and flight-tested it to substantiate the experimental findings.

Optimization-Based Control for a Large-Scale Electrical Vertical Take-Off and Landing during an Aircraft’s Vertical Take-Off and Landing Phase with Variable-Pitch Propellers

The UAV industry has witnessed an unprecedented boom in recent years. Among various kinds of UAV platforms, the vertical take-off and landing (VTOL) aircraft with fixed-wing configurations has received more and more attention due to its flexibility and long-distance flying abilities. However, due to the fact that the advance ratio of regular propeller systems during the cruise phase is significantly higher than that during the VTOL phase, a variable-pitch propeller system is proposed and designed which can be applied without additional propulsion mechanisms during both flying stages. Thus, a VTOL aircraft platform is proposed based on the propulsion system constructed of variable-pitch propellers, and appropriate control manners are precisely analyzed, especially during its VTOL phase. As a basic propulsion system, a nonlinear model for variable-pitch propellers is constructed, and an optimization-based control allocation module is developed because of its multi-solution and high-order characteristics. Finally, the objective function is designed according to the stability and energy consumption requirements. Simulation experiments demonstrate that the proposed controller is able to lower energy consumption and maintain the stability of the aircraft while tracking aggressive trajectories for large-scale VTOLs with noises at the same time.

Development of a solar powered multirotor micro aerial vehicle

Rotary-wing aerial vehicles offer manoeuvrability and vertical take-off and landing (VTOL) advantages over fixed-wing systems. Rotary-wing systems do however have comparatively higher energy demands and consequently shorter flight times and therefore a greater energy dependence over their fixed-wing counterparts. Advances in photovoltaic technologies have resulted in significant increases in the specific power (power-to-weight-ratio) of solar cells enabling the design of solar-powered rotary-wing aircraft, and now micro-sized variants. The micro aerial vehicle (MAV) presented, the Micro Solarcopter, is a 0.15 m ×\\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \\usepackage{amsmath} \\usepackage{wasysym} \\usepackage{amsfonts} \\usepackage{amssymb} \\usepackage{amsbsy} \\usepackage{mathrsfs} \\usepackage{upgreek} \\setlength{\\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \\begin{document}$$\ imes$$\\end{document} 0.15 m ×\\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \\usepackage{amsmath} \\usepackage{wasysym} \\usepackage{amsfonts} \\usepackage{amssymb} \\usepackage{amsbsy} \\usepackage{mathrsfs} \\usepackage{upgreek} \\setlength{\\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \\begin{document}$$\ imes$$\\end{document} 0.02 m solar-rechargeable radio-controlled aircraft. The 0.071 kg aircraft can fly for an average time of 3.5 min, recharge in approximately 68 min under 1000 W/m2 irradiance at 25 °C and can hibernate for 38 days without sunlight. The paper explores the use of commercially available photovoltaic cells for the purpose of increasing the energy autonomy of multi-rotor MAVs, by enabling them to stay out in the field without returning to base for charging. A working prototype has been presented which incorporates a battery management system, automatic power on and off, low-power sleep mode, and first-person-view (FPV) camera.

Hybrid Mode: Routinization of the Transition Mode as the Third Common Mode for Compound VTOL Drones

Fixed-wing Vertical Takeoff and Landing (VTOL) drones have been widely researched and applied because they combine the advantages of both rotorcraft and fixed-wing drones. However, the research on the transition mode of this type of drone has mainly focused on completing the process quickly and stably, and the application potential of this mode has not been given much attention. The objective of this paper is to routinize the transition mode of compound VTOL drones, i.e., this mode works continuously for a longer period of time as a third commonly used mode besides multi-rotor and fixed-wing modes, which is referred to as the hybrid mode. For this purpose, we perform detailed dynamics modeling of the drone in this mode and use saturated PID controllers to control the altitude, velocity, and attitude of the drone. In addition, for more stable altitude control in hybrid mode, we identify the relevant parameters for the lift of the fixed-wings and the thrust of the actuators. Simulation and experimental results show that the designed control method can effectively control the compound VTOL drone in hybrid mode. Moreover, it is proven that flight in hybrid mode can reduce the flight energy consumption to some extent.

Experimental assessment of blowing effect on vehicle performance and aero-acoustics in small-rotor/wing interaction

The tiltrotor design for urban air mobility (UAM) combines vertical take-off and landing (VTOL) capability with fixed-wing efficiency. However, it confronts challenges posed by downward force due to rotor wake effect. Previous research has employed active flow control, such as blowing air, primarily during forward flight using a single air outlet slot. However, the implications for rotor performance and aero-acoustic characteristics have remained unexplored. The experimental approach in this study involves controlled blowing air with moderate momentum in hover mode, concentrating on rotor performance, download force, noise signature, and the influence of port patterns. It is found that the radial port pattern emerges as pivotal for mitigating downward force and augmenting rotor efficiency. The efficacy of noise reduction hinges on both receiver orientation and port pattern selection. This investigation significantly contributes to understanding the role of blowing effect in optimizing tiltrotor designs, particularly in the context of rotor wake-wing interaction.

Implementing and testing a U-space system: lessons learnt

Within the framework of the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program, one of the main goals of the Labyrinth project, which ended on May 2023, was to develop and test the Conflict Management services of a U-space-based Unmanned Traffic Management (UTM) system. The U-space ConOps provides a high-level description of the architecture, requirements and functionalities of these systems, but the implementer has a certain degree of freedom in aspects like the techniques used or some policies and procedures. The current document describes some of those implementation decisions. The prototype included, at least in a basic version, part of the services defined by the ConOps, namely e-identification, Tracking, Geo-awareness, Drone Aeronautical Information Management, Geo-fence Provision, Operation Plan Preparation/Optimization, Operation Plan Processing, Strategic and Tactical Conflict Resolution, Emergency Management, Monitoring, Traffic Information and Legal Recording. Besides, a web app interface was developed for the operator/pilot. The system was tested in simulations and real visual line of sight (VLOS) and beyond VLOS (BVLOS) flights, with both vertical take-off and landing (VTOL) and fixed-wing platforms, while assisting final users interested in incorporating drones to support their daily tasks. The three-year experience developing and testing the environment provided many lessons at different levels: functionalities, compatibility, procedures, information, usability, ground control station (GCS) integration and aircrew roles during the mission.

Techno-Economic Comparison of Low-Carbon Energy Carriers Based on Electricity for Air Mobility

The decarbonization of air mobility requires the decarbonization of its energy. While biofuels will play an important role, other low-carbon energy carriers based on electricity are considered, such as battery electrification and liquid hydrogen (LH2) or eFuel, a hydrogen-based energy carrier. Each energy carrier has its own conversion steps and losses and its own integration effects with aircraft. These combinations lead to different energy requirements and must be understood in order to compare their cost and CO2 emissions. Since they are all electricity-based, this study compares these energy carriers using the well-to-rotor methodology when applied to a standard vertical take-off and landing (VTOL) air mobility mission. This novel approach allows one to understand that the choice of energy carrier dictates the propulsive system architecture, leading to integration effects with aircraft, which can significantly change the energy required for the same mission, increasing it from 400 to 2665 kWh. These deviations led to significant differences in CO2 emissions and costs. Battery electrification is impacted by battery manufacturing but has the lowest electricity consumption. This is an optimum solution, but only until the battery weight can be lifted. In all scenarios, eFuel is more efficient than LH2. We conclude that using the most efficient molecule in an aircraft can compensate for the extra energy cost spent on the ground. Finally, we found that, for each of these energy carriers, it is the electricity carbon intensity and price which will dictate the cost and CO2 emissions of an air mobility mission.

Implementing and Testing a U-Space System: Lessons Learnt

Within the framework of the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program, one of the main goals of the Labyrinth project was to develop and test the Conflict Management services of a U-space-based Unmanned Traffic Management (UTM) system. The U-space concept of operations (ConOps) provides a high-level description of the architecture, requirements and functionalities of these systems, but the implementer has a certain degree of freedom in aspects like the techniques used or some policies and procedures. The current document describes some of those implementation decisions. The prototype included part of the services defined by the ConOps, namely e-identification, Tracking, Geo-awareness, Drone Aeronautical Information Management, Geo-fence Provision, Operation Plan Preparation/Optimization, Operation Plan Processing, Strategic Conflict Resolution, Tactical Conflict Resolution, Emergency Management, Monitoring, Traffic Information and Legal Recording. Moreover, a Web app interface was developed for the operator/pilot. The system was tested in simulations and real visual line of sight (VLOS) and beyond VLOS (BVLOS) flights, with both vertical take-off and landing (VTOL) and fixed-wing platforms, while assisting final users interested in incorporating drones to support their tasks. The development and testing of the environment provided lessons at different levels: functionalities, compatibility, procedures, information, usability, ground control station (GCS) integration and aircrew roles.

Enhanced robust adaptive flight control for a convertible VTOL UAV

In this paper, we propose less conservative formulations for candidate controllers of robust adaptive mixing control (RAMC) strategies. The RAMCs are employed to solve the trajectory tracking problem throughout the full flight envelope, with guaranteed stability, of a convertible plane (CP) vertical take-off and landing (VTOL) unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV). Initially, the multi-body nonlinear dynamic model of the CP VTOL UAV is obtained using the Euler–Lagrange formalism, from which a linear parameter-varying (LPV) model is derived to be used in the design of the RAMC candidate controllers. The new formulations of the candidate controllers are proposed considering two approaches: a (i) Parallel Distributed Compensation (PDC); and (ii) a parameter-dependent Lyapunov function. Hardware-In-the-Loop (HIL) experiments are performed in a high-fidelity flight simulator to verify the fulfillment of real-time constraints, ensuring a computationally lightweight control strategy ready for implementation in a low-cost embedded computational system.