Two-alternative Forced-choice Task Research Articles

Robust holistic face processing in early childhood during the COVID-19 pandemic

The timing of the developmental emergence of holistic face processing and its sensitivity to experience in early childhood are somewhat controversial topics. To investigate holistic face perception in early childhood, we used an online testing platform and administered a two-alternative forced-choice task to 4-, 5-, and 6-year-old children. The children saw pairs of composite faces and needed to decide whether the faces were the same or different. To determine whether experience with masked faces may have negatively affected holistic processing, we also administered a parental questionnaire to assess the children’s exposure to masked faces during the COVID-19 pandemic. We found that all three age groups performed holistic face processing when the faces were upright (Experiment 1) but not when the faces were inverted (Experiment 2), that response accuracy increased with age, and that response accuracy was not related to degree of exposure to masked faces. These results indicate that holistic face processing is relatively robust in early childhood and that short-term exposure to partially visible faces does not negatively affect young children’s holistic face perception.

Macaques recognize features in synthetic images derived from ventral stream neurons

Primates can recognize features in virtually all types of images, an ability that still requires a comprehensive computational explanation. One hypothesis is that visual cortex neurons learn patterns from scenes, objects, and textures, and use these patterns to interpolate incoming visual information. We have used machine learning algorithms to instantiate visual patterns stored by neurons-we call these highly activating images prototypes. Prototypes from inferotemporal (IT) neurons often resemble parts of real-world objects, such as monkey faces and body parts, a similarity established via pretrained neural networks [C. R. Ponce et al.,Cell 177, 999-1009.e10 (2019)]and naïve human participants [A. Bardon, W. Xiao, C. R. Ponce, M. S. Livingstone, G. Kreiman, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 119, e2118705119 (2022)]. However, it is not known whether monkeys themselves perceive similarities between neuronal prototypes and real-world objects. Here, we investigated whether monkeys reported similarities between prototypes and real-world objects using a two-alternative forced choice task. We trained the animals to saccade to synthetic images of monkeys, and subsequently tested how they classified prototypes synthesized from IT and primary visual cortex (V1). We found monkeys classified IT prototypes as conspecifics more often than they did random generator images and V1 prototypes, and their choices were partially predicted by convolutional neural networks. Further, we confirmed that monkeys could abstract general shape information from images of real-world objects. Finally, we verified these results with human participants. Our results provide further evidence that prototypes from cortical neurons represent interpretable abstractions from the visual world.

Visual deprivation induces a stronger dive response in a harbor porpoise.

The dive response allows marine mammals to perform prolonged breath-hold dives to access rich marine prey resources. Via dynamic adjustments of peripheral vasoconstriction and bradycardia, oxygen consumption can be tailored to breath-hold duration, depth, exercise, and even expectations during dives. By investigating the heart rate of a trained harbor porpoise during a two-alternative forced choice task, where the animal is either acoustically masked or blindfolded, we test the hypothesis that sensory deprivation will lead to a stronger dive response to conserve oxygen when facing a more uncertain and smaller sensory umwelt. We show that the porpoise halves its diving heart rate (from 55 to 25bpm) when blindfolded but presents no change in heart rate during masking of its echolocation. Therefore, visual stimuli may matter more to echolocating toothed whales than previously assumed, and sensory deprivation can be a major driver of the dive response, possibly as an anti-predator measure.

As trials go by: Effects of 2-AFC item repetition on statistical learning performance.

One of the most popular tasks used to test statistical learning (SL) involves asking participants to identify which of two stimuli, a triplet presented during the previous familiarization phase versus a new sequence made of the same stimuli never presented together, is more familiar based on the stream presented before, that is, to perform a two-alternative forced-choice (2-AFC) task. Despite the widespread use of this task, it has come under increasing criticism in current cognitive research due to psychometric flaws. A common practice to improve SL measurement involves increasing the number of 2-AFC trials by presenting the same items (triplets and foils) several times during the test phase. This work aimed to directly analyze the effect that this practice entails by examining how the proportion of correct discriminations of three-syllable nonsense words presented during the familiarization phase of an auditory triplet embedded task changed as the number of 2-AFC item repetitions increased. We also tested whether this effect was modulated by the predictability of the "words" embedded in the auditory streams (high and low) and the conditions under which they were presented to participants (implicit and explicit). Results showed that 2-AFC item repetitions had indeed detrimental effects on SL measurement, as indexed by a significant decrease in the proportion of correct discriminations as the number of items repetitions increased, both in the 2-AFC task performed under implicit and explicit conditions, although, in the first case, only for low-predictable "words." These findings recommend caution when using this strategy to improve SL measurement. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2022 APA, all rights reserved).

Approachability and Credibility of Virtual Character Faces: The Role of the Horizontal Viewing Angle.

The present work explores how the horizontal viewing angle of a virtual character's face influences perceptions of credibility and approachability. When encountering virtual characters, people rely both on credibility and approachability judgments to form a first impression of the depicted virtual character. Research shows that certain perceptions are preferred either on frontal or tilted faces, but not how approachability or credibility judgments relate to horizontal viewing angles in finer granularity between 0° and 45°. 52 participants performed a two-alternative forced choice (2AFC) task rating 240 pairwise comparisons of 20 virtual character faces shown in four horizontal viewing angles (0°, 15°, 30°, and 45°) on approachability and credibility. They also rated scales on individual differences based on the BIS-BAS framework (behavioral inhibition system, drive, and reward responsiveness), self-esteem, and personality traits (neuroticism, loneliness). Both approachability and credibility were negatively related to the horizontal viewing angle, but the negative relationship was less pronounced for approachability. Notably, 15° tilted faces were associated with higher approachability than frontal faces by people scoring high in reward responsiveness, drive, and self-esteem, and scoring low in neuroticism and loneliness. Our findings highlight the conditions under which showing a virtual character's face is preferred in a horizontally 15° tilted over a frontal position. The differential impact of the horizontal viewing angle on approachability and credibility should be considered when displaying virtual character faces.

A Novel Tactile Function Assessment Using a Miniature Tactile Stimulator.

Several methods for the measurement of tactile acuity have been devised previously, but unexpected nonspatial cues and intensive manual skill requirements compromise measurement accuracy. Therefore, we must urgently develop an automated, accurate, and noninvasive method for assessing tactile acuity. The present study develops a novel method applying a robotic tactile stimulator to automatically measure tactile acuity that comprises eye-opened, eye-closed training, and testing sessions. Healthy participants judge the orientation of a rotating grating ball presented on their index fingerpads in a two-alternative forced-choice task. A variable rotation speed of 5, 10, 40, or 160 mm/s was used for the tactile measurement at a variety of difficulties. All participants met the passing criteria for the training experiment. Performance in orientation identification, quantified by the proportion of trials with correct answers, differed across scanning directions, with the highest rotation speed (160 mm/s) having the worst performance. Accuracy did not differ between vertical and horizontal orientations. Our results demonstrated the utility of the pre-test training protocol and the functionality of the developed procedure for tactile acuity assessment. The novel protocol performed well when applied to the participants. Future studies will be conducted to apply this method to patients with impairment of light touch.

Behavioral economic and value-based decision-making constructs that discriminate current heavy drinkers versus people who reduced their drinking without treatment.

A substantial number of people reduce their consumption of alcohol in the absence of formal treatment; however, less is known about the mechanisms of change. The aim of this study is to explore whether constructs derived from behavioral economics and computational decision-modeling characterize the moderation of alcohol consumption that many heavy drinkers experience without treatment. Between-subject, preregistered design. People who reside in the United Kingdom and who drink heavily (n = 60) or used to drink heavily but now consume alcohol in moderation (n = 60) were recruited. Participants completed self-report behavioral economic measures (alcohol demand and alcohol-related and alcohol-free reinforcement) and a two-alternative forced choice task in which they chose between two alcoholic (in one block) or two soft drink images (in a different block). A drift-diffusion model was fitted to responses from this task to yield the underlying parameters of value-based choice. Compared to heavy drinkers, moderated drinkers had significantly lower alcohol demand, Omax, p = .03, Cohen's d = .36; elasticity, p = .03, rank-biserial correlation (rrb) = .21, and higher proportionate alcohol-free reinforcement (p < .001, Cohen's d = .75). However, contrary to hypotheses, there were no robust between-group differences in value-based decision-making (VBDM) parameters. Self-report behavioral economic measures demonstrate that alcohol moderation without treatment is characterized by lowered alcohol demand and greater behavioral allocation to alcohol-free reinforcement, in line with behavioral economic theory. However, a computerized VBDM measure yielded inconclusive findings. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2022 APA, all rights reserved).

Annoyance of helicopter-like sounds in urban background noise

Scenarios of urban air mobility see electric vertical take-off and landing aircraft (eVTOLs) operating within cities. Rotorcraft sounds are typically characterised by short bursts of noise, although eVTOLs offer more opportunities for a quieter sound design. We asked participants to compare the annoyance of a reference sequence of bursts of noise with a burst duration of 20 ms with that of a test sequence for which the burst duration was 1 or 5 ms. There were 20 bursts/s. A two-interval, two-alternative forced-choice task and a 1-up/1-down procedure was used. Both sequences were played in background noise that had either the same root-mean-square (RMS) level as the sequence of bursts or 10 dB less. The results were similar to those for loudness: On average, sequences with 1-ms bursts needed 6-7 dB less RMS level to sound equally annoying as the 20-ms bursts, and sequences with 5-ms bursts needed 3 dB less. This suggests that psychoacoustic annoyance is mainly explained by loudness and that the RMS level is an insufficient descriptor. Compared between the two background noise levels, the level difference for equal annoyance between short and 20-ms bursts was 1.5 dB larger in the louder background, which was statistically significant.

Recurrent networks endowed with structural priors explain suboptimal animal behavior

The strategies found by animals facing a new task are determined both by individual experience and by structural priors evolved to leverage the statistics of natural environments. Rats quickly learn to capitalize on the trial sequence correlations of two-alternative forced choice (2AFC) tasks after correct trials but consistently deviate from optimal behavior after error trials. To understand this outcome-dependent gating, we first show that recurrent neural networks (RNNs) trained in the same 2AFC task outperform rats as they can readily learn to use across-trial information both after correct and error trials. We hypothesize that, although RNNs can optimize their behavior in the 2AFC task without any a priori restrictions, rats' strategy is constrained by a structural prior adapted to a natural environment in which rewarded and non-rewarded actions provide largely asymmetric information. When pre-training RNNs in a more ecological task with more than two possible choices, networks develop a strategy by which they gate off the across-trial evidence after errors, mimicking rats' behavior. Population analyses show that the pre-trained networks form an accurate representation of the sequence statistics independently of the outcome in the previous trial. After error trials, gating is implemented by a change in the network dynamics that temporarily decouple the categorization of the stimulus from the across-trial accumulated evidence. Our results suggest that the rats' suboptimal behavior reflects the influence of a structural prior that reacts to errors by isolating the network decision dynamics from the context, ultimately constraining the performance in a 2AFC laboratory task.

Looking tight: Visual judgments of knot strength reveal the limits of physical scene understanding

While early studies cataloged striking errors of physical scene understanding in naive observers, a resurgence of research has instead revealed a remarkable ability to intuit how physical scenes will unfold. Properties such as stability, mass, gravity and kinematics may all elicit accurate intuitions, especially when presented in naturalistic settings. A leading interpretation of these findings is that physical scene understanding recruits a general-purpose “physics engine”. Under this theory, the mind simulates how a scene will unfold by modeling or approximating its physics, and only fails for physics problems that are contrived or presented without context. But might there be tasks that persistently strain physical reasoning, even when presented naturalistically and in realistic contexts? Here, 5 experiments explore this question by evaluating intuitions about the strength of simple knots. Knots are naturalistic stimuli that are ubiquitous across cultures and time periods, and in many contexts evaluating them correctly can spell the difference between safety and peril. Despite this, here we show that naive observers fail to discern even striking differences in strength between knots. In a series of two-alternative forced-choice tasks, observers viewed simple “bends” (i.e., knots joining two lengths of string) and decided which would require more force to undo. Though the relative strength of these bends is well-documented, observers’ judgments completely failed to reflect these distinctions—including in naturalistic photographs (E1), idealized renderings (E2), dynamic videos (E3), and even when accompanied by schematic diagrams of the knots’ structures (E4). Moreover, these failures persisted despite observers demonstrating visual understanding of the topological differences between the knots (E5); in other words, even when observers knew exactly what kind of knot they were viewing, they failed to extract or predict its physical behavior. These results expose a blindspot in physical reasoning, posing a new kind of challenge to general-purpose theories of scene understanding.

Posteromedial thalamic nucleus activity significantly contributes to perceptual discrimination.

Higher-order sensory thalamic nuclei are densely connected with multiple cortical and subcortical areas, yet the role of these nuclei remains elusive. The posteromedial thalamic nucleus (POm), the higher-order thalamic nucleus in the rodent somatosensory system, is an anatomical hub broadly connected with multiple sensory and motor brain areas yet weakly responds to passive sensory stimulation and whisker movements. To understand the role of POm in sensory perception, we developed a self-initiated, two-alternative forced-choice task in freely moving mice during active sensing. Using optogenetic and chemogenetic manipulation, we show that POm plays a significant role in sensory perception and the projection from the primary somatosensory cortex to POm is critical for the contribution of POm in sensory perception during active sensing.

Believing is seeing: The link between paranormal beliefs and perceiving signal in noise.

Research suggests that at the core of paranormal belief formation is a tendency to attribute meaning to ambiguous stimuli. But it is unclear whether this tendency reflects a difference in perceptual sensitivity or a decision bias. Using a two-alternative forced choice task, we tested the relationship between paranormal belief and perceptual sensitivity. Participants were shown two stimuli presented in temporal succession. In one interval an ambiguous Mooney Face (i.e., signal) was presented, in the other interval a scrambled version of the image (i.e., noise) was presented. Participants chose in which of the two intervals the face appeared. Our results revealed that participants with stronger beliefs in paranormal phenomena were less sensitive to discriminating signal from noise. This finding builds on previous research using "yes/no" tasks, but importantly disentangles perceptual sensitivity from response bias and suggests paranormal believers perceive things differently.

On letter-specific crowding and reading: Evidence from ERPs

We compared processing of letter and symbol stimuli presented briefly in the right or left visual field, and either in isolation or surrounded by two flanking characters of the same category. The flankers could be arranged horizontally or vertically. Participants performed a two-alternative forced choice (2AFC) task with the isolated character or the central character in flanked displays as target. Alternatives in the 2AFC task were characters from the same category as the target that were not present in the display. We recorded EEG in order to investigate the timing of crowding effects (isolated vs. flanked conditions) and the hypothesized differential impact of crowding on letters and symbols. Behavioral results showed no significant difference between isolated letters and symbols, but significantly higher accuracy to flanked letters compared with flanked symbols – and the effect of stimulus type was significantly greater with horizontally aligned stimuli. Likewise, amplitude of the N170 and a following negativity (identified here as the N250) did not differ significantly when comparing isolated letters and symbols but did differ for flanked stimuli. Flanked letters showed significantly greater N170 and N250 amplitudes compared with flanked symbols. N170 and N250 amplitudes were also significantly greater for flanked vs. isolated letters whereas symbols showed a significant difference in the opposite direction for the N250. We conclude that the processing of compact strings of letters is optimized for skilled reading via changes in the mapping of visual features onto letter identities in multi-letter arrays in order to reduce the interfering effects of excessive crowding.

Convergence and divergence in prediction from vocabulary and speed of word processing.

Toddler vocabulary knowledge and speed of word processing are associated with downstream language and cognition. Here, we investigate whether these associations differ across measures. At age two, 101 participants (55 monolingual French-speaking and 46 monolingual English-speaking children) completed a two-alternative forced choice task, yielding measures of decontextualized vocabulary (number of correct responses) and haptic speed of word processing (latency of correct responses). At ages three, four, and five children completed a battery of language assessments and an executive function task. Growth curve models revealed that age-two vocabulary significantly predicted age-three performance (but not growth from age three to four or four to five) across all language assessments but speed of processing did not predict language outcomes in final models. Finally, speed of processing was correlated with executive function at age three whereas vocabulary was not. Results suggest that vocabulary is associated with a range of downstream language abilities whereas haptic speed of processing may be associated with executive control.

Detection of dynamic changes in interaural delay by older adults (L).

The ability of older adults (48 to 72) with relatively intact low-frequency hearing to detect the motion of an acoustic source was investigated using dynamically varying interaural delays. Thresholds were measured using a single-interval two-alternative forced-choice task in which listeners determined if the sound source was moving or stationary. Motion thresholds were significantly larger than stationary localization thresholds. No correlation was observed between age and motion-detection ability for the age range tested. An interesting finding was that there were similar thresholds for older and younger adults. Results suggest reliance on dominant low-frequency binaural timing cues unaffected by high-frequency hearing loss in older adults.

From Bayes-optimal to heuristic decision-making in a two-alternative forced choice task with an information-theoretic bounded rationality model.

Bayes optimal and heuristic decision-making schemes are often considered fundamentally opposed to each other as a framework for studying human choice behavior, although recently it has been proposed that bounded rationality may provide a natural bridge between the two when varying information-processing resources. Here, we investigate a two-alternative forced choice task with varying time constraints, where subjects have to assign multi-component symbolic patterns to one of two stimulus classes. As expected, we find that subjects' response behavior becomes more imprecise with more time pressure. However, we also see that their response behavior changes qualitatively. By regressing subjects' decision weights, we find that decisions allowing for plenty of decision time rely on weighing multiple stimulus features, whereas decisions under high time pressure are made mostly based on a single feature. While the first response pattern is in line with a Bayes-optimal decision strategy, the latter could be considered as an instantiation of heuristic decision-making with cue discounting. When fitting a bounded rational decision model with multiple feature channels and varying information-processing capacity to subjects' responses, we find that the model is able to capture subjects' behavioral change. The model successfully reflects the simplicity of heuristics as well as the efficiency of optimal decision making, thus acting as a bridge between the two approaches.

The role of auditory and visual cues in the interpretation of Mandarin ironic speech

PurposeIrony is a form of non-literal language. Its decoding may require receivers to use information from both the auditory (e.g., prosody) and visual (e.g., facial expressions) modalities. However, little is known about the role of cues in different modalities in understanding irony. Therefore, the present study examined the relative contributions of auditory and visual cues in the interpretation of Mandarin ironic speech. MethodSixty-three native Mandarin speakers participated in a perception experiment in which two types of irony (ironic criticisms and ironic compliments) and their literal counterparts (sincere criticisms and sincere compliments) were presented in audio-only, visual-only, and audio-visual conditions. A two-alternative forced-choice task was adopted to measure the listeners’ interpretation of ironic expressions. ResultsIronic criticisms and ironic compliments were interpreted best in the visual-only condition as compared to the other conditions. Furthermore, the participants could employ auditory cues alone to accurately interpret ironic criticisms (accuracy significantly above chance), but not ironic compliments. ConclusionsThis study demonstrated a dominant role of visual information in interpreting Mandarin ironic speech, while the role of auditory information is contingent on the type of irony.

Integrating Visual Information into the Auditory Cortex Promotes Sound Discrimination through Choice-Related Multisensory Integration.

An increasing number of studies have shown that cross-modal interaction can occur in early sensory cortices. Yet, how neurons in sensory cortices integrate multisensory cues in perceptual tasks and to what extent this influences behavior is largely unclear. To investigate, we examined visual modulation of auditory responses in the primary auditory cortex (A1) in a two-alternative forced-choice task. During the task, male rats were required to make a behavioral choice based on the pure tone frequency (low vs high) of the self-triggered stimulus to get a water reward. The result showed that the presence of a noninformative visual cue did not uniformly influence auditory response, with frequently enhancing just one of them. Closely correlated with behavioral choice, the visual cue mainly enhanced responsiveness to the auditory cue indicating a movement direction contralateral to A1 being recorded. Operating in this fashion provided A1 neurons a superior capability to discriminate sound during multisensory trials. Concomitantly, behavioral data and decoding analysis revealed that visual cue presence could speed the process of sound discrimination. We also observed this differential multisensory integration effect in well-trained rats when tested with passive stimulation and under anesthesia, albeit to a much lesser extent. We did not see this differentially integrative effect while recording in A1 in another similar group of rats performing a free-choice task. These data suggest that auditory cortex can engage in meaningful audiovisual processing, and perceptual learning can modify its multisensory integration mechanism to meet task requirements.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT In the natural environment, visual stimuli are frequently accompanied by auditory cues. Although multisensory integration has traditionally been seen as a feature of associational cortices, recent studies have shown that cross-modal inputs can also influence neuronal activity in primary sensory cortices. However, exactly how neurons in sensory cortices integrate multisensory cues to guide behavioral choice is still unclear. Here, we describe a novel model of multisensory integration used by A1 neurons to shape auditory representations when rats performed a cue-guided task. We found that a task-irrelevant visual cue could specifically enhance the response of neurons in sound guiding to the contralateral choice. This differentially integrative model facilitated sound discrimination and behavioral choice. This result indicates that task engagement can modulate multisensory integration.

Modeling Distraction: How Stimulus-driven Attention Capture Influences Goal-directed Behavior.

The importance of paying attention to a task at hand is emphasized from an early age and extends throughout life. The costs of attentional focus, however, include the potential to miss important changes in the environment, so some process for monitoring nontask information is essential. In this study, a model of latent cognitive variables was applied to data obtained from a two-alternative forced-choice task where participants identified the longer of two sounds. Using an adaptive procedure task, accuracy was maintained at a higher or lower level creating two difficulties, and the sounds were heard either where frequency changes in the sound were rare or common (oddball and multistandard conditions, respectively). Frequency changes created stimulus-driven "distraction" effects in the oddball sequence only, and cognitive modeling (using the linear ballistic accumulator) attributed these effects to slowed accumulation of evidence about tone length on these trials. Concurrent recording of auditory ERPs revealed these delays in evidence accumulation to be related to the amplitude of N2 or mismatch negativity period and P300 response components. In contrast, the response time on trials after a rare frequency change was associated with increased caution in decision-making. Results support the utility of mapping behavioral and ERP measures of performance to latent cognitive processes that contribute to performance and are consistent with a momentary diversion of resources to evaluate the deviant sound feature and remodel predictions about sound.

Visual Perception of Photographs of Rotated 3D Objects in Goldfish (Carassius auratus)

Simple SummaryThe ability to visually recognize objects at different viewpoints is known as object constancy and is very important to animals, including humans. By presenting six goldfish with photographs of plastic turtles and frogs at different viewing angles, we were able to better understand object constancy abilities in goldfish. All the fish had successful performance, showing that they were able to distinguish between the turtle and frog photographs, which is evidence of object constancy. This study was the first to look at fish’s ability to identify photographs of objects they had previously seen, known as object-picture recognition.This study examined goldfishes’ ability to recognize photographs of rotated 3D objects. Six goldfish were presented with color photographs of a plastic model turtle and frog at 0° in a two-alternative forced-choice task. Fish were tested with stimuli at 0°, 90°, 180°, and 270° rotated in the picture plane and two depth planes. All six fish performed significantly above chance at all orientations in the three rotation planes tested. There was no significant difference in performance as a function of aspect angle, which supported viewpoint independence. However, fish were significantly faster at 180° than at +/−90°, so there is also evidence for viewpoint-dependent representations. These fish subjects performed worse overall in the current study with 2D color photographs (M = 88.0%) than they did in our previous study with 3D versions of the same turtle and frog stimuli (M = 92.6%), although they performed significantly better than goldfish in our two past studies presented with black and white 2D stimuli (M = 67.6% and 69.0%). The fish may have relied on color as a salient cue. This study was a first attempt at examining picture-object recognition in fish. More work is needed to determine the conditions under which fish succeed at object constancy tasks, as well as whether they are capable of perceiving photographs as representations of real-world objects.