Klemsdal's recent paper on this topic ( JQSRT 13, 517, 1973) has stimulated the comments, (a) that molecular intensity measurements are by no means uniformly reliable and should be interpreted accordingly, (b) the mathematical basis of the r-Centroid approximation is well understood and is related to the existence (or non-existence) of a well developed uncancelled local peak on the vibrational wavefunction product. Contrary to his comments, it has been shown to hold very well for 10 5 bands so far studied.
Read full abstract