The Middle Eocene Climatic Optimum (MECO; ca. 40 Ma) was a prominent global warming event that lasted 400 kyr and was characterized by a 4–6 °C rise in high latitude surface and deep-water temperatures. As the radiolarian plankton response to this warming event is practically unknown, whole assemblage quantitative analyses were undertaken on well-preserved radiolarian assemblages from ODP Site 1051 (western North Atlantic). Although radiolarians have apparently benefited at this site from increase in oceanic fertility induced by the MECO, this event does not appear to have had a severe impact on subtropical radiolarian fauna. No prominent faunal turnover was found in the studied interval, suggesting that subtropical radiolarians are relatively resilient to transient warming events. Likewise, variations in radiolarian assemblage composition establish that ocean warming induced only a weak ecological response. One of the most striking faunal changes associated with the MECO is the clear increase in radiolarian diversity (taxic richness), as a result of the northward migration of warm tropical radiolarian species. Similarly, several typical middle Eocene tropical species are found to be more abundant in the warmest interval. In addition to these poleward migrations, we identified three radiolarian clusters composed of warm-water or cool-water species, as well as two abundant artostrobiid species which may represent nutrient opportunists.