Simple SummaryThe role of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in breast cancer has expanded in the last decade, and studies have demonstrated good sensitivity and specificity of diffusion-weighted imaging (DWI), a functional imaging technique reflecting water diffusion properties in tissues. However, clear results about the reproducibility of DWI are still missing. To utilize DWI as a reliable stand-alone technique for breast cancer detection, the inter-reader agreement of the measurement must be assessed. Accordingly, in this study, we assess the inter-reader reproducibility to retrospectively evaluate the agreement of breast cancer detection using DWI as a stand-alone technique. As our results show a good agreement only in expert readers, the assumption that a breast MRI based only on qualitative analysis of DWI, with fewer variables, may be easier for a non-expert reader to learn seems disproved, and future prospective studies should assess the right time for appropriate training for radiologists to investigate the potential role of DWI as a stand-alone method for un-enhanced breast MRI.Purpose: In order to evaluate the use of un-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) for detecting breast cancer, we evaluated the accuracy and the agreement of diffusion-weighted imaging (DWI) through the inter-reader reproducibility between expert and non-expert readers. Material and Methods: Consecutive breast MRI performed in a single centre were retrospectively evaluated by four radiologists with different levels of experience. The per-breast standard of reference was the histological diagnosis from needle biopsy or surgical excision, or at least one-year negative follow-up on imaging. The agreement across readers (by inter-reader reproducibility) was examined for each breast examined using Cohen’s and Fleiss’ kappa (κ) statistics. The Wald test was used to test the difference in inter-reader agreement between expert and non-expert readers. Results: Of 1131 examinations, according to our inclusion and exclusion criteria, 382 women were included (49.5 ± 12 years old), 40 of them with unilateral mastectomy, totaling 724 breasts. Overall inter-reader reproducibility was substantial (κ = 0.74) for expert readers and poor (κ = 0.37) for non- expert readers. Pairwise agreement between expert readers and non-expert readers was moderate (κ = 0.60) and showed a statistically superior agreement of the expert readers over the non-expert readers (p = 0.003). Conclusions: DWI showed substantial inter-reader reproducibility among expert-level readers. Pairwise comparison showed superior agreement of the expert readers over the non-expert readers, with the expert readers having higher inter-reader reproducibility than the non-expert readers. These findings open new perspectives for prospective studies investigating the actual role of DWI as a stand-alone method for un-enhanced breast MRI.
Read full abstract