The pile fermentation process of Fuzhuan brick tea is unique in that it involves preheating without the use of starter cultures. The detailed metabolite changes and their drivers during this procedure are not known. Characterizing these unknown changes that occur in the metabolites and microbes during pile fermentation of Fuzhuan brick tea is important for industrial modernization of this traditional fermented food. Using microbial DNA amplicon sequencing, mass spectrometry-based untargeted metabolomics, and feature-based molecular networking, we herein reveal that significant changes in the microbial community occur before changes in the metabolite profile. These changes were characterized by a decrease in Klebsiella and Aspergillus, alongside an increase in Bacillus and Eurotium. The decrease in lysophosphatidylcholines, unsaturated fatty acids, and some astringent flavan-3-ols and bitter amino acids, as well as the increase in some less astringent flavan-3-ols and sweet or umami amino acids, contributed importantly to the overall changes observed in the metabolite profile. The majority of these changes was caused by bacterial metabolism and the corresponding heat generated by it.