Scholars of Thomas Müntzer, the revolutionary religious leader of the German Peasants War of 1524–6 and Engels’s hero, have been waiting for this book to appear. It is the first fully archivally grounded study of the Peasants’ War in Mühlhausen, and it does not disappoint. The result of two decades of research, it is a major contribution not only to studies of Thomas Müntzer, but to our understanding of the early Reformation. Müller finally places Müntzer in his context, and Mühlhausen within the wider history of urban revolt. Beautifully written and structured, it also marks a historiographical shift that unites the scholarly traditions of both the former Eastern and Western Germanies, taking the best of each. Müller’s method, he explains, is ‘thick description’, drawing on the work of the anthropologist Clifford Geertz. But this is not a conventional microhistory. Rather, it is the most thorough reconstruction of ‘what happened’, using all the available sources and allowing for a multiplicity of actors, contexts, and goals. The result is a complex narrative. There was no single ‘Müntzer party’, Müller shows, and the Mühlhausen Reformation was driven by a group of well-educated, passionate clergy, many of whom were influenced by the theologian Andreas Karlstadt perhaps more than by Müntzer; the period of Müntzer’s ascendancy lasted only three months of March, April and May and even then, it was not total. As Müller strikingly puts it, Luther’s characterization of Müntzer as the ‘devil who reigns at Mühlhausen’ was simply not true; Müntzer never reigned, and even his famous call to his fellow citizens at the civic muster was undercut by the captain, who told him in no uncertain terms that he could ‘preach in the church, but not in the field’.
Read full abstract