The avifauna within the willow (Salix spp.) community on the Arapaho National Wildlife Refuge (NWR) was dominated (96% of all observations each year) by 11 species of passerine birds during the summers of 1980-81. Using 28 vegetation variables measured or calculated for randomly selected points and points where birds were sighted, we assigned the species to 3 distinct response guilds relative to historical patterns of seasonal grazing. A eurytopic response guild (habitat generalists) included yellow warblers (Dendroica petechia) (YEWA), savannah sparrows (Passerculus sandwichensis) (SASP), and song sparrows (Melospiza melodia) (SOSP). A stenotopic response guild (habitat specialists) included willow flycatchers (Empidonax traillii) (WIFL). Lincoln's sparrows (Melospiza lincolnii) (LISP), and white-crowned sparrows (Zonotrichia leucophrys) (WCSP). The intermediate, mesotopic response guild included American robins (Turdus migratorius) (AMRO), red-winged blackbirds (Agelaius phoeniceus) (RWBL), and brown-headed cowbirds (Molothrus ater) (BHCO). Population densities of the eurytopic response guild differed little between healthy (historically winter-grazed) and decadent (historically summer-grazed) willow communities within a year. Densities of species in the mesotopic response guild differed more dramatically, and stenotopic responseguild species were absent or accidental in decadent willows. Information on habitat use patterns of the individual species between years supported the definition of response guilds; vegetation structure was most variable in habitats of eurytopic species and least variable in habitats of stenotopic species. Comparisons between used and available vegetation features indicated that species in the stenotopic response guild used locations that differed from random on the basis of bush spacing. We hypothesize that the response-guild structure primarily reflects the impact of cattle upon the horizontal patterning of the vegetative community. J. WILDL. MANAGE. 52(2):280-290 Grazing by domestic cattle is the most common historical use of native rangelands in the western United States (Busby 1979). Ecologists have described the impacts of grazing upon breeding bird communities by comparing avian populations on adjacent sites that have been subjected to different levels of grazing (Kantrud 1981, Mosconi and Hutto 1982), on the same site before and after exclusion of grazing (Duff 1979), or both (Bock et al. 1984). Those studies generally have described patterns of species presence or abundance relative to grazing impacts upon vegetation. Birds generally respond to changes in vegetation structure as a consequence of grazing rather than to the presence of cattle per se (Bock and Webb 1984). However, avian responses to vegetative changes are neither easily defined nor consistent among sites (Wiens and Dyer 1975). Ryder (1980) reviewed studies of grazing impacts upon avian communities and categorized species as either increasers or decreasers (in abundance) with the introduction of cattle into their habitats. Studies of grazing impacts, however, generally have not elaborated on the nature of avian behavior or population responses, especially relative to all bird species within a community. Previous studies in northern Colorado have shown that seasonal grazing practices over a 75100-year period may alter the horizontal and vertical structure of a shrub-willow community as potential habitats for birds (Knopf and Cannon 1982). Our objectives were to define avian guilds within the shrub-willow community which respond similarly to structural vegetation parameters, statistically test the validity of the response-guild structure with information on species densities and habitat use, and identify vegetation parameters that cattle alter that appear important to sensitive bird species. We thank E. C. Patten for his interest and local support. Field assistance was provided by B. Bergstrom, K. Bergstrom, J. F. Ellis, E. A.
Read full abstract