ObjectiveThe objective was to explore ICU nurses’ experiences of caring for non-sedated, critically ill mechanically ventilated patients, when following a study protocol as part of a clinical trial. DesignThe study had a qualitative design with twelve nurses participating in two focus groups. The interviews were analysed using a thematic approach. FindingsOne overall theme emerged, “Cautious optimism”, which suggests positive experiences but with a negative undertone. The most remarkable experiences were related to caring for the patient, but there were some disappointments with regard to the interprofessional teamwork. Three subthemes were identified: 1) Excitement and uncertainty 2) Inspiring but demanding nurse-patient relationship, and 3) Teamwork or working against the tide? ConclusionThe main findings reflect the remarkable and positive aspects of caring for awake and involved mechanically ventilated ICU patients, but also how nurses found it demanding to follow a weakly implemented study protocol that sometimes resulted in deviations from their nursing ethical standards of care. A more strategic implementation plan for the study and improved interprofessional teamwork might have improved their experiences.